Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
It has for me. I have 4 friends with the iPhone 4 that came over to my place last night. I asked all of them whether they have the reception problem and all said no. Once I tried replicating the problem on each of their phones, ALL of them did in fact have the problem, and I live across the street from an ATT cell tower. I've never seen anything less than 5 bars in my apartment. I'm seriously considering just keeping my 3GS until next year.

Gee, so they had the problem and yet it didn't affect them because they didn't even notice til you had to replicate the problem. Seems their phone is working fine for them.

Honestly, a problem that doesn't pop up under normal use and you have to try to show the problem means maybe you should stop freaking out about it so badly as it obviously does not affect your friends.

For me, the other stuff the phone does so well is not worthy worrying about a problem that for me I really had to try to get it to show (and honeslty, I can't replicate it every single time) and has yet to even get my phone to lose connection (it at worst shows 0 bars but never searches for signal. And then sometimes it gets signal back while I'm replicating the issue). It's a small corner you have to avoid so while it's annoying, it's not bad enough for me to say the phone isn't worth it. Now if you couldn't hold an entire side, that would be more worth worrying to me.

I mean, I'm sure there is always going to be something you don't like about whatever you get (my old phone it was the camera). You just have to decide if that is important enough to shadow what you like (or if what you like is good enough to shadow over what you don't like).

I trusted Apple - BIG MISTAKE

I've spent over $10k this year upgrading to new Apple laptops & peripherals.

Then I bought this iPhone 4, only to find that I can't expect it to make a phone call?

Lucky for me I have other lines with excellent smartphones. If I wasn't an enthusiast of mobile devices & only had one phone, if it was an iPhone 4 I'd be out of luck.


Um, isn't that bit of an exageration? It can make the call fine. Even if you have the mistake and it seems easy to replicate, it's easy to avoid by either a case or holding the phone slightly different.

Honestly, yeah, it's an issue. But this is what I object to, people exagerating it to make it sound like the phone can't make a call. And even if you replicate the problem easily (I can't), there are ways around it so it's not like it can't make the call. It's like it's more inconvenient to use to make a call.
 
I'm still waiting for iPhone 4 to be released here next month but this new antenna design debacle and also reports of how easily the glassed back cracks has indeed put me off. Also Jobs email response to not to hold it that way was too arrogant. I'm sorry, but naturally, users will end up touching that area in both landscape and portrait, while on a call or playing a game etc.

Please admit it's your faul this time Apple, it's a freaking design flaw! Unless iOS 4.0.1 update addresses this, I may just continue to use my 3GS. Please don't tell me to put tape across the hinges or buy a protective case...that's not the point.
 
Bring on the White iPhone 4!!

I will not hesitate to buy once the white model is released!

AS a side note, I have yet to see a new "beat all to end all" tech gadget released in recent years that didn't have some sort of complaints immediately start rolling in.......Xbox 360, PS3, Wii, Blu Ray players, HDTVs, cell phones, etc, etc...:rolleyes:
 
Nope. Still waiting for my White iPhone w/ White Bumper.

It's still several weeks out which gives Apple plenty of time to work all the kinks out. (Especially the antenna issue)
 
At the very least, I would wait to see if this issue can be resolved before making any definitive decisions on the iPhone 4.

While I understand every new launching will have certain issues, the ability for a phone to potentially make a telephone call is a severe one. It appears Apple may have a software fix by Monday, since some upgraded 3Gs to OS4 are exhibiting the similar eroding signal as illustrated on the iPhone 4.

At least, there is hope this could be fixed via a software upgrade.

In a couple of weeks, we'll all know whether or not this "issue" can be resolved.
 
Gee, so they had the problem and yet it didn't affect them because they didn't even notice til you had to replicate the problem. Seems their phone is working fine for them.

Honestly, a problem that doesn't pop up under normal use and you have to try to show the problem means maybe you should stop freaking out about it so badly as it obviously does not affect your friends.

So just because it hadn't affected them after barely 24 hours of use, it's not ever going to affect them? Not sure I understand your logic. I don't want to have to think about how to "properly" hold my cell phone every time I make a phone call. It wasn't even hard for me to replicate the problem by casually holding the phone in my left hand, less than 250 feet from an AT&T cell tower. That's a serious concern IMO. I'm hoping it's just a software issue, because I really want an iPhone 4. I'm an engineer and design consumer products myself. To let a design flaw (whether it's software or hardware) this glaringly bad make it to a commercially launched product is unacceptable. I hold Apple to a higher standard than this, and so should everyone else for the prices they charge for their products. I've always justified the premium because Apple designs their products so well, but they dropped the ball on this one IMO.
 
The display and extra memory are marketing gimmicks? Have you seen the phone yet? The display is stunning.

Yes I've seen it, meh. The problem is it's still a small screen, no matter how sharp it is it's still uncomfortable to have a full computer like interaction with it. That's why in MY opinion it's a gimmick.
 
It did at first... Then I went into the store and looked at one. When I first picked it up, it went from 5 bars to 2 bars. Put it back down and it went back up to 5. Then I picked it up again... nothing. Tried everything to replicate the issue again; I even put my finger on bottom left gap... nothing. This whole thing is overblown, IMO, and if it's a real issue, Apple will take care of its customers. I'm ordering a white ASAP.
 
I'm gonna wait for the kinks to be worked out. This is basically a completely redesigned iPhone and everyone knows that version 1 of anything always has issues.

I think the reception problem is a very big issue and I'm sure Apple is working hard right now to figure out a solution. Once they have that figured out, I'll buy one. But until then, no friggin' way.
 
I'm not even put off a little... I honestly wish i could have the white one in my hand right now.

Sure there is a risk of having issues but based on the way i hold the phone and the way people that have the problem are holding the phone i doubt I will run into any issues. Its the life of an early adopter in my opinion how many major new products come out and have zero issues? I know for some this is a bigger issue than others but ultimately it is my opinion that people are blowing it out of proportion.
 
If it puts you off, use the screen for about 5 minutes. Then go back to your old phone. You can't go back.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.