Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

enduro0125

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Apr 9, 2012
276
161
Auto pause while running but still not able to use while cycling or hiking.

WTF?
 
Yeah ,I’ve done the same.
I just stopped even trying.

It’s just frustrating that it works for one discipline but not any of the others.
 
Yeah ,I’ve done the same.
I just stopped even trying.

It’s just frustrating that it works for one discipline but not any of the others.
I assume it works for running because you stop moving your arms, but how would it know to pause for a bike ride? This is me asking because I don’t know. If you down a mountain and coast would it pause?
 
My Garmin Fenix 3HR had it. Something we need to let Apple know we want included for sure. What a bummer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vanilla35
I assume it works for running because you stop moving your arms, but how would it know to pause for a bike ride? This is me asking because I don’t know. If you down a mountain and coast would it pause?

I would think it goes off your phones GPS.
I don’t use my arms that much when riding.

My Garmin Fenix 3HR had it. Something we need to let Apple know we want included for sure. What a bummer.

When they announced the auto pause for running last year I asked about doing it for other activities

Guess my voice hasn’t been heard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sgt93
I don't know why Apple can't do this when 3rd party apps can. I've been running the Ride Report app to capture my rides automatically. I commute by bicycle, so I make a lot of short trips that add up. Ride Report runs in the background and will capture those, but it's not perfect... and maybe that's why Apple has shied away from it. Sometimes Ride Report thinks I've stopped riding when I'm really just going very slowly up a steep hill :p It's mostly pretty accurate though. The only thing is that it quite offer all of the features of Workout, Strava, etc. No elevation gained, for example. For that reason I run the Workout app for rides when I'm actually out for exercise. I have to remember to Pause Ride Report or there will be some duplicate information written to the Health and Activity apps. You can pause Ride Report for one hour, until tomorrow, or until you manually un-pause. Overall I'm pretty happy with it, although it would be unnecessary if Apple just built in some automation. Ride Report can figure out, with darn good accuracy, when I'm traveling by car vs by bicycle. Seems like Apple ought to be able to do that as well.

Sean
 
I assume it works for running because you stop moving your arms, but how would it know to pause for a bike ride? This is me asking because I don’t know. If you down a mountain and coast would it pause?
Old post I'm replying to but still relevant info.
GPS. Once it detects no forward movement it should be able to deduce you have stopped. It does not but I wish it did. When I pause my Garmin on the bars pauses (500 model from years ago) but watch keeps going. I have the beta installed so its not there still.
 
Who knows why Apple does what they do. A better question is, why would a real cyclist not being using the Strava app?
 
Who knows why Apple does what they do. A better question is, why would a real cyclist not being using the Strava app?


I’m not a real cyclist but I like to use both Strava and my watch.
 
I’m not a real cyclist but I like to use both Strava and my watch.

Your watch has Strava. Do you mean you use Strava as a platform to upload activities to, but prefer to use non-Strava apps to do so?
 
Who knows why Apple does what they do. A better question is, why would a real cyclist not being using the Strava app?
What is a real cyclist? I don't use Strava, do track all my rides, don't study the data like I did in the past because I found more joy in just riding and recording.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Plett
What is a real cyclist? I don't use Strava, do track all my rides, don't study the data like I did in the past because I found more joy in just riding and recording.

The term real cyclist is just bait, you know that right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Plett
Do you really want to auto-pause? When I finish a bike ride, I want to see total time / distance stats, not "you were biking for 52 minutes" (but really out there for one hour, spent 8 minutes stopped at red lights).
 
The term real cyclist is just bait, you know that right?
Thats fine and in the end I would guess I'm not a real cyclist anyhow. I ride quite a bit but do it for stress relief and weight loss only.
Do you really want to auto-pause? When I finish a bike ride, I want to see total time / distance stats, not "you were biking for 52 minutes" (but really out there for one hour, spent 8 minutes stopped at red lights).
I do because the time sitting reduces the moving averages shown. I don't have to maintain a certain average but I try as a high level goal.
 
Do you really want to auto-pause? When I finish a bike ride, I want to see total time / distance stats, not "you were biking for 52 minutes" (but really out there for one hour, spent 8 minutes stopped at red lights).
Average speed is an important stat for cyclists, no auto pause corrupts it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: enduro0125
Do you really want to auto-pause? When I finish a bike ride, I want to see total time / distance stats, not "you were biking for 52 minutes" (but really out there for one hour, spent 8 minutes stopped at red lights).

Total time has less meaning than moving time. Without auto-pause or manually pausing activities your pace/power calculations will have a stream of zeros making a mess of your averages and making a nonsense of your data.

Total time is basically the least useful field you could have in any activity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: enduro0125
Your watch has Strava. Do you mean you use Strava as a platform to upload activities to, but prefer to use non-Strava apps to do so?

I have a Wahoo computer that runs Strava and my HR monitor.

I like the Apple fitness app as a stand alone program.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.