Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Huntn

macrumors Penryn
Original poster
May 5, 2008
24,090
27,182
The Misty Mountains
My current Mac is a 2016 MBP, see signature, paid $2100, still is working great, yet it is getting older. I was in Costco yesterday and saw a 13”MacBook Air, M2 on sale for $700 ($200 off) through 17 November. This got my attention I examined it, it looks good. My only concerned is that it only has two USB ports and the hard drive is half the size of my current computer, which also has three USB ports, not counting power. Basically all I do with my Mac these days is manage my finances and use it as a word processor, so I’m wondering why not save $1300 this time and get the lesser box? I can mitigate one less USB port with a USB hub although I’m not crazy about the smaller hard drive. Any thoughts on this to share? Thanks! 🙂
 
You said all you do is use it to manage your finances which I’m guessing is online and a word processor. How many thousands of word documents do you keep on your laptop?

Look how much space you’re using on your current set up and figure out what is using that space. There has to be something other than documents.


I didn’t see you mention the size of your current MacBook Pro but if it’s a 13”, this is going to be a significant upgrade. Just don’t buy something if it doesn’t have what you need. I have this MacBook Air myself and absolutely love it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
I don't mean to be the devil's advocate, but whenever I'm in situations like this I try to ask myself honestly what it is that the new model I am looking at can do (of the things for which I use my computer) which my current can't. Basically, what flaw or void am I trying to fix or fill?

The 2016 MBP is a terrific machine. Unless I felt I really had cash to burn I probably wouldn't buy that Air. It's not that much lighter than the MBP and apart from the speed of the M2 compared to the i5 it seems more limited. You don't write how much RAM either model has but I suppose the M2 only has 8GB at that price (or?). Granted, I'm writing this on a 2008 Mac Pro running Monterey and like to keep older Macs running for as long as possible.

cheers
Philip


My current Mac is a 2016 MBP, see signature, paid $2100, still is working great, yet it is getting older. I was in Costco yesterday and saw a 13”MacBook Air, M2 on sale for $700 ($200 off) through 17 November. This got my attention I examined it, it looks good. My only concerned is that it only has two USB ports and the hard drive is half the size of my current computer, which also has three USB ports, not counting power. Basically all I do with my Mac these days is manage my finances and use it as a word processor, so I’m wondering why not save $1300 this time and get the lesser box? I can mitigate one less USB port with a USB hub although I’m not crazy about the smaller hard drive. Any thoughts on this to share? Thanks! 🙂
 
  • Like
Reactions: Andrey84 and Huntn
Given that you appear to keep your devices for a long time, and Apple has just stopped selling new 8GB models, I’d rather spend an extra $100 and get an M2 Air from Amazon with 16GB of RAM. If the difference was $200, that becomes a tougher choice.
https://www.macrumors.com/2024/11/04/m2-macbook-air-16gb-200-discount/

The storage sounds like it should be fine for your usage, but check how much you’re using on your current device first. You can always get a portable hard drive or SSD to supplement the internal storage.
 
Given that you appear to keep your devices for a long time, and Apple has just stopped selling new 8GB models, I’d rather spend an extra $100 and get an M2 Air from Amazon with 16GB of RAM. If the difference was $200, that becomes a tougher choice.
https://www.macrumors.com/2024/11/04/m2-macbook-air-16gb-200-discount/

The storage sounds like it should be fine for your usage, but check how much you’re using on your current device first. You can always get a portable hard drive or SSD to supplement the internal storage.
16 GB would be worth the extra $100. My current MBR has a 500GB hard drive, the new Air has 250Gb, and I have a hard time justifying an extra $1000 for a 500GB hard drive in a new MacBook.🤔 Thanks! :)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: AJB1971
16 GB would be worth the extra $100. My current MBR has a 500GB hard drive, the new Air has 250Gb, and I have a hard time justifying an extra $1000 for a 500GB hard drive in a new MacBook.🤔 Thanks! :)
I think RAM is the equivalent of horsepower in the car world. You have people that drive like grandma in a 392 Dodge Charger when they could be perfectly fine with the V6. It’s just the fact that they know if they wanted to they could hit the gas and have that power. You have people in the computer world that only use it for browsing the Internet with 32 GB. Absolutely nothing wrong with it unless you’re trying to save money
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
I am an attorney and have north of 250.000 docs on my laptop, many of those large-ish pdfs, and it not exceed 90Gb.
For office work 8/256 is plenty (my colleagues have base m1 minis and no one is complaining).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
Sounds like you don't really need a new laptop, but rather you just want one. Get a clean Mac OS Sequoia install with full SSD formatting, clean the laptop really well, and voila, you'll get that new laptop feeling. I'm sure a new thinner and lighter MBA is coming in the spring. The existing MBAs are not really that amazing of a product due to how thick they are. The money you save you can invest into something or partially fund a holiday.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pullman and Huntn
When Best Buy gives you 24 months to finance and a $750.00 trade in on my M3 air, I find it hard not to jump to the new Pro M4
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
Do you really need portability? If not, get a base M4 Mac Mini 16GB/256GB which has five USB/Thunderbolt ports then expand storage with inexpensive external storage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn and dmr727
My current Mac is a 2016 MBP, see signature, paid $2100, still is working great, yet it is getting older. I was in Costco yesterday and saw a 13”MacBook Air, M2 on sale for $700 ($200 off) through 17 November. This got my attention I examined it, it looks good. My only concerned is that it only has two USB ports and the hard drive is half the size of my current computer, which also has three USB ports, not counting power. Basically all I do with my Mac these days is manage my finances and use it as a word processor, so I’m wondering why not save $1300 this time and get the lesser box? I can mitigate one less USB port with a USB hub although I’m not crazy about the smaller hard drive. Any thoughts on this to share? Thanks! 🙂
It only has two USB ports, but they’re 40 GBPs Thunderbolt ports. You can attach a Thunderbolt hub and attach a huge number of devices, including charger, to just one port on your Mac and have full speed.

