Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
He is so out of touch and clueless about IT.

Coding should not be required at school . And I have a development background. Yes we live in a digital age, we don't need to code it ourselves .
Most people won't be chemists either, yet they persist in teaching chemistry. It's not the knowledge per se, but the intellectual development that comes from the process of acquiring that knowledge. Programming requires the development of a kind of logical thinking and problem solving.
 
Sorry, as an Apple fan, I'm looking for great products that just work. I couldn't care less about diversity reports. They can have the most diverse company in the world, but if they're building garbage, what good does that do anyone?
If that was the case, it would do a lot of good for Apple's employees.
 
  • Like
Reactions: doelcm82
I suppose the University College Dublin felt it would be poor taste? Thanks for allowing us to launder your money, here's a doctorate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huck
Tim Cook wants more and more minions to make money from him , just happens that he can take 30% from and developers in a nice AppStore he has.....
You're overlooking the 70% the minions get. For some that could be how they earn their living.
[doublepost=1486614650][/doublepost]
Most people won't be chemists either, yet they persist in teaching chemistry. It's not the knowledge per se, but the intellectual development that comes from the process of acquiring that knowledge. Programming requires the development of a kind of logical thinking and problem solving.
I agree. Learning to program teaches you how to rigorously analyze real-world problems. Without proper analysis your programs will be rubbish. And that will be embarrassingly obvious.

It's the same way that learning to draw teaches you how to observe the world closely. Very closely. And just like programming, if you're an inattentive observer, your drawings will be crap.

It's all about transferable skills.
 
Most people won't be chemists either, yet they persist in teaching chemistry. It's not the knowledge per se, but the intellectual development that comes from the process of acquiring that knowledge. Programming requires the development of a kind of logical thinking and problem solving.
I'm reminded of a high profile Twitter user who doesn't demonstrate much in the way of logical thinking.
[doublepost=1486617606][/doublepost]
At the end, Timmy said to the students:
Man, I feel sorry for you guys since you all have to work your back end off to earn your real degree where I got mine just by ripping people off.
Why would he say that? An honorary degree is more honor than degree. You don't list it in the Education section of your resume.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbital~debris
You're overlooking the 70% the minions get. For some that could be how they earn their living.
[doublepost=1486614650][/doublepost]
I agree. Learning to program teaches you how to rigorously analyze real-world problems. Without proper analysis your programs will be rubbish. And that will be embarrassingly obvious.

It's the same way that learning to draw teaches you how to observe the world closely. Very closely. And just like programming, if you're an inattentive observer, your drawings will be crap.

It's all about transferable skills.

Career wise it's fine.

What we lack teaching is in fact analysis, focus on software development is programming, which in itself is a problem. In the 15 years of software development some of the best people I have worked with , did not code, the coding is the easy bit. Also some of the best problem solvers were not coders, anyway , maths teaches you those basics.
[doublepost=1486620462][/doublepost]
Most people won't be chemists either, yet they persist in teaching chemistry. It's not the knowledge per se, but the intellectual development that comes from the process of acquiring that knowledge. Programming requires the development of a kind of logical thinking and problem solving.

Maths and physics already give you those fundamentals .

What kids really need is to spend more time away from computers and playing sports. Human interaction will teach you relationship building, teamwork etc....

Let me give you A clear example. I have 20 young devs, who missed the point of the following video


A classic video in the agile community .

20 very gifted devs who lack team work and problem solving skills and the ability to acknowledge that like sport you strive as a team to improve. It tends to be a case of problem amplifiers and not not problem solvers . Had these gifted kids played some team sports ....they may have learned something about team work and pushing oneself
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Aldaris
Difficult for an American to get a job when they hire from outside the US so often.

Uuuum, Apple's a global company with global perspectives, mate.

Anyhow, this makes it no easier for me as a foreign national to get a job. Apple (like many other companies) is interested in the BEST employees. To get a head office job from overseas you're essentially gonna have to prove you're better than the best in Silicon Valley.

I know two friends who have worked for Apple:
1. Topped EVRYTHING at Australia's top uni and re-wrote the Darwin kernel for a heap of techie reasons during his honours (first class, Apple ended up implementing most of his changes that he submitted to the Darwin codebase... he essentially schooled all Apple's programmers on how to make a kernel, and wrote a paper on it that got him a uni medal).
2. An American guy with no uni degree. He was essentially in the right place at the right time because Apple bought out a startup that he was working for as a tester. He's freakishly talented BTW, his lack of a degree was more due to the fact his family were poor and he HAD to work to support his extended family from a young age. He's one of the most talented, driven and generous people I know...

That's why it's hard to get good jobs, there's a lot of super smart people who work their butts off!!!

Me? I'm an ex tech lead at a large non-American company and I'm now a relatively senior lawyer (doing IT contracts). I've done well for myself, but my CV has never made it past the initial screening stage for large US-based global IT companies. That's my dream... and if I want it, I'll have to keep working hard because it's REALLY competitive.

