Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This is so lame. Still no 4K yet. I wouldn’t be surprised if it takes months to get this feature ... halfway to TvOS 15
 
  • Like
Reactions: kirbisi
Yes, Apple should support VP9, but YouTube should also deliver in H.265. The same argument can be made on both counts. So be upset with YouTube for not supporting an established standard!

Why should Google pay h.265 license for free YouTube content? That makes zero business sense and the reason why royalty free codecs like VP9 exist. Another case of Apple abusing their customers as pawns. Smart consumers buy the Fire TV Stick 4K when on sale for $30 that has all the codecs including VP9, has internet browser, can run Retroarch, etc. that are all lacking on the more expensive Apple TV.
 
Smart consumers buy the Fire TV Stick 4K when on sale for $30 that has all the codecs including VP9, has internet browser, can run Retroarch, etc. that are all lacking on the more expensive Apple TV.

I guess the option is there to buy zero Apple products and do all your web browsing with a fire stick on your TV.
I could never get a fire stick to play my 1200+ iTunes movies though. So I’ll stay a pawn with my expensive Apple TV.
 
It is a big deal to me. You’re essentially telling me to throw out 1200 movies because you say so. Why would I do that?
If Apple TV is available on Fire OS than it means you can view your (formerly iTunes) library on there directly.

I still prefer the Apple TV hardware for the playback capabilities. Dynamic range and frame rate matching, Dolby Vision, and support for almost any legitimate service. It also won’t overheat while playing back content like some of the cheapest devices do.
 
If Apple TV is available on Fire OS than it means you can view your (formerly iTunes) library on there directly.

I still prefer the Apple TV hardware for the playback capabilities. Dynamic range and frame rate matching, Dolby Vision, and support for almost any legitimate service. It also won’t overheat while playing back content like some of the cheapest devices do.
Everything you just said is why I’m perfectly happy with my Apple TV. I doubt my 500+ 4K iTunes movies would play on a fire stick in 4K with Dolby vision/ atmos and frame matching. And even if they did I like the ATV interface. When my Sony TV is updated later this year to have the ATV+ app I will still use my Apple TV.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jasonefmonk
Agree, I have Fire Tv Cube, Xiaomi Box (Android TV), ATV4K, and the native webOS on my TV all hooked up to my LG OLED and the ATV4K blows them all out of the water for video processing, user interface, and getting channels/apps day 1 (peacock and HBO Max not on fire tv for instance though you can side load)
 
  • Like
Reactions: jasonefmonk
Agree, I have Fire Tv Cube, Xiaomi Box (Android TV), ATV4K, and the native webOS on my TV all hooked up to my LG OLED and the ATV4K blows them all out of the water for video processing, user interface, and getting channels/apps day 1 (peacock and HBO Max not on fire tv for instance though you can side load)
OLED high five - I have a Sony OLED and it's breathtaking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jus711
Ok this might be good news or not, but in tvOS 4.2 public beta (18K5036d) Youtube app version 2.05.01 4k videos automatically play at 4k (at least as long as they are vp9) sorry no screen caps,Ii have not got a capture card sorry. We will have to wait and see if this remains when 14.2 hits full public release, but stil no bt.2020 or hdr, well I did not search wery long so maybe there arre videos out there
 
Last edited:
Ok this might be good news or not, but in tvOS 4.2 public beta (18K5036d) Youtube app version 2.05.01 4k videos automatically play at 4k (at least as long as they are vp9) sorry no screen caps,Ii have not got a capture card sorry. We will have to wait and see if this remaines when 14.2 hitys full public release

that’s pretty cool. Thanks for the update. 14.2 might be a few weeks away assuming the next phone will ship with 14.1 but good to know it’s working.
 
Ok this might be good news or not, but in tvOS 4.2 public beta (18K5036d) Youtube app version 2.05.01 4k videos automatically play at 4k (at least as long as they are vp9)

sorry, no confirmation for that. Still 1080p vc1 and no vp9.

Sample YT-Link please
 
  • Like
Reactions: gregsapphire
I’m still 1080p max here with tvOS 14.2.
Perhaps it’s a staggered release or a premium only feature.

I’m seeing more people report it’s working on Twitter and Reddit.
 
I really hadn't thought about 4K Youtube on Apple TV, to be honest. I've pretty much settled on Roku as my main go to player as they are neutral and really don't have the licensing and other conflicts that direct competitors have. With this said: I have both an Apple TV HD, and Apple TV 4k, for specific apple related things. However, from a tv and movie only prospective, since Apple TV is now on Roku, the only reason to have a physical Apple TV box these days is for the apps, and Apple Music, and Homekit, if you use your Apple TV for that.

As I said though, I have multiple platforms, because I find it's the best solution in the end. Even in 2020 no one device can do everything, or does everything perfectly.

Roku is “neutral”? Can you explain the Peacock and HBO Max debacles? Roku finally caved when NBC threatened to pull all of their apps from the platform...
 
Why should Google pay h.265 license for free YouTube content? That makes zero business sense and the reason why royalty free codecs like VP9 exist. Another case of Apple abusing their customers as pawns. Smart consumers buy the Fire TV Stick 4K when on sale for $30 that has all the codecs including VP9, has internet browser, can run Retroarch, etc. that are all lacking on the more expensive Apple TV.

Buy the Fire TV stick and get no Peacock or HBO Max? Smart...
 
sorry, no confirmation for that. Still 1080p vc1 and no vp9.

Sample YT-Link please
come tomthink of it you might need to force it to 4k via the pull up menu. Other oeople might be right about staggered roolout and/ or it being a premium feature ( but I cant see why as iI cant see why yr wants to limiy 4k to oremium only, esp if it’s only on tvos unless it is to further push android as a cheap os)
Update: tested with a guest account (ie nopremium) and 4K vp9 is still there so just a staggered roll out, btw do you have the latest tvos beta
 
Last edited:
Roku is “neutral”? Can you explain the Peacock and HBO Max debacles? Roku finally caved when NBC threatened to pull all of their apps from the platform...
That I wasn't aware of, mainly because I don't use those services. What I was going by was information I had several years ago when looking at streaming provider / hardware comparisons. One of the points made at THAT particular time was Roku being a more neutral platform, and providing the hardware and environment for different vendors to bring their content to.

I'll admit I haven't kept up with company practices in a while. So it's possible the information I had at one point is now out of date. I do follow Cord Cutters News: mainly on YouTube, I probably need to go back and look at some more recent episodes. Typically with me, I'll get the info I need, then stop following what's going on, until I need some more info. This can sometimes be years between so again, I'm probably out of date here.
 
+1 , no success
Odd have you checked if you have tvos 14.2 build 18K5036d (setings/system/software update). That is the only version i can say anything about as it is the only version I’ve got working 4k youtube on. Other than a build miss match or a staggered 4k rollout I’m out of ideas
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.