Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
With most everyone's Fan Idle at around 2000rpm, are you able to hear the fans? I can hear mine running quietly at around 2000rpm, which is usually where it's at from the moment the MBP's turned on, until the CPU load goes up. I'm assuming that's normal.

EDIT: By the way, is this thread the only way to get a sense of where the new MBP temps should be? There's no literature any where in Apple's Support section or from Intel?
 
That's why this thread has been created, cause seems that Apple, take a little bit long time to shoot new and fresh anouncements about his products specs or issues (with this last being the most important, having seen the freezing problems there).

So, still posting please. :)
 
Just like to point out two variables that have not been noted here. The temperature of the room you are running this test in and the altitude of where you live. A fan has to work harder (the air is thinner) in Denver than in a sea level city. A machine running in a 65 degree room has a big advantage over a machine in a 80 degree room.
 
With most everyone's Fan Idle at around 2000rpm, are you able to hear the fans? I can hear mine running quietly at around 2000rpm, which is usually where it's at from the moment the MBP's turned on, until the CPU load goes up. I'm assuming that's normal.

EDIT: By the way, is this thread the only way to get a sense of where the new MBP temps should be? There's no literature any where in Apple's Support section or from Intel?

Fan - Your fan sounds like mine, so it's probably normal

Temp: There is info on the Intel datasheet's for the various CPUs. eg for Core i7....
http://www.intel.com/products/processor/corei7/mobile/techdocs.htm
Intel defines a temperature called Tj,max. Above this temperature the CPU starts to take steps to protect itself by down clocking. Intel also "recommends" in some circumstances running 10 C below this temperature, though the wording is quite vague. I think for all the current products Tj,max is 105 C.
 
Model: MBP i5 2.40 GHz 15" HDD 320GB 4GB

Program used: iStat Pro Widget
Average CPU Idle: 35C
Fans Idle: 2k rpm
Fans Full: 6k rpm

Fans started : 91C
Peak: 93C
Full CPU after fans: 75-77C


Seems like my 2.40GHz i5 is quite a lot cooler than the i7s posted here!
Maybe it's the CPU or maybe someone have done a proper job applying thermal paste on mine!

So far I'm really happy I got the i5, since it seems like it's the sweet spot between performance, heat and battery life (which is awesome, I can actually get 8 hrs from this)
 
i7 with an SSD

Anyone testing i7 with an SSD?

I have an i7 17" 8-gb 128SSD on the way. I'll post a complete set of numbers. In the meantime just wondering if it makes a difference in the heat factor...
 
Anyone testing i7 with an SSD?

I have an i7 17" 8-gb 128SSD on the way. I'll post a complete set of numbers. In the meantime just wondering if it makes a difference in the heat factor...

I have a 512GB SSD from Apple and I had during an avchd files conversion and xfr, cores temp peak at 103-104°C (CPU A temp diode at 95-97° max) with fans kicking at 100°C on cores (95° on diode). All this monitoring has been done with HW monitor. Here below the thread I opened on apple forum:
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2435667&tstart=0

Do you think please that my MBP is normal as yours / others?

Thanks to reassure me....
Cheers
 
Model: MBP i5 15" 2.4
Program used: iStat Pro Widget
Average CPU Idle: 37-42ºC
Full CPU: 95ºC
Full Heatsink: 57ºC
Fans Idle: 2000rpm
Fans Full: 3500-3700rpm
Fans started: @ 94ºC.
Full CPU after fans: ~85ºC
CPU Heatsink (full CPU after fans): ~52ºC
 
istat results for 17"mbp

Four terms yes>/dev/null
also 5 safari windows and 1 finder open
Model: MBP i7 17" 8gb 128ssd
Program used: iStat Pro Widget

Average CPU Idle: ~27ºC
Full CPU: ~97ºC
Full Heatsink: ~50ºC
Fans Idle: ~1900rpm
Fans Full: ~2900rpm
Fans started: @~90ºC.
Full CPU after fans: ~95ºC (after 20 min)
CPU Heatsink (full CPU after fans): ~51ºC
 
I have a 512GB SSD from Apple and I had during an avchd files conversion and xfr, cores temp peak at 103-104°C (CPU A temp diode at 95-97° max) with fans kicking at 100°C on cores (95° on diode). All this monitoring has been done with HW monitor. Here below the thread I opened on apple forum:
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2435667&tstart=0

Do you think please that my MBP is normal as yours / others?

Your situation is not really comparable to what others are reporting on this thread. Why don't you try the test outlined at start of this thread? It's easy and then you have something to compare to.
 
