Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Music literally destroyed my interest in music. And the worst part is I still use it. But every album or song I add to this day, is seemingly gone a few months later.
 
Exactly this.

I was burned by Apple Music in the transition from iTunes to Apple Music — my carefully curated music library literally — yes, literally — destroyed.

An 800GB+ music library that had been carefully sorted in albums and playlists. Mangled.
partial albums uploaded. Lossless files replaced by lossy.
Cover artwork? Pffft. Mixed and matched… missing.
Artists mixed up and ignored.

Broke my heart.

Unless there is a major rebuild from the foundations up, I will never be tempted to again.

Why other services could achieve it and the giant Apple cannot is a mystery.

And yet, how often do we hear that Apple really cares about music. "It is in our DNA" they say… yeah sure.
Your story just cements my determination to never touch Apple Music under any circumstances. Or even streaming service for that matter. Certainly Apple does NOT care about music no matter what their official statement says. Actions speak lower than words, as it always does.
 
I just joined to confirm it's fixed, finally some proper syncing across devices. However, I also want to emphasize that the user base of Apple was the iPod users (Music) for a long time. And it's even more frustrating if this got fixed just because this has popped up on Macrumors. This issue has been there for a while. While I deeply thank Macrumors for giving exposure to the issue, I also want to condemn Apple for taking this into priority/speeding the release once the exposure has happened...
 
Exactly this.

I was burned by Apple Music in the transition from iTunes to Apple Music — my carefully curated music library literally — yes, literally — destroyed.

An 800GB+ music library that had been carefully sorted in albums and playlists. Mangled.
partial albums uploaded. Lossless files replaced by lossy.
Cover artwork? Pffft. Mixed and matched… missing.
Artists mixed up and ignored.

Broke my heart.

Unless there is a major rebuild from the foundations up, I will never be tempted to again.

Why other services could achieve it and the giant Apple cannot is a mystery.

And yet, how often do we hear that Apple really cares about music. "It is in our DNA" they say… yeah sure.
Sounds like a user problem. Never had major issues
 
Sounds like a user problem. Never had major issues
Oh dear…

I'll ask you to go cast off the blinkers, and point you to the discussions years ago when the transition from iTunes to iTunes Match or Apple Music Match or whatever flavour of the day Apple wanted to call it happened.

No, not user error… just one of the many unfortunate enough to be ****ed over by Apple.

Anyway, I could go on… but instead I'll wave you goodbye and wish you a nice day.

Cheers.
 
I just joined to confirm it's fixed, finally some proper syncing across devices. However, I also want to emphasize that the user base of Apple was the iPod users (Music) for a long time. And it's even more frustrating if this got fixed just because this has popped up on Macrumors. This issue has been there for a while. While I deeply thank Macrumors for giving exposure to the issue, I also want to condemn Apple for taking this into priority/speeding the release once the exposure has happened...

Unfortunately still not syncing on my new Mac mini.
Of course, tried signing out, deleting the local library & restarting - still refuses to sync, for weeks now :(
Very frustrating.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SantaFeNM
How is this a news story? Apple Music, iTunes, library syncing, artwork dropping, track name changes, etc have been an issue for years. The biggest POS Apple has produced and quite an embarrassment as a 14 year old programmer could create this. I have had so many issues (still do) that I gave up on anything useful with it.
This is an important news story. I can't sync between Mac, iPad and iPhone. I can't sync my owned music to my iPhone or iPad. I really appreciate that MR is lobbying on our behalf.
The only reason I've stuck with Apple Music is Apple Music Classical. Otherwise I'd just be with Spotify.
 
  • Like
Reactions: arkitect
I just joined to confirm it's fixed, finally some proper syncing across devices. However, I also want to emphasize that the user base of Apple was the iPod users (Music) for a long time. And it's even more frustrating if this got fixed just because this has popped up on Macrumors. This issue has been there for a while. While I deeply thank Macrumors for giving exposure to the issue, I also want to condemn Apple for taking this into priority/speeding the release once the exposure has happened...
How recently was this fixed for you?
 
I still have this 'Genius results can’t be updated right now. An unknown error occurred 18004' issue. It's really annoying.
 
Been using iTunes forever, and am an iTunes Match/Apple Music subscriber. The only real problem I have is that when I add new music to the library by dragging it into a playlist they get removed and I have to add them back in.

Music syncs fine between two Macs, my iPhone and iPad.