People need to get used to the fact that good companies want TALENT, not jobs for lazy locals. Don't blame hard-working foreign nationals for the competitive environment, let them motivate you to work harder. That's my motto... a lot of Aussies love to blame foreign nationals for the fact that they can't get their dream job. As Rev Run said about people who muck around then whinge that they're under-paid... THAT'S THE WAY IT IS... :p
 
Last edited:
Nonsense.

For instance, under Tim, Apple launched a charitable matching program and a global volunteer program, and they've started doing annual diversity reports.

These sorts of things wouldn't have been a priority for Steve, thus clearly having an impact on Apple's corporate culture. And I'm pretty sure that impact is "great".

Is this some kind of a joke, or?
You are comparing IT company innovation to charitable actions and diversity reports? And that helps their products how?

Don't get me wrong. I don't care who makes the products, the team could be made of only americans, or from India, Africa, China and Bangladesh. I really don't care.

But when you want innovation, diversity is a joke. Only a great team, A+++ players are welcomed. It doesn't matter where they are from.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huck and Aldaris
"I met a CEO for the first time that was totally focused on basically one thing: making great products. He had a focus that was unlike any other. His thinking was so pure. He wasn't trying to maximize his wealth or anything else. He really understood the sort of things we work on, and the results that come from those things, and he separated those two."

So TC.. You made it your life's work to undo all of that?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aldaris
I'm reminded of a high profile Twitter user who doesn't demonstrate much in the way of logical thinking.
[doublepost=1486617606][/doublepost]
Why would he say that? An honorary degree is more honor than degree. You don't list it in the Education section of your resume.
You realize that is a joke, right?
 
Uuuum, Apple's a global company with global perspectives, mate.

Anyhow, this makes it no easier for me as a foreign national to get a job. Apple (like many other companies) is interested in the BEST employees. To get a head office job from overseas you're essentially gonna have to prove you're better than the best in Silicon Valley.

I know two friends who have worked for Apple:
1. Topped EVRYTHING at Australia's top uni and re-wrote the Darwin kernel for a heap of techie reasons during his honours (first class, Apple ended up implementing most of his changes that he submitted to the Darwin codebase... he essentially schooled all Apple's programmers on how to make a kernel, and wrote a paper on it that got him a uni medal).
2. An American guy with no uni degree. He was essentially in the right place at the right time because Apple bought out a startup that he was working for as a tester. He's freakishly talented BTW, his lack of a degree was more due to the fact his family were poor and he HAD to work to support his extended family from a young age. He's one of the most talented, driven and generous people I know...

That's why it's hard to get good jobs, there's a lot of super smart people who work their butts off!!!

Me? I'm an ex tech lead at a large non-American company and I'm now a relatively senior lawyer (doing IT contracts). I've done well for myself, but my CV has never made it past the initial screening stage for large US-based global IT companies. That's my dream... and if I want it, I'll have to keep working hard because it's REALLY competitive.

People need to get used to the fact that good companies want TALENT, not jobs for lazy locals. Don't blame hard-working foreign nationals for the competitive environment, let them motivate you to work harder. That's my motto... a lot of Aussies love to blame foreign nationals for the fact that they can't get their dream job. As Rev Run said about people who muck around then whinge that they're under-paid... THAT'S THE WAY IT IS... :p
They're hired in the employees that walk the line between skilled and cheap. When living expenses are much lower in other countries, foreigners coming to the US for tech company work don't need the same salary as domestic, especially Bay Area, skilled workers. Example: someone raised in SF learns that $70k a year is the minimum they'd need to be in the area. Someone raised in (insert foreign Asian country here) would think $70k is more than their parents ever made and wouldn't even ask for anything more than $50k or less.

Trust me. I've got dozens of friends in recruiting at large tech companies. They all see the same thing happen - when a foreign worker will take less money, they get hired almost instantly compared to equally or usually more qualified domestic workers.
 
Sorry, as an Apple fan, I'm looking for great products that just work. I couldn't care less about diversity reports. They can have the most diverse company in the world, but if they're building garbage, what good does that do anyone?

Is this some kind of a joke, or?
You are comparing IT company innovation to charitable actions and diversity reports? And that helps their products how?

The assertion was that "everything great about Apple's culture and products he basically inherited from Jobs". I disagree with the "culture" part of that assertion; he has had quite an impact on Apple's culture.
 
I'm surprised nobody considered asking about MacBook ports.

Apple products are expensive in England so probably nobody in the audience was a Mac user.
[doublepost=1486853207][/doublepost]
Coding should not be required at school . And I have a development background. Yes we live in a digital age, we don't need to code it ourselves .

Agree. Coding is just a blip on the computing radar and will soon be a thing of the past when AI and robots take over.
 
He is so out of touch and clueless about IT.

