@insomniac86 @Bistroengine No, it's not the first tracker ever. But the iPhone wasn't the first smartphone ever, either. This will be bigger in scale and easier to use than anything that came before, so privacy concerns will also be bigger than up until now. Of course GPS trackers already exist, but they're not a big thing. AirTags will be a big thing.
Also, of course you can only locate tags with your personal iCloud account. But that doesn't stop me from putting my tag in my girlfriend's bag. Those kind of things will happen, and those are things people would not have even thought about doing before AirTags existed.
The large scale and ease of use will make it unethical. Is that really such a weird point to make?
While is see your main point, that these will be way more popular, and I still think it’s a moot point.
Will there be some abuse using an AirTag? Sure, but it could have also been done via a million other ways just as easy.
I think you are giving far to much credit for how simple Apple’s version will be to use compared to other products. Other products are two button presses and setup. Tile is literally download app, click add device, Done. The difference with Tile is that they will have a much smaller discovery network, compared to Apple. But again, if the tech changes from Bluetooth to something else, like GPS, then the network isn’t important.
I believe we have seen in the code a solution to your “drop one in your gfs bag problem” Apparently it will report when a tag has been following you that isn’t yours.
Also you could just add your gfs account to your current find my app. If she doesn’t use it, she would probably have no idea that she’s sharing her location with you.
What’s to stop that problem? That has existed for years.
Same thing with Snapchat, Facebook messenger etc . All can be set to permanently share your location.
Apples Family Sharing wants to share everyone’s location too. And more on that....I can also assure you that majority of families still share a single Apple ID to the AppStore purchase (instead of using family sharing). What does this mean? It means that the family members know the account password. This means that at the very least everyone in that family can sign into Find My and see the location of the account owners personal devices.
In regards to the “Find My via Apple ID’s”
Personally my view is that a parent has a right to know the location of their “child”. And a a husband and wife shouldn’t have an issue with sharing their location already, without needing an “AirTag”.
I get it with bf and gfs, but I mean, if you’re gonna be a creepy dude and secretly track your gf via an AirTag, you’re just as likely to do it via another “just as easy” way that’s probably cheaper too.
Maybe you will be right, and all of a sudden every “normal” person will turn into a stalker overnight with the release of AirTags.
But then if everyone’s tracking everyone, there’s nothing to hide. Lol.
IDK, maybe I’m giving humans too much credit.