Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The milk finally expired

timcook.jpg
 
Haha I used Apple Music when it was in beta still and had no issues. But good luck!

I currently use Google Play on my iPhone but only because it was .99 for 3 months and came with YouTube red as well. After I'm probably going to subscribe to Apple Music

I wish tidal wasn't so expensive I'd like to try it with the higher quality. But love apple smart playlist and still think itunes is a pretty good player for sorting and organizing. Hope the ios/android apps gets more of the itunes features. Like give us the itunes view in landscape mode on the larger ios devices? Let us build smart lists in ios. Even better a web based itunes. Dreaming.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mthomas184
"Samsung is shuttering its Milk Music Service in the United States."

So "shuttering" means shutting down? How about that!
 
Wow, I can sort of see why they're dumping the service; I'd never even heard of it.

Perhaps I might have heard of it had I owned a Samsung phone...

My thought exactly. And what a weird name for it.


In the meantime, I buy and own my music.


I agree with just buying music outright; streaming screws over the artist more than ever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JamesPDX
First time I've read the word shuttering used in that context.

Second, is that the Samsung Music logo? Absolute imitation gone wrong.
 
I agree with just buying music outright; streaming screws over the artist more than ever.

I dunno... prior to July 2011, I did not pay for music at all. I "acquired" by other means... then Spotify came to the USA and the industry started getting $10 per month out of me. Since Apple Music came out, they now get $15 per month out of me. Seems like the artists got screwed more BEFORE streaming existed.
 
So closing down a company or a service is now called "sun setting"?

Nice euphemism. Just when I thought corporate lingo couldn't get any dumber. The employees who get fired are then "riding into the sunset", I assume?
 
I agree with just buying music outright; streaming screws over the artist more than ever.

In my mind there are two kinds of songs you'd have in your library: A song that sounds good straight away, but fades are a few listens, and a song that sounds okay initially but grows on you. It's kind of like: X-Factor Winner vs All Time Low... one is a flash in the pan, the other has a fan base which has grown over time, organically and will last much longer.

If I buy all my music, then I'm spending money on two songs like they're equal, when they're not. With streaming, the better the song, the more money the artist earns from each user.
 
Milk Music just uses Slacker Radio library anyway which sucks. Slacker Radio sucks I had it for months but hearing the same songs, many karaoke versions and annoying live tracks made me cancel. Even Play Music has annoying karaoke versions of certain songs which AM actually has the studio versions. Really loving Apple Music which is my only service I am keeping out of all of them.
 
I heard about Milk Music when it was originally launched several year ago. After that, I didn't hear a peep from it. So it makes complete sense that Samsung is shutting it down since it had zero impact.
 
Apple Music on my Nexus 6 is typically great, with an occasional hiccup here and there.

The only things I miss are that you can't use the 5 star ratings in the Android version and google now voice assistant still doesn't recognize apple music to use voice commands. On a better note it connects to my car bluetooth better than my iphone did.
 
Milk Music? WTF kind of a name is that?

Reportedly they named it that because it was "fresh and organic".

Huh. I think it might be a cultural thing that has more meaning to Koreans.

Reminds me of back while intercepting North Korean military comms decades ago, we suddenly heard them using a new term every time they established contact with each other:

"The mother's milk is good."

Weird! Was it some kind of special code?? After asking some South Koreans what they thought it meant, we quickly figured out that it was simply the slang equivalent of our own, "I hear you five by five."

No doubt some of our own American product name choices also don't make sense overseas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HiRez
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.