Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
That GarageBand icon is an absolute abomination. Not only is that guitar missing a bridge, everything about its shape and the way the color is applied, is completely off. It looks like an icon for some malware garbage that will trick you into paying a weekly subscription.
 
  • Love
Reactions: turbineseaplane
That GarageBand icon is an absolute abomination. Not only is that guitar missing a bridge, everything about its shape and the way the color is applied, is completely off. It looks like an icon for some malware garbage that will trick you into paying a weekly subscription.

Apple have clearly been having trouble hiring top notch design talent.

It's evident everywhere in the software, across all the platforms.
 
Amazing, 3 Trillion $ company. Updating icons months after updates. Going the microsoft road i see
4 shareholder downvotes for your blasphemy!

would have preferred to see the 26.1 releases today ...
Sharing personal preferences? Downvote! (really smh at that one)

Please just don't force them on us users who are sticking with iOS 18 because of Liquid Glass.

I've already deleted Apple Support because they glassed the iOS 18 icon. Guess I won't bother updating these apps at all.
This is the first year I haven't upgraded iOS and, the longer I wait, the happier I am that I'm still on iOS 18.
 
  • Love
Reactions: turbineseaplane
I guess I'm still in the flatter less-skeuomorphism-is-more camp. This reminds me of OS10 Aqua or MS Vista.
 
Looks like only the icons are updated. Wish Apple updates UI also for all its apps and hope that it happens soon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mganu
That GarageBand icon is an absolute abomination. Not only is that guitar missing a bridge, everything about its shape and the way the color is applied, is completely off. It looks like an icon for some malware garbage that will trick you into paying a weekly subscription.

They must have used Image Playground to generate the new icon.
 
Why do you suppose that would be?

It's almost like folks aren't enjoying the forced visual change for the sake of change.
💡🫤
I suppose it's because some people are happiest when they have something to complain about.😁


Forced? 🤣 Nobody is forcing anybody to use Apple products. There are plenty of competitors out there.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: carswell
There are plenty of competitors out there.
If you care about privacy, stability, security and compatibility, there aren’t that many.

We could really use some more, actually.

For professionals in creative and software engineering fields that use Macs professionally, you could even make the argument that there aren’t any competitors out there. I would.
 
If you care about privacy, stability, security and compatibility, there aren’t that many.

We could really use some more, actually.

For professionals in creative and software engineering fields that use Macs professionally, you could even make the argument that there aren’t any competitors out there. I would.
So basically, there are no good companies out there??
 
I absolutely love Photomator as it's almost the only way to work with HDR photos (except for Lightroom which is made by Adobe so lol no thanks)

But I the pace of updates and bug fixes is lacklustre even after the acquisition. I would expect more from Apple. Hopefully they step it up?
 
So basically, there are no good companies out there??
No, there are plenty of good companies out there.

But there is no real alternative to macOS as a platform for certain workflows.

Personally, I wish there were some. But at this stage, given the maturity of the market, it’s extremely unlikely to happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carswell
No, there are plenty of good companies out there.

But there is no real alternative to macOS as a platform for certain workflows.

Personally, I wish there were some. But at this stage, given the maturity of the market, it’s extremely unlikely to happen.
Ok I am confused. This post is about iOS and liquid glass. Not sure why you brought in macOS.

I go back to my original point, basically every comment in this thread is a complaint. Yes, people are complaining about GarageBand icon re-design. Not the app itself, an icon. I can hear Allen Iverson now “we talking about an icon….icon”

My point still is valid, there are plenty of phone options out there for people to choose from if they are so unhappy with what Apple puts out. It wouldn't matter anyway because if somebody moved to competitor, they would likely complain about the operating system or phone. And that goes to my other post, some people are happiest when they are unhappy and have something to complain about.


If people want Apple to change, they should speak with their wallet. If enough people follow suit, Apple will be forced to change.

Have a good one!
 
Last edited:
  • Disagree
Reactions: carswell
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.