Body was scratched up, screen was fine. I'm jokingly saying i replaced it only because of the wear, but that's not true. I bought the watch on eBay for like $200 and it was giving me some problems with battery, so I go to my Apple Store and they run their diagnostic, and turns out it's got an ambient light sensor going haywire causing the screen to remain at 100% brightness all day. They replaced it.Wait what? Was the body scratched or the screen? Did you have AppleCare+?
Because usually this sort of thing is „normal wear“ and no reason for a replacement.
Yes, it had AppleCare+. That expired today.