Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
V-MODA vibe headphones incompatible with iPhone 4?
- Thread starter illyanadmc
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
i guess i should call them. i don't have proof of purchase anymore, though, so i don't know how they're going to verify when i bought the headphones.
Yep my Vibe Duos dont work with my iphone 4 - well the button doesnt anyway.
Bought a pair of Vibe Remix Remotes from iheadphones.co.uk which came yesterday, very happy with them, the buttons are great and the mic quality is pretty good, and the sound is just as good as before, if not better (i'm not really an audiophile).
recommend as an upgrade, although i want the over-head crossfades for christmas
Bought a pair of Vibe Remix Remotes from iheadphones.co.uk which came yesterday, very happy with them, the buttons are great and the mic quality is pretty good, and the sound is just as good as before, if not better (i'm not really an audiophile).
recommend as an upgrade, although i want the over-head crossfades for christmas
2 iPhones 4 here (let's call A and B), with 2 Vibe Duo (one Black, one Chrome) and 1 Vibe II. I'm having the exact same problems as reported here: buttons don't always work, click-click-click sound when on a call.
Here's the conclusions of my tests:
Vibe II
- Despite v-moda says Vibe II is not compatible with iPhone 4 as pointed above, it worked perfectly here with both iPhone A and B.
- No clicking sound, buttons stop/start music properly, hang-up calls, etc.
Tests with Vibe Duo Black:
- Worked flawlessly on iPhone A - no clicking, button working as expected.
- Failed miserably on iPhone B. Button randomly changes volume or skips music, phone calls with clicking sound.
- Interestingly, on the same iPhone B the clicking sound stops when I pull the plug a tiny bit. Initially I thought it could be something with the metal on the end of the plug touching the antenna, but upon close inspection I noticed it doesn't seem to be the case. It has no effect over the buttons (ie, pulling a bit doesn't help).
Tests with Vibe Duo Chrome:
- Failed miserably on iPhone A.
- Button didn't work on iPhone B, but at least there was no clicking sound.
- on iPhone A, same as above: pulling off a bit stopped the clicking sound.
My takeaways so far:
1) seems the headphone button circuitry is pushing the limits of tolerance on the iPhone 4, and that's why it works on some combinations of headphone/iPhone but not others.
2) the click-click sound is clearly a problem on the design of the headphone plug on v-moda and/or the socket on the iPhone. That's why pulling off a bit stops the clicking bug. Absolutely nothing to do with noise cancellation mic as some other users pointed out.
Next step would be to do some electrical tests to understand what's the difference between the two headphones to figure out why it works on one but doesn't on the other. Anyone has the hardware specs for a headphone? What exactly is the signal that is sent when someone presses the button?
Any additional info would be highly appreciated. All the 3 headphones are fairly new so I could opt-in for v-moda upgrade program, but shelling out $30 (for each headphone) for what seems to be a design flaw on the iPhone 4 seems ridiculous to me. C'mon, why Apple didn't test the freaking device with different headphone models? How difficult can it be?
** UPDATE: Seems I spoke too soon. Upon further testing I discovered that despite not hearing the click-click when using the Vibe Duo with iPhone A, in fact the other person could still hear the noise and the voice sounded really bad. So, bottom line is: neither Vibe Duo work. The only functional is really the Vibe II, and seems to be pure luck. Impressive.
Here's the conclusions of my tests:
Vibe II
- Despite v-moda says Vibe II is not compatible with iPhone 4 as pointed above, it worked perfectly here with both iPhone A and B.
- No clicking sound, buttons stop/start music properly, hang-up calls, etc.
Tests with Vibe Duo Black:
- Worked flawlessly on iPhone A - no clicking, button working as expected.
- Failed miserably on iPhone B. Button randomly changes volume or skips music, phone calls with clicking sound.
- Interestingly, on the same iPhone B the clicking sound stops when I pull the plug a tiny bit. Initially I thought it could be something with the metal on the end of the plug touching the antenna, but upon close inspection I noticed it doesn't seem to be the case. It has no effect over the buttons (ie, pulling a bit doesn't help).
Tests with Vibe Duo Chrome:
- Failed miserably on iPhone A.
- Button didn't work on iPhone B, but at least there was no clicking sound.
- on iPhone A, same as above: pulling off a bit stopped the clicking sound.
My takeaways so far:
1) seems the headphone button circuitry is pushing the limits of tolerance on the iPhone 4, and that's why it works on some combinations of headphone/iPhone but not others.
2) the click-click sound is clearly a problem on the design of the headphone plug on v-moda and/or the socket on the iPhone. That's why pulling off a bit stops the clicking bug. Absolutely nothing to do with noise cancellation mic as some other users pointed out.
Next step would be to do some electrical tests to understand what's the difference between the two headphones to figure out why it works on one but doesn't on the other. Anyone has the hardware specs for a headphone? What exactly is the signal that is sent when someone presses the button?
Any additional info would be highly appreciated. All the 3 headphones are fairly new so I could opt-in for v-moda upgrade program, but shelling out $30 (for each headphone) for what seems to be a design flaw on the iPhone 4 seems ridiculous to me. C'mon, why Apple didn't test the freaking device with different headphone models? How difficult can it be?
** UPDATE: Seems I spoke too soon. Upon further testing I discovered that despite not hearing the click-click when using the Vibe Duo with iPhone A, in fact the other person could still hear the noise and the voice sounded really bad. So, bottom line is: neither Vibe Duo work. The only functional is really the Vibe II, and seems to be pure luck. Impressive.
Temp fimple fix for V-moda and iPhone 4
Place a few small pieces of scotch tape, or a piece of electrical tape across the headphone input of the iPhone 4. With an exacto knife carefully cut out only the hole thru the tape. This will keep the headphones from grounding. Initial tests show that the microphone now works when on a call; headphones for music still fine, but the button will not answer or end call, and will not pause music (it only makes the volume go up or down a bit). At least it's a workaround so you can listen to music AND make calls. I suppose putting some whiteout or liquid rubber (or paint) across the top of the input will work as well
Place a few small pieces of scotch tape, or a piece of electrical tape across the headphone input of the iPhone 4. With an exacto knife carefully cut out only the hole thru the tape. This will keep the headphones from grounding. Initial tests show that the microphone now works when on a call; headphones for music still fine, but the button will not answer or end call, and will not pause music (it only makes the volume go up or down a bit). At least it's a workaround so you can listen to music AND make calls. I suppose putting some whiteout or liquid rubber (or paint) across the top of the input will work as well
The best option you have right now is to search for the compactable headphone for your iphone as that may help you to enjoy the ultimate musical experience in the long run. So, before you buy do lookout for the great deals available on headphone online.