Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
My MacBook Air and my retina MacBook are running the same software, so it's not software.

The main difference? Hardware, specifically the retina screen.
It is the software. The hardware is powerful enough. However, OS X doesn't make as good a use of the GPU as Windows 10.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mcmeowmers
It's OS X. That lag has been present since Mavericks or so when they added transparency effects. Simply disable that and it's smooth... Not the answer you were hoping for.
 
It's OS X. That lag has been present since Mavericks or so when they added transparency effects. Simply disable that and it's smooth... Not the answer you were hoping for.
I'll try that. But doesn't it look ugly then?
 
I'll try that. But doesn't it look ugly then?
IMHO yea, I'm a fan of the transparency, but if it alleviates the issue then it blows your "hardware not powerful enough for a retina screen" theory right out of the water.
 
Because in HiDPI / Retina mode, you have a gorgeous screen, but a screen that renders at 2880*1800 (for the more space option) - twice the size the MBA has to render, or 2560x1600 (for the default) - twice the size the non-retina MBP has to render.

That's not twice the size, it's 4 times the pixels (twice horizontally, twice vertically)
 
  • Like
Reactions: SchodMC
Okay; thanks for your input.
[doublepost=1464035741][/doublepost]

Doesn't that remove the entire advantage of the retina display, i.e., the gorgeous display?
Perhaps. It looks better with the pre set resolution. I'll stick with it tbh
 
Lmao! At above

Yeah it kind of looks ugly imo.

I wish you could set other resolutions that wouldn't cause fonts to be rendered rediculously ugly, jagged, and too small.
 
Well i got some good news for me at least. The forum lag is gone. I searched the forum and found that the solution to the lag was solved by changing the background to plain grey
 
Lmao! At above

Yeah it kind of looks ugly imo.

I wish you could set other resolutions that wouldn't cause fonts to be rendered rediculously ugly, jagged, and too small.

You can with this hack. I'm running 1536x960 with HiDPI and I find that it really is the sweet spot in terms of screen estate and font size.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 997440
It is the software. The hardware is powerful enough. However, OS X doesn't make as good a use of the GPU as Windows 10.

So how does that explain that my MBA runs smoothly and my rMB less so, regarding animations in UI?
[doublepost=1464122453][/doublepost]
IMHO yea, I'm a fan of the transparency, but if it alleviates the issue then it blows your "hardware not powerful enough for a retina screen" theory right out of the water.

That's not true. If you disable some of the requirements it actually demonstrates that the hardware couldn't pull it off.
[doublepost=1464122496][/doublepost]
Well i got some good news for me at least. The forum lag is gone. I searched the forum and found that the solution to the lag was solved by changing the background to plain grey

That's very interesting to me; and I must say that I'm skeptical. What was your background previously?
 
So how does that explain that my MBA runs smoothly and my rMB less so, regarding animations in UI?
The MBA has a lower resolution screen that doesn't tax the GPU as much. So it renders OK even with OS X's sub-optimal use of the GPU. A fairer comparison would be Windows 10 in Boot Camp vs OS X. The former would get better GPU performance while the latter gets better battery life. Microsoft and Apple focus on different things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mcmeowmers
The MBA has a lower resolution screen that doesn't tax the GPU as much. So it renders OK even with OS X's sub-optimal use of the GPU.

Yeah, that's what I think too. It bums me out that Apple is willing to accept degradation in performance with the retina models. =(
 
So how does that explain that my MBA runs smoothly and my rMB less so, regarding animations in UI?
[doublepost=1464122453][/doublepost]

That's not true. If you disable some of the requirements it actually demonstrates that the hardware couldn't pull it off.
[doublepost=1464122496][/doublepost]

That's very interesting to me; and I must say that I'm skeptical. What was your background previously?
I had the grey flowers
 
You can with this hack. I'm running 1536x960 with HiDPI and I find that it really is the sweet spot in terms of screen estate and font size.

Wait whhhattt! Is the text readable and not some jaggy mess when you pick a custom resolution?
[doublepost=1464139280][/doublepost]
So how does that explain that my MBA runs smoothly and my rMB less so, regarding animations in UI?
[doublepost=1464122453][/doublepost]

That's not true. If you disable some of the requirements it actually demonstrates that the hardware couldn't pull it off.
[doublepost=1464122496][/doublepost]

That's very interesting to me; and I must say that I'm skeptical. What was your background previously?


I would guess that with a solid background simplifies the algorithm apple uses for transparency allowing for fewer calculations
 
Wait whhhattt! Is the text readable and not some jaggy mess when you pick a custom resolution?

Yes. HiDPI means it uses the built-in DPI scaling engine, rather than just running the screen at a non-native resolution that RDM and other tools normally do. It's as sharp as at 1440x900, but slightly smaller, so you get more screen estate. 1680x1050 is also an option, but I found it to be a bit too small for my liking, although you can quickly switch using RDM (it adds new 1536x900 HiDPI and 1680x1050 HiDPI options).
 
Yes. HiDPI means it uses the built-in DPI scaling engine, rather than just running the screen at a non-native resolution that RDM and other tools normally do. It's as sharp as at 1440x900, but slightly smaller, so you get more screen estate. 1680x1050 is also an option, but I found it to be a bit too small for my liking, although you can quickly switch using RDM (it adds new 1536x900 HiDPI and 1680x1050 HiDPI options).

Thank you so much for this!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.