Model: Mid April 2010 MacBook pro 13" 2.4GHz Intel Core 2 Duo, 4Gb RAM. Base model (no upgrades, all stock config)
Program used: iStat Pro
Average CPU Idle: 45ºC.
Fans Idle: ~2000rpm.
Fans Full: ~5067
Fans started : @ ~90ºF
Full CPU after fans: ~190ºF.
 

Attachments

  • Screen shot 2010-05-28 at 7.58.59 PM.png
    Screen shot 2010-05-28 at 7.58.59 PM.png
    376 KB · Views: 129
Model: MBP i5 15" 2.4
Program used: iStat Pro Widget
Average CPU Idle: 50-55ºC
Full CPU: 97ºC
Full Heatsink: 57ºC
Fans Idle: 2000rpm
Fans Full: 4500-4700rpm
Fans started: @ 97ºC.
Full CPU after fans: ~85ºC
CPU Heatsink (full CPU after fans): ~55ºC

i think my idle temp a bit high :confused:
 
Model: MBP i5 15" 2.4
Program used: iStat Pro Widget
Average CPU Idle: 50-55ºC
Full CPU: 97ºC
Full Heatsink: 57ºC
Fans Idle: 2000rpm
Fans Full: 4500-4700rpm
Fans started: @ 97ºC.
Full CPU after fans: ~85ºC
CPU Heatsink (full CPU after fans): ~55ºC

i think my idle temp a bit high :confused:
I have the same model (2.4 i5 15") my idle temperature is around 33-35C (from iStat Widget)
 
MBP 15" i5 2.4 Ghz

Idle and after 4x yes>/dev/null
 

Attachments

  • Screen shot 2010-08-22 at 1.56.48 PM.png
    Screen shot 2010-08-22 at 1.56.48 PM.png
    59.6 KB · Views: 106
  • Screen shot 2010-08-22 at 2.05.43 PM.png
    Screen shot 2010-08-22 at 2.05.43 PM.png
    62 KB · Views: 121
My main Temps are David Ruffin and Eddie Kendricks.

Oh, you mean TempERATURES?

My 17" doesn't get very hot even under load. The worst it gets is if I'm doing movie processing with MPEG Streamclip and even then it's a fraction of what I'd get with my previous computers. For the record this is the 2.66GHz i5 17" 2010 MacBook Pro.

These stats assume the following:

- encoding a large FLV file to an HD QuickTime movie at full quality which on my old 2009 13" would have resulted in max fans and near unbearable heat after a minute;
- running multi-stream GarageBand; and
- VMWare Fusion loaded and running Windows Server 2008.

Running dev null - yeah, that's a good way to peak things out, but is it realistic? I'd rather test using applications that users would be using, because that's closer to accurate than just running a process that goes nowhere for the sake of seeing numbers spike.

SSD so drive heat is not considered here. That likely is contributing to the cooler temperatures I see.

Program used: iStat Pro Widget

Idle State

  • Average CPU: ~32ºC
  • Average Fan Speed: ~1999ºC

Load State

  • Peak CPU: ~83ºC
  • Peak Fan Speed: ~3400ºC
  • Peak GPU: ~63ºC (I think this rating is just as important, BTW. A lot of what makes the computer hot is not just the CPU but the combination of the CPU and GPU generating heat in most cases, especially in graphics-intensive apps like Adobe)



This is in a room that has constant airflow and where the ambient temperature never exceeds about 75 degrees, and it's sitting on an elevated heat dissipating desktop stand (bought it for the 2009 13" which got a fair bit hotter). Again though, the circumstances I completed my testing in are completely abnormal for a laptop, so I'm going to definitely see even cooler temperatures in "real world" situations, and I do. Normally my CPU never even gets to 40 degrees Celsius unless I'm running VMWare Fusion, which I do on occasion.

I have to agree that ambient room temperature AND surrounding airflow are both going to play big parts as to what temperatures you get from your MacBook Pro. If you're running 80 or above, especially in places like Arizona or wherever where it's dry heat, or if you're one of those "stale air" types, I submit that's going to slant your results.
 
Model: MBP i7 17" Glossy HDD 500GB@7200rpm RAM@8GB
Program used: iStat
Average CPU Idle: 29ºC.
Full CPU: 96ºC
Fans Idle: ~2000rpm.
Fans Full: ~5500rpm.
Fans started : @ ~90ºC.
Full CPU after fans: ~86ºC.
 
ill post my resutls when i get home but im pretty much in the same zone as 85~92 ish category

i7 mbp 2010 with 330m 512 15"
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.