Just got off the phone with Amazon and was able to talk to a more competent CSR. I told her the problem, and they are shipping me a new 2011 MBP as we speak. She also said this has been happening frequently with their MBPs and that they are currently investigating the issues. They think it is a group in the one of the warehouses who are buying 2010's and swapping them with 2011's then selling them.
Anyways, I should have my new 2011 15" MBP on tuesday or wednesday.
Glad it is resolved, hopefully they double check before it goes out!