Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I really wish people would stop referencing that poll as if it had any meaning. Don't get me wrong, EA have their issues (to put it mildly) but... it's an Internet poll. Whoever happens to have the ire of the geek community at that point in time is going to get slaughtered. Or are we really saying that always-on DRM is worse than, say, the effects Bank Of America has on people's lives?

Actually decided to put money down on SimCity last night thanks to a good offer price. The always-on DRM annoys me but it's not a deal breaker, the limitations of the simulation are well known but don't necessarily make it a bad game. Frankly at this point in my life I'm not looking for something to sink hundreds of hours into managing a thousand minor details. A simpler sim is appealing at the moment where I can throw a few hours at it here and there and just have fun. I can understand why others may think otherwise though and fair play if you do.

Ok that's fine if you want a simple to play game. That is what this Simcity is, and therefore it should cost about $10 or less. Also, the true draw of Simcity is how expansive you COULD make a city, or you could make a small village if you want and just let it thrive. But with this you can't make anything but a town, and that blows for most people, even if they didn't even want to make a huge metropolis.

Big city management is what really gave Simcity that extra zing. Now it's just extra ztupid
 
I downloaded the PC version after I was tired of waiting and, more importantly, found out about the cross-platform thing. I have a $250 Windows 7 notebook, and it does actually kinda run the game -- as much as you can run a game on a notebook with a Celeron (I know!) processor. I lucked out and got 4GB of RAM, which was the minimum required.

It's pretty awesome, although it does have a few flaws. Some stuff I just never understand, like why homes will whine about a ferry or airport and then some advisor tells me I don't have enough tourists for one. I also don't like that my hourly income number at the bottom of the screen doesn't calculate the deals for selling power or materials such as plastic and metal. It'll say -$15,000/hour yet I keep banking because I'm selling alloy and processors.

So yeah, it has glitches. But it's pretty fun. Hopefully EA will support it with some DLC other than landmarks. I think the "small" city sizes are fine if the sims would go to the damn university in the next town instead of always begging for one.
 
Just bought the game on gamefly for 35$. Then redeem the code in origin and upgrade to deluxe version with the villians set and other paid dlc for 20$. Comes out lower than what they are pushing us for normal version.
 
Hmm okay. Well I haven't played SimCity since SC3000 which if I recall came out in the late 90's. I was just looking forward to playing a new version. So you can only build cities online? There's no offline option? And what does RCI mean?

RCI = residential commercial industrial balance.
 
I downloaded the PC version after I was tired of waiting and, more importantly, found out about the cross-platform thing. I have a $250 Windows 7 notebook, and it does actually kinda run the game -- as much as you can run a game on a notebook with a Celeron (I know!) processor. I lucked out and got 4GB of RAM, which was the minimum required.

Since they have now confirmed you get both Windows and OS X versions for the one price, now I'm wondering about getting the Windows version now and running it in my existing Parallels/Windows 7 VM. If it doesn't run well enough to be playable, I'll have lost nothing compared to waiting for the native OS X version.
 
SimCity 5 is shockingly bad in comparison to 4. I thought games were meant to get better with every new version. All EA have done is remove features and added a load of online nonsense that is supposed to equate to 'having fun'.

Do like the poo map though.
 
I think people also forgot how bad simcity societies was, however i am huge fan and will give it a try. Besides it comes out a day after my birthday, so how can i resist.
 
Great game, ignore the haters whining about DRM. The online part of it is great.
 
NO to on-line requirements for software.

No thanks to always on-line. I travel a lot, and it is pointless to own a game you can't play in flight, or at a remote location with no internet, including if my kids wanted to play it on a laptop during our regular long drives. This is a trend in games that I feel consumers should make economically distasteful to the developers (if it is required - the game is a sales flop). If we buy the game, we are saying it is acceptable, and the trend will only continue to expand. I can't imagine anyone would accept this requirement for Office, Photoshop, FCP, or many other software titles. Yet people say this is OK for their leisure gaming?
 
My .02 cents:

Yes the game has its share of problems. Yes it could have been better. That said, it's still a fun game and frankly I'd be playing it daily if it didn't mean I had to reboot into Windows. Can't wait for the Mac version. By then hopefully the lions share of bugs will be fixed.
 
I refuse to purchase any EA game including console versions, until they are back on Steam. How dare they tell me where I can and can't shop for their crappy products. :mad:
 
Until there is an offline version, this is an absolutely awful creation not worthy of my dollars. So much cool gameplay wasted by DRM.
 
This whole debacle makes me so angry. :mad:

I've loved Sim City since the original. I used to go over to a friend's house and play it on his PC (we didn't have one yet). I never really got into 4, but was excited to see what 5 would bring.

Little did I know they were planning to ruin it. They lost a guaranteed sale with the BS, and obviously I'm not alone. I just want to play it on my own. I don't want a social game. I wanted Sim City.

I've heard of some of the alternatives, but Cities XL isn't available for Macs as far as I'm aware. Tropico might be, but I haven't looked into it yet.
 
No thanks to always on-line. I travel a lot, and it is pointless to own a game you can't play in flight, or at a remote location with no internet, including if my kids wanted to play it on a laptop during our regular long drives. This is a trend in games that I feel consumers should make economically distasteful to the developers (if it is required - the game is a sales flop). If we buy the game, we are saying it is acceptable, and the trend will only continue to expand. I can't imagine anyone would accept this requirement for Office, Photoshop, FCP, or many other software titles. Yet people say this is OK for their leisure gaming?

It's funny that you mention Photoshop, as I know a lot of pro photographers (i.e. people that do serious commercial and art photography for a living) that do a lot of editing on their laptops while flying form gig to gig and if Photoshop was only online, Adobe would lose their business.
 
Since they have now confirmed you get both Windows and OS X versions for the one price, now I'm wondering about getting the Windows version now and running it in my existing Parallels/Windows 7 VM. If it doesn't run well enough to be playable, I'll have lost nothing compared to waiting for the native OS X version.

Had this been broadcast to us from the beginning, I could've ended up with a free darn game. But I ended up not learning that until about 3 days too late. I was watching IGN's videos with an editor playing SimCity for 10 minutes a day. I got to the point where I was looking up how much Windows 7 would be to run using Boot Camp, but then I remembered that Microsoft is stupid and charges like $200 for an OS. I don't get that considering the notebook I bought was $250 brand new. Yes, on sale, but it was $400 regularly. Is Windows really half the cost of a computer or does Microsoft hose people? (yes)
 
People are seriously paying 60 USD for a game? I mean, I never played any games (or at least I never paid for one), I wasn't aware that they are so expensive. I can't imagine spending that much money on a game.

I paid 80 for BlackOPS 2
 
Dammit. Gamefly deal is gone. Since I won't be able to play until June 11 I'm waiting for better deals.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.