Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
No clubs have any issues raiding less wealthy clubs for their best talent. NUFC has no compunction about it either; they do it as much as anyone else. It’s business, and that’s what football is. Liverpool didn’t make a stink in the press about it, all the noise was on Newcastle’s side. The part that stings for Newcastle is that despite their Middle Eastern wealth they’re still getting poached. I’m not convinced the Isak deal is the best idea (the mind boggles at the sums involved), but he is a good forward, proven in this league. Geuhi is a much more pragmatic move; there is a shortage in defense when considering league, cup, and European commitments plus Konate’s situation and Gomez’s injury history.

Clubs on the receiving end of these bids are in a difficult situation. If they hold the line and refuse to sell the player may be unsettled. If they try to hold the line and fail, they may find themselves in the last week of the transfer window trying to buy a replacement for a key starter when everyone knows they have money and are desperate. And such players don’t grow on trees.
Almost worse, than the player being unsettled, from a vendor club perspective, is having the player run down their contract and thus leaving the club as a free agent, which would leave the vendor club completely out of pocket.

In such circumstances, it may be deemed more prudent to sell the player when a demand for his services arises - along with an offer of an appropriate fee for the player - rather than waiting, and running the risk of earning nothing as a consequence.
 
I think that this "the death of competitive football" is over-stating the case.
I am sure you can understand my frustration spilling out, especially as my team was hugely impacted by this.

From the many reports, and articles, that I have read since then, no one has seen anything wrong with the lead up to the Fulham disallowed goal. The Fulham player, had the ball, used skill to evade the player, and more noticeably, no other player, or the on field referee, had an issue.
The penalty, was harsh, but you can understand it. The mitigating factors should have been the player, jumping and turning, and the ball hitting his upper arm/elbow. Not sure how you can jump without using your arms.
There were a few other incidents in that penalty claim, and that was the 2 pushes, but they are part of the game, the handball, again that would have been harsh, because the Chelsea player had little time to do anything. But in balance, if the Fulham one was handball, so should the Chelsea one have been.
I strongly feel, that hand ball, should be essentially from the elbow down, as you can do little to influence the balls trajectory with your upper arm/elbow.
The excess time played in the first half, was excessive. The injury time number, is a minimum, but MOTD did a add up of the time, and felt it too was 2/3 mins longer than had accrued.

On the matter of referees, I fully get that they have it tough, and are sadly, including from me, getting some inappropriate comments made to them, and sadly subject to even worse commentary too. However, the culture of VAR, the lack of allowing anyone to publicly comment on decisions, and ability of a referee, publicly, by teams, after a game, and the inability to reverse 'wrong decisions', adds to the hotbed of discussion that follows.

Former Premier league defender, Stephan Warnock, suggests there should be former player input into VAR, and feels that referees should spend time with clubs, to understand the players, tactics etc, more than they clearly do now. I'd go a step further, and suggest, just like Cricket has often had (plus many other sports) that the FIFA Refeering Panel should consist of match officials, that have played the game at the highest levels. Providing to the Match referee, valuable insight, alongside refereeing qualifications, to advise appropriately.
 
I don’t know why anyone would want to be an elite ref these days (especially, by the sound of it, in Australia!). Nothing but abuse, public exposure, and hard work, they get very little for it.
For the record, I don't indulge in the practice of 'sledging' match officials, in any sport. The term used in Australia, is (sadly) ubiquitous towards afl umpires, and boundary riders, and is perceived as a slight, not an insult. If you frequent an AFL game, you see the fans vent at the officials, not the players, and yet in the stands, supporters of competing clubs, often will be found sitting next to each other, and having a great time, with a little bit 'banter' between.
 
giphy.gif
 
Always difficult when two teams play and you want them both to lose!

Just watching MOTD (two tired last night). I feel bad for Burnley. They had done so well against Utd I think a draw would have been the right result. But I can’t ague with the penalty. The shirt pull was really not necessary and ultimately very costly.
 
Always difficult when two teams play and you want them both to lose!

Just watching MOTD (two tired last night). I feel bad for Burnley. They had done so well against Utd I think a draw would have been the right result. But I can’t ague with the penalty. The shirt pull was really not necessary and ultimately very costly.
Hahaha.

Yeah Burnley got themselves to blame tbh. Even the second goal they conceded they switched off.

I guess VAR officials had to make it even stevens for overruling earlier United pen for shirt pulling by Mount.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
2-1 Brighton

Man City finished last season strongly, so this return to mediocre form is interesting. They seem to have lost the momentum they regained last spring.

Haaland continues to be Haaland….physical specimen, goal machine, a player of superior qualities, but does his inclusion make Man City worse as a team? I think that debate is still very much open.

Perhaps more worrying for Man City is to have Brighton successfully pin them back when trailing and go on to win the game. Pep’s men had much more possession but as the match wound down they lost control.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
Solid half for Arsenal new boys.

He needs to take off Martinelli.

Bring on Eze imo.

I really hope we get a specialist left winger in the coming windows.

Playing with Martinelli is effectively playing with 10 men. He offers next to nothing and seems to be getting worse.
Indeed; however, it will take a couple of games to properly integrate the new players into the team and for them to develop a cohesive and comfortable playing relationship with the rest of the team.

Nevertheless, Arsenal's perennial pattern of repeatedly incurring injuries, some of them serious - to key players - does concern me.
 
Not a classic by any means but LFC will be happy with that, the crowd + a moment of magic decided the game. Arsenal will have to ruminate on what might have been. Arteta came for a draw and perhaps should've been more adventurous with his selection.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.