Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
…I saw many pictures in October/November showing issues with phones assembled in India. Scratches out of the box etc.
I’m quite surprised by this.

Yes it’s consistent with my experience in manufacturing in India (though the higher up the “stack” you go the less common such defects become)! But Apple’s fanaticism for product quality and in particular for fit and finish, plus and the number of Apple personnel they have embedded in supposedly third party manufacturing sites makes, this seem unlikely to me.

Note I don’t have any experience in Apple manufacturing anywhere, much less Foxconn so what do I know? But I have talked casually with various former Apple low-level mfg folks who spent a lot of time embedded at Foxconn.
 
Makes sense I guess, but what is the Apple vs Android split these days? So many handsets out there than just top 10.
Worldwide userbase is ~70% Android & ~29% iPhone.

In terms of smartphone profits it is ~85% iPhone & the rest Android.

It is a shrewd move for Apple to follow the Pareto Principle. Doing so avoids any anti-trust investigation as in terms of active devices or active users they're the minority.

And yet their profit margins allows them get >80% of smartphone profits. The share that actually matters.

So Apple's competitors & govts looks for loopholes which is the the App Store & even iMessage.
 
Last edited:
I do not believe the companies research because it is not statically possible when it is a matter of fact that Android mobile phones have approximately 70% of the mobile phone market. This means consumers are buying way way more Android phones than Apple but yet we are expected to believe that with the merge market share that Apple has that they hold the top 7 slots of the global mobile phone market!!!, sorry, not possible because if it was possible, Apple's market share would be way way more than what it is but it isn't.
The iPhones alone account for about 20%. Now going by your 70%, share that amongst the uncountable Android manufacturers and their even-more uncountable models and tell us what share each model gets to compete with, say, iPhone 14.
 
It's wild to me that the most popular Android smartphones on this list are all budget models. I would have expected to see at least one flagship, or even a mid-ranger. 😮
 
Is this data limited to Apple and Samsung?

Reason I ask is because I bet the cheap Android phones are probably way above these expensive phones.
 
Is this data limited to Apple and Samsung?

Reason I ask is because I bet the cheap Android phones are probably way above these expensive phones.

Is there a reason you believe that or a model you have in mind? Or are you just lumping every cheap android phone into a single line item and calling it a competing model?
 
All iPhone 15 would have much better sales if they were assembled fully by China. I saw many pictures in October/November showing issues with phones assembled in India. Scratches out of the box etc. I’m not surprised that sales of 15 is not better.
And not a single Huawei or ZTE phone on the list. Isn’t that a surprise?
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: Qubelek
Makes sense I guess, but what is the Apple vs Android split these days? So many handsets out there than just top 10.

This can vary significantly by country but according to Statcounter, the global mobile OS market share for Android is around 70% and around 30% for iOS. In Japan, for example, it's more like 68% iOS and 32% Android.
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: gusmula and LeeW
It's wild to me that the most popular Android smartphones on this list are all budget models. I would have expected to see at least one flagship, or even a mid-ranger. 😮

The list is for GLOBAL and not the US or other rich nation.

Everything written below is for GLOBAL market share & not just your rich or poor country.

Relative to Samsung & other major Android brands, Apple has few smartphone SKUs and primarily caters $429-1599 price points.

Android monopolizes the sub-$429 smartphone market.

For $429-1599 price points all the Android brands likely have ~50% share with ~50% of Apple.

This setup's ideal for Apple as the number of active devices they have does not qualify their platform as a anti-trust or even a monopoly.

And yet they take home ~85% of all smartphone profits.

Makes you wish you could go back to the tail end of the 2007–2008 financial crisis in 20 Jan 2009 and bought $AAPL at its 2 decade low.

Buy 4,000 Apple shares at $78.20/share for a total of $312,800.00 and today's portfolio value would be $20,345,920.00 at $181.58/share. Quarterly div for more than a decade would be $25,760.00.
 
This can vary significantly by country but according to Statcounter, the global mobile OS market share for Android is around 70% and around 30% for iOS. In Japan, for example, it's more like 68% iOS and 32% Android.
... and around 60% iOS / 40% Android here in the US.
 
I do not believe the companies research because it is not statically possible when it is a matter of fact that Android mobile phones have approximately 70% of the mobile phone market. This means consumers are buying way way more Android phones than Apple but yet we are expected to believe that with the merge market share that Apple has that they hold the top 7 slots of the global mobile phone market!!!, sorry, not possible because if it was possible, Apple's market share would be way way more than what it is but it isn't.
The list shows top 10 best selling individual phone models... The iPhones were (according to the list) the best selling phones. Android has a much greater share of the market but also ~3000 times more different models of phones that run Android, which of course divides the attention of the market and makes every Android phone capture less individual shares of the market because of the sheer volume of other Android phones each model has to compete with.