For instance, I have one of these hubs and I attack a 4K60 monitor, plus a very fast SSD drive, my card readers, gig Ethernet and my keyboard mouse... All through one USB connection to my laptop, and that connection includes power. Very convenient! So unless you want 2 or 3 monitors, one port can be all you need.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Huntn
Sounds like you don't really need a new laptop, but rather you just want one. Get a clean Mac OS Sequoia install with full SSD formatting, clean the laptop really well, and voila, you'll get that new laptop feeling. I'm sure a new thinner and lighter MBA is coming in the spring. The existing MBAs are not really that amazing of a product due to how thick they are. The money you save you can invest into something or partially fund a holiday.
Well, my 2016 is running fine, and it could hiccup any time. But I might just wait for it's 10 year anniversary with my fingers crossed. Is 10 years reasonable? It just sits on my desk most of the time...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Andrey84
It only has two USB ports, but they’re 40 GBPs Thunderbolt ports. You can attach a Thunderbolt hub and attach a huge number of devices, including charger, to just one port on your Mac and have full speed.

For instance, I have one of these hubs and I attack a 4K60 monitor, plus a very fast SSD drive, my card readers, gig Ethernet and my keyboard mouse... All through one USB connection to my laptop, and that connection includes power. Very convenient! So unless you want 2 or 3 monitors, one port can be all you need.
I just wanted the connivence without having to run cables up from the floor. Space is tight on my desk.
 
Well I think ten years is reasonable for a Mac, all depending on what one uses it for of course. I mentioned my 2008 Mac Pro above, which ticks along. I use it for all my photo editing and even video editing. Granted with bigger video files I may need to upgrade to another machine but not yet.

For my daily work, which consists of word processing, email, web browsing and giving presentations at a university, I use my 11-inch MacBook Air from 2015 which runs Monterey natively. I replaced the battery recently which was a simple operation which has extended its functionality considerably.

I'm not at all opposed to buying new gear, but like keeping and maintaining equipment for as long as possible. It's an investment after all. In addition, I have found that it is often actually handy to use older Macs because of the various ports which are included. Sure, it's cool to have a super fast Thunderbolt but in all honesty how often does one benefit of being able to transfer a super-large file in a few seconds and in which situations will it be impossible to wait the extra seconds it takes over a slower connection? And if having only one type of ports requires a dock, hub or adapters to connect to other equipment it becomes complicated in practice. In such situations it's helpful to have built-in ports of different kinds, like a HDMI, USB-A ports and even SD card readers. In a similar fashion I'm very happy today in 2024 to have the expandability of the Mac Pro chassis which allows me to connect PCI cards of various types.

All this to say that it sounds to me that for your use case your 2016 MBP, which as said is a superb machine, seems to be adequate. Still, if you have the cash to burn and desire a more modern machine there's nothing wrong with that.

cheers
Philip

Well, my 2016 is running fine, and it could hiccup any time. But I might just wait for it's 10 year anniversary with my fingers crossed. Is 10 years reasonable? It just sits on my desk most of the time...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn and Andrey84
Do you really need portability? If not, get a base M4 Mac Mini 16GB/256GB which has five USB/Thunderbolt ports then expand storage with inexpensive external storage.
I need the small desk foot print... my PC's 2 large monitors and keyboard, mouse take up a good deal of it... My curent MBP sits on the left side of my desk in front of the secondary monitor.
 
Well, my 2016 is running fine, and it could hiccup any time. But I might just wait for it's 10 year anniversary with my fingers crossed. Is 10 years reasonable? It just sits on my desk most of the time...

10 years is absolutely reasonable. I had a late 2013 rMBP (15 inch) for close to 10 years, and I'd still be using it now, 6 months after its 10 year anniversary, except that it met with a fatal accident on the Deutsche Bahn. (I did have to replace the battery after about 8 years; not a difficult process if you're careful.)

If you're OK with the performance and it's working, I'd just wait. Maybe keep an eye on sales or Apple refurbished units for a deal you can't refuse.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Huntn
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.