It can only tell you about products it sells on amazon. The Google home will do a web search.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Siri on HomePod Asked 800 Questions and Answered 74% Correctly vs. Just 52% Earlier This Year
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
And yet I still cant get Siri to schedule a calendar appointment properly
I don’t ever use Siri on my HomePod because it’s so much easier to start with Apple TV or iPhone, pick what I want, and change the output to HomePod. Normally I listen to an artist on shuffle and if you ask Siri it will play from the Apple Music catalog and not my library. It makes the voice command useless to me. Wish there was a toggle to only play what’s in my library.
Happy to see improvement, although I only use my HomePod's for commands and music, which it works perfectly for. I've been really happy with mine and enjoy using them daily.
It does although there have been a few times when it’s not been able to answer some basic questions like converting between different time zones. However for the most part it does what I need and I know apple will continue to improve it with updates.
I just don't understand why there aren't third-party apps for HomePod yet. I'd buy an interactive story game thing, or Duolingo... there are tons of possibilities given the quality of the hardware in the device already.
Does Apple even believe this propaganda?
Come on. Siri can’t process a fraction of what the google assistant can do. Sure Siri can play music when you ask but that’s really it. It’s still very basic compared to other virtual assistants.
Come on. Siri can’t process a fraction of what the google assistant can do. Sure Siri can play music when you ask but that’s really it. It’s still very basic compared to other virtual assistants.
Honestly I have to admit I have a love-hate relationship with my HomePod. Sometimes it works really well and responds quickly, other times I can't even change the volume, I just get "the volume of this speaker can't be changed right now, please try later" as an answer, and that is utterly useless.....
Also the weather is useless, you can ask it if it will rain, but you can't ask at what times (this is easy information to give, its given in the iPhone app)
Also the weather is useless, you can ask it if it will rain, but you can't ask at what times (this is easy information to give, its given in the iPhone app)
You cannot equate smart assistance with keyboards or music. They're not even remotely comparable. A more appropriate comparison would be using only autocomplete to write a sentence, or getting a piece of software to recognise a tune from you simply humming it.
EDIT: Thinking about it, what was the failure rate of early typewriters, and what percent quality of the original recording was audible on original gramophones? Hmmm.
The trouble with smart assistants is they have to understand the question, understand the context - and then get it right first time - which is the hard part.
How often do you use search engines, and how often is the result you want the first link? In my case at least, rarely.
The point is it's not perfect, but it is getting there. Give it some time.
[doublepost=1545319574][/doublepost]
Try looking up 'Skyrim Very Special Edition'
Last edited:
That’s my thinking. I have 2 Homepods that do everything I want/need—but sound terrific as stereo. I bought one Echo because of price and that it now streams Apple Music and use it only in the BR for music for bedtime reading with a sleep timer. I purposely did not give it access to my contacts or phone number and won’t use it for ordering anything-or any of the stranger requests/skills.
Afaik, these were general information questions in different general categories. What does Apple's privacy stance have to do with any of that? Privacy can't be used as a crutch for every Siri shortcoming. Apple is working to improve Siri's accuracy. That's a good thing. The irony is Siri did the best in the category that actually required some private information. Privacy isn't hindrance in this instance.
May not be helpful to you but I found by putting music I wanted played together in named playlists that I can remember means it plays that precise music—from my library. But LOL—at times I need to refresh my memory by looking at my library on phone or Ipad—because the name has to be correct for Siri to find it.
It just came out. I believe the Echo came out in 2013? Maybe 2014. It takes time.
Just skimmed over the article and a lot of them are hindered by privacy, such as access to their messages, phone book, phone records, location data of you and family members, and also access to order anything from Amazon.
"Hey Siri, set a timer for 1 minute".........."Hey Siri, set a timer for 400 minutes" ............... "Hey Siri, set a timer for 800 minutes"
you can install it on your iPhone. though I don't believe it responds to "ok google" and you need to manually launch the app
Wonder if you are using Car Play because then mine appears to be open once I connect by cable. I can’t remember if I’ve asked for a certain podcast to be played but I often send and receive messages, play music, listen to TuneIn. I know in my husband’s Subaru without Car Play I actually do have to open my phone first though (as a passenger)-don’t remember when I am driving but then I don’t use Siri in that car because its more an interaction between me and phone and that seems awkward-never seems to work correctly.
So three out of 10 questions are answered wrong. That's still horrible enough to never trust it.
I feel like the issue with these devices is we're taking a completely incorrect approach to designing the UX.
The current approach seems to be to make a ridiculously gimped command line that has no "help", "man", "find", "grep", pipes, or variables.
I think a way better approach would be to take an apps approach, like a smartphone.
Me: "What were we talking about?"
Device: "We weren't talking about anything. What app would you like to launch?"
Me: "Oh, right. What apps do I have installed?"
Device: "Currently installed are weather, stocks, messages, phone..."
Me *cutting off*: "Open messages. Who texted me last?"
... so on...
Me: "Close apps" or "Goodnight" or "Goodbye" or something along those lines.
These AIs suck for general purpose. They need context and we need context. They need to be able to contextually tell us what our options are. They need to prompt us about what they can do. Apps can provide that context.
The current approach seems to be to make a ridiculously gimped command line that has no "help", "man", "find", "grep", pipes, or variables.
I think a way better approach would be to take an apps approach, like a smartphone.
Me: "What were we talking about?"
Device: "We weren't talking about anything. What app would you like to launch?"
Me: "Oh, right. What apps do I have installed?"
Device: "Currently installed are weather, stocks, messages, phone..."
Me *cutting off*: "Open messages. Who texted me last?"
... so on...
Me: "Close apps" or "Goodnight" or "Goodbye" or something along those lines.
These AIs suck for general purpose. They need context and we need context. They need to be able to contextually tell us what our options are. They need to prompt us about what they can do. Apps can provide that context.