Coding should not be required at school . And I have a development background. Yes we live in a digital age, we don't need to code it ourselves .

Coding teaches logic, problem solving, and math in application. Why exactly do your kids not need more of this?
[doublepost=1486853689][/doublepost]
Agree. Coding is just a blip on the computing radar and will soon be a thing of the past when AI and robots take over.

"Coding" isn't the hard part, solving problems is. "Coding" is like learning to speak English, solving a useful problem with code is like writing a successful novel.

We may not be banging out hundreds of lines of code for decades into the future, but there will always be new problems to solve.
 
Last edited:
Apple products are expensive in England so probably nobody in the audience was a Mac user.
[doublepost=1486853207][/doublepost]

Agree. Coding is just a blip on the computing radar and will soon be a thing of the past when AI and robots take over.
No that's not true, there would have been many Mac users in the audience. It is a room full of university students and while the price means the market share in England likely isn't as much as the US, it doesn't mean it's non existent. Whether they are users of Type-C MacBooks or not is a different question.
 
They're hired in the employees that walk the line between skilled and cheap. When living expenses are much lower in other countries, foreigners coming to the US for tech company work don't need the same salary as domestic, especially Bay Area, skilled workers. Example: someone raised in SF learns that $70k a year is the minimum they'd need to be in the area. Someone raised in (insert foreign Asian country here) would think $70k is more than their parents ever made and wouldn't even ask for anything more than $50k or less.

Trust me. I've got dozens of friends in recruiting at large tech companies. They all see the same thing happen - when a foreign worker will take less money, they get hired almost instantly compared to equally or usually more qualified domestic workers.

1. It's more expensive to live where I do in Australia compared with just about everywhere in the world.
2. My wife's originally from Vietnam. She speaks perfect English and has multiple degrees from Australia's top 3 unis (which are only beaten by a few Ivy League unis on international rankings). This includes a law degree, a commerce degree and a masters in linguistics. She works for a top-tier firm and gets paid exactly the same as anybody else at her level (if not more) and has the option of working in the USA. Your racial prejudice is a farce...
3. To add to the above, this is LESS than her parents earned in a developing Asian country (where corruption is rife) and has required a LOT more work. They have multiple servants, a heap of property, drive European cars and spend most of their time travelling the world first-class. Again, your assumption that EVERYBODY in Asia is poor is a sick joke. Those who can afford an education in developing countries are (generally speaking) quite wealthy and could live a much more luxurious life in Asia.
4. Apple in particular don't want cheap labour, they want QUALITY. In my experience the best jobs (the ones you want) go to the best applicants. My experience as an IT manager (before I re-trained as a lawyer) was that most of the contractors (regardless of their background) were under-skilled, over-sold themselves and were just after as much money as possible ASAP (rather than wanting career development, and contribute to the culture). Whadda you tell a 'SAP testing expert' with no coding skills who wants an hourly rate of $250? 'Sorry... some dude with coding skills and experience doing auto testing with a range of systems will accept a salary of $85k a year... I think he's a better fit in terms of skills, culture and affordability'.
 
Coding teaches logic, problem solving, and math in application. Why exactly do your kids not need more of this?
[doublepost=1486853689][/doublepost]

"Coding" isn't the hard part, solving problems is. "Coding" is like learning to speak English, solving a useful problem with code is like writing a successful novel.

We may not be banging out hundreds of lines of code for decades into the future, but there will always be new problems to solve.

Interesting you say that , cause the best problem solvers in the industry I found to be business analysts , coders actually have very limited capacity to think outside the box . It's a very shallow view to say coders are problem solvers ... the best problem solvers I found to work in support system , and the skill in fact is quick analysis and coming up with options. Coding does not teach you this

Kids need more social skills these days. If coders did not lack social skills and analysis we would not need BAs And testers .....fact is coders are poor analysts and what if you don't know the problem...good luck solving it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Aldaris
Interesting you say that , cause the best problem solvers in the industry I found to be business analysts , coders actually have very limited capacity to think outside the box . It's a very shallow view to say coders are problem solvers ... the best problem solvers I found to work in support system , and the skill in fact is quick analysis and coming up with options. Coding does not teach you this

Kids need more social skills these days. If coders did not lack social skills and analysis we would not need BAs And testers .....fact is coders are poor analysts and what if you don't know the problem...good luck solving it.

Maybe you guys are hiring cheap labor and getting what you pay for. The top 10 tech companies aren't hiring people like the ones you are trying to describe as "coders". i work on a squad of engineers, physics, and math professionals who all are "coders". We don't have BAs or testers, that work is handled inside the squad.

As for shallow views, I think you are trying to peg all coders as socially inept shut ins, go visit a tech campus, that's not reality.
 
One student asked if he could work at Apple as a tongue-in-cheek question, and Cook noted the company is hiring worldwide and pointed him towards its jobs website.

Lol. Good luck with that. These companies receive 10s of thousands of resumes per month.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.