Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Apple's new Vision Pro headset can scan a user's face and use advanced machine learning to create a photorealistic "Persona" of them for video calls. And in a future visionOS update, these avatars will become even more realistic.

Vision-Pro-Spatial-Personas.jpg
Spatial Persona on Vision Pro​
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michaelgtrusa
I don’t want to interact with peoples’ personas, I want to interact with them as they actually are. Especially people I’m close to, children and grandchildren come to mind. I want them to interact with me as well.
Agreed! Human communication and interaction are very important and essential. It's also too valuable! Time is precious. All this is pretty much leading to this:

1686150562987.png
 
#2creepy4me
Would you rather the person you are talking to over face time see you wearing the Vision Pro? This is a well thought out trade off. Of course, its not gonna be 100% replica of you or your behaviors which might be a good or bad thing. But it does remove the awkwardness of being able to interact with you and see your gestures. I hope Apple will make it optional to train the persona: goofy face, mourning, sadness, silly, anger, boredom, busy, concerned, joyful, excited, disbelief, annoyed, express intimacy, blushing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlexMac89
Why does it seem "creepy" to you. Please explain.
I don’t want to interact with peoples’ personas, I want to interact with them as they actually are. Especially people I’m close to, children and grandchildren come to mind. I want them to interact with me as well.
this is why it's creepy Bob. He articulated it well
 
Would you rather the person you are talking to over face time see you wearing the Vision Pro? This is a well thought out trade off. Of course, its not gonna be 100% replica of you or your behaviors which might be a good or bad thing. But it does remove the awkwardness of being able to interact with you and see if your gestures. I hope Apple will make it optional to train the persona: goofy face, mourning, sadness, silly, anger, busy, concerned, joyful, excited, disbelief, annoyed, express intimacy, blushing.
Yeah, I know it's a tradeoff. Still doesn't make it creepy though
 
A little bit uncanny valley but it’s the right direction and will only get better. But I hope you have the option, just like now, to replace yourself with a Memoji. Of high quality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlexMac89 and xmach
I don’t want to interact with peoples’ personas, I want to interact with them as they actually are. Especially people I’m close to, children and grandchildren come to mind. I want them to interact with me as well.
Agreed but what about those times when you’re unable to be present, is this better than a letter, photograph, phone call, or Skype? Isn’t this a more personal communication with loved ones when we’re far away?
 
What's the point of Face-Time when it's not really you? If I get haircut, scratch on my face from my puppy, it won't show that. Just makes it less human.

I know it's a trade-off but not understanding the benefit. Especially when the new Face-Time effects in Sonoma seem useful for communicating (like having your monitor display behind you).
 
I don’t want to interact with peoples’ personas, I want to interact with them as they actually are. Especially people I’m close to, children and grandchildren come to mind. I want them to interact with me as well.

I think this is a good approach and it will only get better over time. We still accept audio only (aka, a phone call) to connect with people "as they actually are". Given the choice, I'd take a 3D persona that can mimic eye contact, expressions, etc. over just an audio call.

Google has been toying with 3D recreation and displays too...

 
  • Like
Reactions: SFjohn and kfireven
So we’ll get “create a face that looks like you” to match the “create a voice that sounds like you”. And we can look young forever! 🙂
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.