Applejuiced
macrumors Westmere
Has been for years, great. Things change though. Look at the major reinvention of revenue Verizon has created by moving from tiered minute/text plans to tiered data plans, grandfathering old plans, and restrictions on grandfathering that have *NEVER* happened before like the unlimited data feature loss debacle. Just because it has been a certain way is not really enough reason to believe things won't change.
That said, my evidence to believe that there would be an issue with the new-line-upgrade-and-dumbphone-switcheroo-downgrade system isn't the strongest, either:
In the last 6 months, in all sorts of retail levels, little tags and blurbs have appeared on pricing stating a requirement of a data plan at $XX, alongside normally standard requirement of a 24-month commitment, which would seem to more say that it's the data plan required for the commitment moreso than the data plan required for the phone.
But I could just be looking into it a bit too deeply. Maybe the switcheroo-downgrade will work without a hitch.
That said, even if it works through mostly-automated channels, all it would take would be one savvy and overly-concerned customer service agent or supervisor realizing what you've done and putting a visible note on your account to give you lots of problems with this approach.
Nonetheless, the switcheroo-downgrade is pretty smart.
You are looking into it way too deeply.
Relax and Just Do It like Nike says
There's nothing illegal or anything on your contract that prohibits such thing.
People update and automaticly sell their new phone all the time. Swap upgrades with other people etc... People lose, break or get their iphones stolen all the time. They dont make them keep an iphone data plan on their account for the next 23 months if they're not even using an iphone any more.
You're still tied in for 24 months on that new line you created.