If this replaced the old stock purchase program, then this is a greedy way of taking away a good benefit from retail.
The reality is that the retail stores barely pay a living wage. I worked there a year while my wife was a para-educator. I could afford to work there because I wasn't living off the Apple Retail pay. She got pregnant and we decided she would stay at home. I couldn't stay at Apple.
I have about 10 shares of Apple Stock from my time as an employee. They are mine. No restrictions. Had this program been in place, I may not have any after leaving.
You want to retain your talent? Here's a few tips Apple:
1. Pay them better. You have 200 billion dollars. Share a little more with the grunts on the front lines.
2. Fix your broken scheduling. Working till 11 one night then 8 again the next morning was not cool. Sporadic and unpredictable shifts were horrible.
3. Show that corporate gives a hoot about retail. Come visit stores that aren't in major markets. Give kudos and attention to the folks who work their butts off.
4. Don't do major upgrades to internal systems on weekends and holidays... we're still open and when retail systems go down when there isn't someone to call, it's a nightmare.
5. Trim the fat. Every retail store has it. Some folks are super negative and need to go. That may include management. Get more involved in your stores and really get a feel for the attitudes there.
6. NPS sucks. When you're graded on a scale where 1-7 is bad, 8-9 are neutral and only a 10 is positive, you feel constantly brow beat. Sure, NSP is a standard metric, but isn't Apple different?
7. Fix Apple culture. Times are changing. It feels like the cool hippy spirit of the store is fading into a more corporate feel. Angela, you should restore the excitement of launch days. Tim, you should revisit what OneToOne is all about, and don't be so dang stingy with Apple branded perks. Water bottles and t-shirts are cheap but people love Apple branded gear.
8. Empower your employees. Let them make more judgement calls. Apple magic is more than just a receipt coming out of a table or a product being delivered from behind a big steel wall. Apple magic is letting someone replace out of warranty headphones because it's the right thing to do. It's about making customers feel special when they walk into your stores.
Talent retention isn't about holding financial benefits hostage, it's about creating an environment where people both want to stay and can afford to stay.