Sorry guys, totally forgot to take a picture before boxing it up and sending it back. I'm sorry to hear that somebody else experienced this as well, Rhinoshield cases have been my favorite, go to cases since the first crashguard and this fit issue on the mod surprised me.
To try to describe it in words a bit more, at the bottom at the charge port the case bowed out enough that you could push it back probably about a 1/16 of an inch. I know that doesn't sound like much but I'm used to the near-perfect fit of the playproof and crashguard. You could see AND feel the looseness.
As for the buttons, only the volume up button had a nice, "clickable" feel to it, the volume down button and especially the power button were mushy.
I may give it a second chance and see what the black friday sale is like and buy another one. The return process is relatively easy, BUT....make sure you take a picture of the case and the box and any accessories you get as soon as they arrive because in order to return an item you need AT LEAST 2 pictures of the item "in an unused or near new" state. You also need to pay for return shipping.
To help others decide on this or not, it's not especially grippy but it isn't terrible. It's nearly the same as my crashguard but because of the rounder counter it's a little easier to grip than the crash. It's wider than the playproof but not quite as wide as the crashguard.