To be honest, I'm not sure what iTunes Match does for me anymore. At some point I legalized all my mp3s via match, but I think it's the same as Apple Music sync...but more reliable?

52,000 songs, 465GB.
I buy a lot of my music on BandCamp, a lot of times some vinyl records with the accompanied downloads that then get added into the Music app and synced with Match. A lot of music I like just isn't on Apple Music at all, so being able to at least upload music is great. That makes it easier for me to add the music for the band I'm in, too.


Screenshot 2024-01-05 at 6.20.30 AM.png
 
its broken again. Well it was a great 10 hours I guess
 

Attachments

  • Bildschirmfoto 2024-01-05 um 13.46.47.png
    Bildschirmfoto 2024-01-05 um 13.46.47.png
    32.9 KB · Views: 63
No matter what, I still believe in Apple Music and I have slowly been noticing it getting improved.
That said the core experience is still too glitchy.
Music is already feature-packed, what it needs to truly shine is a little polish and an increase in performance.
I'd also like apple to invest in automatic playlists; the "Discovery Station" was a great step in the right direction (I discovered so much amazing music), but more needs to be done.
Hopefully by the end of this year Apple Music will have become an actual competitori to Spotify.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AhRiHmAn
We have AppleOne family sharing enabled and Homepods which are shared too.
I can't play my any Music playlist on any HomePod (Hey Siri, play my playlist XY), because i am only a family member but not the owner in Homekit.
This is so stupid!
 
My brother has a huge iTunes library and tons of playlists. He's afraid to upgrade from high sierra to newer macOS because he's not familiar with the new music app. After reading some of the horror stories I think his fears are well founded. :rolleyes:
 
My 60GB library and playlists got borked by Apple Music last year. It's still sitting on my drive, waiting for a long meeting for me to dive in and start re-organizing it.

But once again, this underscores my belief that Cupertino can't run a stable cloud service to save its life.....it's like the more built-in, cute, or proprietary it becomes, the worse and/or more unreliable it gets.

The only thing I use iCloud for is iPhone backups and Messages (but even that's wonky at times). Otherwise, I won't sync ANYTHING through/with Apple.
1) too had a run of issues with iCloud and syncing. Long long ago, when I had multiple systems and before I bought into iCloud, I had iCloud turned off on all devices. Then a replacement iPhone slipped in with iCloud enabled, I decided to play with it, and a couple of devices were brought online, merged, and synced. All was well. Until I turned on one of the older systems and updated it. New features defaulted to iCloud, but existing configured items did not. This resulted in a host of issues with iCloud and syncing that took a cycle of disabling iCloud on everything and re-enabling it. (FWIW, this means de-registering Find My also) A painful process, but once completed and confirmed that iCloud had no devices nor data and then re-enabling the devices, everything started working pretty well.

2) Music, first thing - disable managing my music. Second - make a backup (Actually, this should be step 0 and 2). Third, point your Music app to your local library. All should be well after that, although I personally do not like how Music deals with personal libraries, cloud libraries, and playlists. I have well over 10K lossless ripped songs in my personal library store, so I made darn sure that it didn't get destroyed by iTunes/Music, and I always keep a backup.
 
No matter what, I still believe in Apple Music and I have slowly been noticing it getting improved.
That said the core experience is still too glitchy.
Music is already feature-packed, what it needs to truly shine is a little polish and an increase in performance.
I'd also like apple to invest in automatic playlists; the "Discovery Station" was a great step in the right direction (I discovered so much amazing music), but more needs to be done.
Hopefully by the end of this year Apple Music will have become an actual competitori to Spotify.
Discovery Station is what I was waiting for. Spotify/Pandora, unless they've changed, absolutely failed in this area. So AFAIC Music already bests both, because in every other way it was at least equivalent (for my purposes)
 
Feeling smug with my CDs ripped and playing on my phone with no issues 😂.

Thing with streaming is if the internet died you all lose access to your music.. I knows it never gonna happen but if it did I’d be feeling smug again 😂
 
I've always had loads of issues with syncing across multiple apps, not just Music. I constantly get settings being reset entirely in Podcasts, playlists duplicating, syncing just plain not syncing, among dozens of other little and constant annoyances.

I really don't get how a three trillion dollar company can be this pathetic.

Oh wait, yes I can, that's why they have so much money, 'cause they sure as hell don't spend it on QC.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.