I received my new 14 Pro yesterday and was very excited to try the dynamic island. I have to say it sucks. I found the notch on the 13 pro somewhat intrusive, but the island is all on another level. When I open Safari/Mail/calendar or other programs with a white background, the island looks like a big black spot in the middle of the screen, which significantly interferes with my regular phone usage. I am not sure if I will be able to adjust.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone 14 Pro the dynamic island sucks
- Thread starter topomango
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
After 12 hours or so on the 14 Pro Max, had to do something on the ol' ball and chain's 11 Pro and let me tell you, the notch is cringe and dated.
Like an ancient relic from a less civilised time. An anachronism. Should be buried with dear old Liz.
Like an ancient relic from a less civilised time. An anachronism. Should be buried with dear old Liz.
I was hoping every time I exit from an app it goes up to the dynamic island, idk I like the animation.... but I guess it's just music apps and whatever app that plays in the background....
It is not that easy. Going back to the 13 may work for a few years, but eventually, this island is going to be standard for all iPhones. Either you adjust to it, or you switch to Android. I found it very distractive.
13 should be supported at least another 4-5 years, you’ll be fine.
Who was that guy on here who was very vocal about refusing to upgrade while there was still a camera bump?
I like the concept behind it. The apps that currently use it use it well. Just waiting to see what the devs do with it. Other than that the notch in general never really bugged me.
Notch = old and busted. Island = new hotness. I can’t believe how much better it is. Maybe because now I look at it as a notification and information center. Instead of trying to ignore it I’m interacting with it and referring to it. Also I use dark mode. But come on, the island is where it’s at. Don’t get voted off, embrace the island.
This is really the only response that matters. If you’re unhappy with your purchase for whatever reason, there’s nothing anyone here is going to be able to do for you.
Island is super for marketing to sell you the phone, but suck for using it since you cannot really use with one hand to touch the island and also the notch is lower so the effective area is smaller, then you will see a lot of apps or browsers just show content with part of the notch or whole Notch.
Anyway expensive 14 pro series but actually this island thing is worse than old notch.
Anyway expensive 14 pro series but actually this island thing is worse than old notch.
Dynamic Island is awesome. Sounds like user error.
So far from playing around with my Pro, it seems only a few apps utilise Dynamic Island (Apple Music for example)…which other ones use it well and for those loving it, how has it made a difference? I know I’m missing something as it only seems easier to switch between some apps but that’s it?
Can I ask exactly how the island interferes with the usage of your phone? If anything it adds functionality
It will be interesting to see if you get used to it. I've never gotten used to the notch on the XS or 13PM, but for others they do. The functionality of the DI I would assume somewhat helps, but in terms of Screen Real Estate and how it works with video and content, it does seem at this point to be worse than the notch on the 13PM.
11Pro has the older, bigger notch compared to the 13P/PM. Obviously the Notch isn't interactive, but in terms of screen real estate it can be argued the 13PM notch is superior to the DI.
So if you want to discuss or debate the cons of a new piece of kit then you should just return it? It is an option though. I think purchases can cover a spectrum of how satisfied one is with it. The OP has mentioned they will have to suck it up. I find the OPs view pretty rational tbf.
I never really noticed either the notch or the island. Since Apple is such a tight ecosystem, the apps are all designed around them so you rarely have anything going on up there worth looking at.
With the island I do like that the narrower width has allowed them to use that extra space. It could use some refinement and added app support. So far I’ve liked the quick access to timers, music, maps, etc.
With the island I do like that the narrower width has allowed them to use that extra space. It could use some refinement and added app support. So far I’ve liked the quick access to timers, music, maps, etc.
If you’re not satisfied return it. It took me a few days to get used to the notch same with the DI. I’m sure there will be more apps that will use the DI.
You have to make a informed decision for yourself whether the phone is for you.
People post that this feature sucks or that feature sucks or It’s not really a upgrade or I’m bored already with the 14 Pro etc. They are looking for a vote of confidence of what might be a unpopular opinion on a iPhone forum.
Right now with iPhones it’s Notch or Dynamic Island. Those are your choices. Pick one or switch to a Android based device. It’s that simple.
You have to make a informed decision for yourself whether the phone is for you.
People post that this feature sucks or that feature sucks or It’s not really a upgrade or I’m bored already with the 14 Pro etc. They are looking for a vote of confidence of what might be a unpopular opinion on a iPhone forum.
Right now with iPhones it’s Notch or Dynamic Island. Those are your choices. Pick one or switch to a Android based device. It’s that simple.
It will be replaced by something else at some point, you can bet on that. It's just a phase, like the notch was.
its new.
its different.
Takes getting used to.
And, "in the middle of the screen" is a tad of an exaggeration isn't it. hardly in the middle.
The 14 Pro isn't marketed by Apple as a one-handed use phone.
The island doesn't really take anymore space than the notch and it doesn't interfere with the screen. The problem is the island seems to distract people when it is active and people are using a webpage etc. A lot of complaining going for something that barely registers on the a real complaint scale.
I’m mulling returning it for other reasons - mainly lack of practical improvement over my 12P and a comically large camera array. But I do think the Island is actually pretty neat. The notch is just a notch - it’s dead space on the screen. I’m enjoying how the island is more of a notification hub.
HobeSoundDarryl
macrumors G5
Some developer is going to write an app to fill the visible screen above the island... yielding what might be called Dynamic Notch. If notch was fine/"iconic"/"I love the notch"/etc and island is not, grab that app when it is available (if not already).