I think that the average user will try maps, immediately realise that it's unreliable and either try a few more times, or just not use it again. People will not use it if it doesn't come across as reliable.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Tim Cook Publishes Open Letter on Maps for iOS 6
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I think that the average user will try maps, immediately realise that it's unreliable and either try a few more times, or just not use it again. People will not use it if it doesn't come across as reliable.
Depends where you live I guess. Quoted from a Slashdot Story:
In an effort to figure out how innacurate the data in my area is I did the following:
- Fired up Xcode
- Determined that Apple Maps uses the CLGeocoder Class by peeking at the iPhone's debug console in Xcode while doing live searches in Apple Maps
- Scraped an official list of towns and cities in the province of Ontario from the provincial governments website.
- Coded up something quick in Xcode to get the results of a couple thousand searches. Searches always included the province name to be more specific.
- Ran a quick analysis of the results - not perfect but enough to get a perspective on the matter.
This is what I found:
- 2028 cities and towns searched
- 688 are not even on the map! Error Code 8
- 551 are clearly incorrect (wrong country, street names that are similar to town names etc.)
- 389 were close but not good enough (for example turn-by-turn might send you off a bridge but you'll get rescued close to where you want to be)
- Only about 400 results were actually correct.
Actual results data here and methodology here for those interested: http://www.mtonic.com/applemaps/
Oh please. Quit with the drama. It's the right thing to do. And it's not a fair comparison. Cook didn't recommend people purchase a competitors phone! And personally I'm glad Cook isn't a tyrant like Steve was. You don't have to be an ****** for people to respect you.
The apology letter is almost as silly as Apple thinking they can farm out mapping data and easily assemble collections into something that works and competes. It's not that easy. Geospatial data comes from so many different sources and scales of collection and has crazy variability in accuracy and precision. And getting current mapping data is anything but cheap. I think in order for maps to work, Apple needs to become a data service company, not just a connector to 3rd party data services. Clearly they know what google is doing and has done with Google Maps? And I don't think Apple is prepared to be a data service company in that way??
You joined the site on Septemebr 20th and your post history shows nothing but Apple bashing and repeatedly saying "Give us back Google Maps app. NOW" the last few posts.
It might be time for you to get your android phone, then come back with a list of issues you run into. Or you can let me know how perfect it is.
Tim is not responding to criticism. He's himself criticising. He's acknoledging criticism is deserved
.
This is what apologies means.
I don't care if Apple has changed or not. What I care for is that my iOS devices have changed for worse.
Talk is cheap, no one cares how sorry you are, we want a functioning product that works. If your going to block the best (imo) maps product in Google maps native app, then put out a product of equal or greater quality.
Probably not. The Dow is down as well (and so is Google, Amazon, Microsoft for comparison).
How long do you think it takes to make corrections? iOS6 has barely been out a week...
Sometimes acknowledging the faults of your product is more important than stock prices. Stock price will fly right back up as rumors of iPad mini roll in. I applaud Cook for his honesty and willingness to provide alternatives to those who are up in arms. He isn't saying it can't be fixed; he is saying if you don't want to help improve the map data, there are other alternatives.
And that quote is another example of severe hyperbole. Maps works pretty well for many users in the US (other countries have more legitimate reasons to be unhappy), myself included. Calling Maps a "disaster" or "appalling, embarassing, least usable," is patently absurd.
I postulate this as someone who doesn't even like Apple all that much, but these claims are obnoxiously audacious and tiring.
Except that it's slow, the refresh rate of the GPS in Safari can't keep up with normal walking speed, the map doesn't work with the built-in compass, etc...
http://www.engadget.com/2012/09/28/editorial-apple-apologies-actually-arent-that-infrequent-and/
Editorial: Apple apologies actually aren't that infrequent, and that's okay
Editorial: Apple apologies actually aren't that infrequent, and that's okay
This is just a little quote from this article. One article I agree with 100%. It takes a real person to remove your head from the sand, admit what you made does not cut the mustard and promise to make it better. Very few companies do this currently. I do wish a lot more did though.
How hard would it be for them to put out an ios6 fix to reinstate Google Maps side by side with Apple Maps (even though it lacks turn-by-turn) and remove it down the road? That would certainly stop the discussions around the globe and then incrementally provide Apple maps releases.
ah, another "Steve Job would never!" numb-nutter. unless you actually do know what he would have done because you were close personal friends?
because jobs released plenty of crummy or half-baked items: the hockey puck mouse, MobileMe Final Cut Pro X, Ping, etc...
Ok - let me rephrase. I wonder how many people searched and got wrong information.
What if turn by turn takes you off a bridge?
Here's an interesting look at the problem: http://www.mtonic.com/applemaps/
You joined the site on Septemebr 20th and your post history shows nothing but Apple bashing and repeatedly saying "Give us back Google Maps app. NOW" the last few posts.
It might be time for you to get your android phone, then come back with a list of issues you run into. Or you can let me know how perfect it is.
Your post history shows nothing but fancying Apple shortcomings when the slightest touch of criticism is raised. It seems the way you spell poor is g r e a t.
I don't intend to get an Android phone (unless you buy me one) because I already own 3 iPhones and I want them to work as properly as they're supposed to and as they used to.
Give us back Google Maps app. NOW
We must be talking about different companies. There might have been negative instances that happened with Apple but they are extremely small and sparse in comparison to their successes. As far as I know, they have a much better record than most companies.