As a "Mac Elitist" and “mobile phone power user” I feel more than qualified to speak about the pros and cons of the iPhone vs. Blackberry and whole GPS issue. I've got them all iPhone, BB Curve and BB Bold.
When the iPhone introduced I wanted one like Ralphie Parker wanted the "Red Rider BB Gun". No one desired this piece of technology more but it would seem that my boys at Mac went soft, choosing mass consumption over innovation; flash over substance. The iPhone has become nothing more than the "poser phone" of the decade and we, the willing consumer, all blindly bought.
Here are a couple of points to consider and if for no other reason its going to drive some of the iPhone devotees into a cataleptic rage.
GPS- It doesn't have it and yet AT&T along with Apple made us believe it does. Cell tower triangulation is not GPS so you can create an app all day long but unless those programs can read a line of site satellite it's just Google maps with nice graphics.
The GPS system became operational in 1993 and that was prior to the planning phase of the iPhone. I find hard to believe that as the elite design team sat around sipping their double espressos and comparing their henna tattoos the idea of including a GPS receiver didn't come up. Logic would lead us to the conclusion it was intentionally left out so we would continue upgrade.
Remember the first rule of marketing, “A Need is a learned Wand.” Lets continue to follow the logic and see what else was left out...
Spell check- my blackberry curve has it so where is it on my iPhone. Oh it's coming with the next version because "Apple really listens to their customers and now that you’ve got the latest 3G their going to add it." Can you imagine the freakish little guy with way to much product in his hair bringing that one up to Jobs. "Oh Commander, My Commander. Shouldn't we include spell check? I mean it's already in the operating system." Of course we know the answer. "NO" says Jobs, "make them want it. We'll roll that out with version 3 or maybe 7."
Push email- Mobile ME to the rescue for an additional $100 a year. There is of course Microsoft exchange but if you don't have it then your back to square one. This I found out from iPhone support at Apple.
We all know the battery issues and the need to continually hunt for electricity. Be sure not to leave the house with your WiFi on or use a bluetooth headset for more than two minutes. Of course you have no choice but to use a headset because of the wonderfully rich glass screen that cuts a line into your ear making each call over 5 minutes a real commitment to pain. The iPhone is meant for anything and everything accept making a call.
Please don't misunderstand my angst but after putting this device through it's paces it falls into the category of iMovie and LiveType. They are wonderful programs that make the average consumer feel creative by eliminating options. I gladly use these programs and believe their million times better than any Microsoft product but when I want to edit a movie I use Final Cut Pro and After Effects not iMovie and LiveType. iPhone has become an App factory meant to suck more cash out of us while creating an non-social generation with thumbs that can lift a small car.
Final thought/irritation and I don't mean to pile on but is it to much to ask for "cut and paste". For some clarity on that lets try to decipher the reasoning of the crack design team on this one. The reality is I've got a screen that will zoom, rotate, knows orientation and even knows when i've got the blasted thing next to my ear; pretty cool technology. So was it impossible to include "cut and paste"? Next time you want to move info to your "GPS assisted" GOOGLE MAPS, you might want to have a good memory or a pen handy because you can't cut and paste it. (Of course there is an app for it and it only costs ______.)
Now if you want to watch movies, pick a restaurant or know the proper way to exercise your thumbs while lifting weights at the gym then the iphone is for you. But if you need your email "NOW" and would like to know preciously where you are and how to get where you're going then you might find the iPhone a little hit-and-miss. When I say "hit-n-miss" this wonderful piece of programmed technology placed me in the LA reservoir twice last week.
Before I forget. In a recent post on this site someone asked the question, “is the BB Bold pretty?” Not really but neither are most of it's users. Remember BB owners are professional phone users who need vital information not iTunes latest "U2" essentials download.
I'm sure I'm going to hear from those of you who are red-faced and unable to collect your thoughts but I needed to get this off my chest and who knows maybe a design person from Apple will read it and realize they could do better.
DarsMind
Professional Phone User and Creative Professional
(Quad G5, MacBook Pro, PowerMac G4, PowerMac G3 and lot of crap made by Apple.)