Note on the statistic I mentioned: 3000x comes from the official Android website where they state there are currently "24k+ distinct devices" - rounding to 24,000 i just divided that number by 8 (the number of models apple is selling) to get 3000 times more models of Android phones than iPhones.
 
I do not believe the companies research because it is not statically possible when it is a matter of fact that Android mobile phones have approximately 70% of the mobile phone market. This means consumers are buying way way more Android phones than Apple but yet we are expected to believe that with the merge market share that Apple has that they hold the top 7 slots of the global mobile phone market!!!, sorry, not possible because if it was possible, Apple's market share would be way way more than what it is but it isn't.

To support @c_nn_r the number of active smartphone brands is down to almost 250 in 2023 so far from over 700 in 2017.

If you live in the US the smartphone brands you are exposed to are

1704888398-us-smartphone-market-share.png


Have you fellas hear of Cherry Mobile or myPhone? How about Micromax? Symphony? vivo? OPPO?

GLOBALLY these are the 6 dominant smartphone companies

yEL07_n4kfGHETZ18_RCBOB0gpfHM5wk.jpg


So 24,000 distinct smartphones ÷ 700 Android brands = about 34 distinct smartphones per brand. Quantities produced could be as little as 150,000 units.


Another thing to consider is the % of the global smartphone market the iPhone 14 shipped for. It is less than 4%.

If you add up all 7 iPhones then it comes out as nearly 16%

Share-of-Global-Top-10-Best-selling-Smartphones-2023.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Chuckeee
the key part of this data chart is the word mentioned at the bottom of the chart.
which says it reflects "Sell-Through".

sell through normally indicates sales to retail level customers.
ive gone to the data source site and there is no mention of how many shops and exactly where these shops (countries, cities, etc) are located (other than the specific mention of the data includes points in the usa and china).

the methodology most likely uses a selected (limited) number of shops in "several" countries which typically are large size electronics goods shops, which have agreed to provide sales information for the survey.

there is only one way to know if this info is credible. that involves following several cycles of the source's reports and correlating the results to other reports that use different methodology.

for people who reject the data in this report due to the often repeated and generally held "70% android / 30% apple" world wide market share view, sell through data will always favour apple since it doesn't dump phones into the trade (like all chinese and korean branded phones) where wholesale level sales are counted as "sales". versus end-customer level sales.
apple (especially Tim Cook !) is excellent at managing inventory to almost completely never need to "buy back" trade inventory, as all other smart phone companies do.

this report's data and the 70/30 market share data could both be true at the same time.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Abazigal
I’m quite surprised by this.

Yes it’s consistent with my experience in manufacturing in India (though the higher up the “stack” you go the less common such defects become)! But Apple’s fanaticism for product quality and in particular for fit and finish, plus and the number of Apple personnel they have embedded in supposedly third party manufacturing sites makes, this seem unlikely to me.

Note I don’t have any experience in Apple manufacturing anywhere, much less Foxconn so what do I know? But I have talked casually with various former Apple low-level mfg folks who spent a lot of time embedded at Foxconn.
And? They told you they didn’t damage any phone before closing it in a box? Ok, then it probably mean then really didn’t 😉 cmon. You just need to use google to see I’m telling you the truth about India assembly:

 
  • Disagree
Reactions: Chuckeee
And not a single Huawei or ZTE phone on the list. Isn’t that a surprise?
You don't know that iPhones are assembled in China and India or you wanted to say something else but I don’t get it if it’s something else. Who cares about huawei or ZTE?
 
And? They told you they didn’t damage any phone before closing it in a box? Ok, then it probably mean then really didn’t 😉 cmon. You just need to use google to see I’m telling you the truth about India assembly:

Published: Sep 24, 2023, 12:21 PM

If it is overheating issue then I think it is resolved by iOS 17.3.1
 
Published: Sep 24, 2023, 12:21 PM

If it is overheating issue then I think it is resolved by iOS 17.3.1
What are you talking about xD We are talking here about dirt on the lenses and scratched phones out of the box of phones assembled in India. I’m just pointing out what others tweeted and what I’ve found on google. It’s not just my opinion.
 
What are you talking about xD We are talking here about dirt on the lenses and scratched phones out of the box of phones assembled in India. I’m just pointing out what others tweeted and what I’ve found on google. It’s not just my opinion.
Ah... I didn't read the link ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Qubelek
Wonder how much of an influence carrier discounts potentially had on overall sales?

Not that I understand much about these things but I’ve noticed a few more offers here in the UK (incl. new models) compared to previous years.
 
Buy 4,000 Apple shares at $78.20/share for a total of $312,800.00 and today's portfolio value would be $20,345,920.00 at $181.58/share. Quarterly div for more than a decade would be $25,760.00.
I bought in just before the spit in 2014. has performed well for me. up 400% on my 200 shares.
 
  • Love
Reactions: aj_niner
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.