That's what I need -- some answers, or even a clue. I stopped watching after the 6th episode I think? I think it's well produced overall, but without any clues, it's just frustrating (to me); that's why I quit watching. The cult is silly in my opinion. The dogs are such a random thing that it felt like they were introducing another random event just to add to the mystery, as if everything was all tied together somehow.
I would assume the dogs are related, not that it was going to be revealed. 😉
As for Lost, I really enjoyed that first season. Somehow it was interesting even the next few seasons. Then the whole time travel thing kind of caught me by surprise. I didn't watch the last season. But I still think that first one was really good.
Again, just my feelings on these shows. Think I will finally start Boardwalk Empire.
For Lost I bought most of it, although I admit that when they got off the island and then were told they needed to go back, that irritated me a bit. 🙂 Instead of time travel, I'd describe it as alternate reality. I could accept it, but it moved the story out of a realm where many viewers could follow. I begrudgingly accepted it because I was enamored with the characters and their interpersonal relationships. And Lost had many rays of sunshine as compared to the eternal darkness of The Leftovers.
Regarding Boardwalk Empire, I never really liked it. My wife fizzled out on it about Season 2. Give it a shot. 🙂