I come from a Sony P800, then P900, then P910 and later the amazing Nokia 7710, which, btw, actually has the REAL internet experience... The keyboards were so much better and you could type with your nails, if necessary. The iPhone only recognizes skin touching...
In my experience with the above, I still disagree. Not in the same league.
Plastic buttons will go the way of the Edsel. I understand the fingernail concern though if you have long nails, but then you couldn't play piano, guitar, violin or any delicate instrument with long nails, at least not very well. The skin touching is one of the best features. Also not sure what you mean by the real internet experience...I'll take Safari anyday over some crippled mini app.