Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Last year, accessory company Alogic launched its 27-inch "Clarity" display, offering a 4K experience with 90 watts of power delivery to charge a connected computer, an array of connectivity options, and hub functionality for connecting peripheral devices.

alogic-clarity-pro-displays.jpg
 
No miniLED, no OLED? HDR400 seems like table stakes. I mean money is money but once you've seen the latest LG-panel OLED TVs and the M-series MacBook Pros with 1600-nit (HDR) displays, it's kind of hard to buy anything else. I'll save up and wait if I have to. (The Apple Studio Display suffers from this same problem.)
 
The vast majority of 4K monitor panels are 60Hz until you get to TV sized units. Looks like they don’t put HDMI 2.1 on many units below 43”
There's actually a few options if you don't want to stash a monster TV on your desk. I just recently purchased a Mac Studio M2 Max (base config; I added a pair of NVME 2 TB drives externally via USB-C and a Belkin USB-C hub) and had been shopping around for monitors for a bit as I was upgrading from a 2012 iMac (Quad i7 with Nvidia Graphics and 32 Gig RAM). This was my first non-AIO Mac in awhile so I had to bite the bullet and drop a lot of $ all at once. I've generally preferred non-AIO machines but with the nature of where Apple has gone with the M# chips, the fact that there's 0 upgradability inside the Studio really made a 32" iMac begin to make more sense to me but... without an option and having waited as long as I have? It was time to bite the bullet.

I will say that finding a monitor with nice build quality with respectable specs has a rather limited pool. I mean, after coming from a 27" iMac (granted, it was only 1440p but... it was a VERY nice 1440p panel that still rivals a lot of 1440p 60Hz screens today) it wasn't as easy to find a really nice industrial designed monitor that was Apple-like in quality. I didn't want a plasticky LG or Samsung or MSI or something of that nature. The similar spec Dell (IPS Black) had worse #'s in color accuracy (you'd actually need an even more expensive calibrator to get it to better match the Corsair and ViewSonic options) and it cost more with speakers and the webcam (around $1,300) for the 4K version. The 6K is even more expensive (though a rather unique offering).

I narrowed mine down to the Corsair Xeneon 32" 4k option and the fairly similar ViewSonic Elite 32" 4K display. Both have rather nice aluminum stands (they're not Apple aesthetic designs but they're still elegant in their own way). The Xeneon has dual HDMI 2.1 ports (though I have mine hooked up via USB-C/Thunderbolt to take advantage of using iCue for controls) whereas the ViewSonic only has 1 HDMI 2.1 and one standard fare 2.0 port. Both can run at 144hz (faster than the Alogic monitor). Both basically have a built-in KVM so you can actually use them with multiple machines using one keyboard and mouse (assuming you don't have your mouse set as Bluetooth -- I've got an older WASD Code [eventually will likely upgrade to a Keychron] and a Mac version of the Logitech MX Master -- regret not buying the PC version as it didn't come with the 2.4 Ghz dongle that the PC version comes with). Eventually I'll buy the dongle (as I'm thinking of hooking up a PC and/or older Mac to one of the video ports) but it's kind of ridiculous as the Mac version of the mouse actually costs exactly the same but omits the dongle (though it still supports it). I love the mouse but... yeah, trying to support a Mac-specific version bit me in the butt. LoL. Thanks Logitech!

The Xeneon lacks a webcam (it has a mount though you can mount various camera options on - with Corsair buying Elgato the monitor is actually positioned towards gamers and creators and there's a ton of accessories you can buy to help with streaming) and speakers.

The ViewSonic comes with speakers, no cam though.

I will say you can opt to go with a humongous 4K OLED TV but I don't really need a 40+ monitor on my desk. I find that 27-32" is the sweet spot for me and my needs and in reality... that's where the OLED options don't really fall. Sure you can get better contrast overall with an OLED... but you're not buying an OLED 4K monitor at 32" for less than like $2k. Because of the volume sales of TV's... 40"+ OLED's are available in the $1k range if not cheaper. So keep in mind at the moment if you buy a monitor you're going to pay a premium in this space.

The only real options in OLED's on the desktop are 1440p and not 4K displays. Examples that come to mind are Samsung and Alienware's QD-OLED ultra wides (highly recommend the Alienware even if it loses Tizen in the process, it at least doesn't come with fragile micro sized ports for DisplayPort and HDMI). That said, I will say that macOS on a 4k panel that isn't Apple supplied (i.e. their 5k Studio option as an example) isn't quite as nice as it could be. Every icon on screen and the menubar are absolutely tiny and the options to fix it are frustrating to say the least. This is one area I hope Apple improves as when you buy a 4K display you'd love to operate at 4K and not have everything need to be altered on an incremental basis to display nicely on a higher resolution display that you in the end cut down to a smaller resolution by default.

As far as those questioning why you'd pay the costs of the Alogic (or similar pricing for the Corsair and ViewSonic Elite options)? It's pretty simple. If you do any level of design work you'd want a display that's an IPS (or IPS Black) panel with high levels of DCI-P3, sRGB and AdobeRGB accuracy. Both the ViewSonic and Corsair are considered reference-level displays in terms of out of the box accuracy. I'm not sure on the Alogic but it sounds like it's similar specs in terms of panel to both of the Corsair and ViewSonic panels and a few other displays in the market (I'm guessing they might all be 4K panels sourced from LG). The fact that all of the aforementioned Corsair, ViewSonic and Alogic monitors are Quantum Dot with HDR400? Sounds pretty similar. Shocked though that the Alogic doesn't drive more than 60Hz? That's a pretty big downer for the price. I'm running at 144Hz as we speak.

I'm pretty happy with the Corsair FWIW. iCue is still coming along in terms of build but so far it's pretty full-featured. It does have issues with not using the media keys for brightness like the Alogic ran into in the MacRumors review above. Hopefully Corsair can do some upgrades eventually that allow it to tap into those keys. They've been pretty good so far with firmware and software updates (just had an update I installed a few minutes ago).
 
they're really useful for consuming XXX content
this was my first thought as well.

suddenly need to not have tabs of pr0n on your screen while your trying to get lube off your hand and pull your pants up?

with a quick gesture you can switch desktops and focus on getting the frank and beans tucked away.

i'm a single guy who never bothers to clear my browsing history, even in relationships, but its pretty clear to me how helpful this would be for guys with kids, who live with their parents, with insecure / disapproving wives, etc.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: TheGenerous
I’m curious about running a 4K panel at 1440p effective resolution: is there still a performance hit for that?

I remember in the early days of retina that using a scaling factor that wasn’t either 1:1 or 2:1 would noticeably decrease performance. I’m curious whether that’s no longer true, or if it’s just that GPU performance even at the low end is good enough it doesn’t matter.
 
There's actually a few options if you don't want to stash a monster TV on your desk. I just recently purchased a Mac Studio M2 Max (base config; I added a pair of NVME 2 TB drives externally via USB-C and a Belkin USB-C hub) …
I want to hear more about your 2TB NVME drives.
 
Seems like a lot of money ($800) for a USB-C hub monitor and $200 additional for a webcam? OUCH.

Dell P2723QE 4K USB-C hub monitor at their Outlet for $240 after discount. Or $480 new. Same ports. Great monitor.
How do you get the $240 discounted price? Here is the Outlet page:
 
  • Like
Reactions: nerdherdster
All those touchscreen AIO Windows desktop PCs that launched with Windows 8 disappeared as quickly from the market as they appeared - for good reason.

The ergonomics are terrible (really fatiguing on your arm) and fingerprints on your screen is gross.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.