Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The simple fact that all of today's info is post on the At&t site on the IPHONE INFORMATION PAGE should spell it out.

The prices shown on that page are for TWO iPhone 3G lines.

If you have 1 iPhone 3G and 1 regular phone, it will be exactly the same as if you had 1 WinMo phone and 1 regular phone, or 1 BlackBerry and 1 regular phone...

I will use my plan (1 normal phone and 1 BlackBerry) as the example.

2100 shared minutes- $100
2nd line- $9.99
Unlimited family text- $30
BlackBerry Personal Plan- $30

Total = $169.99

If I swap the BlackBerry out for the iPhone 3G, NOTHING CHANGES. It will be the exact same cost.

Again, the Family Plan info on the "iPhone information" page is for TWO iPhone 3G lines.

Same 2100 minutes on 2 iPhone 3Gs...

2100 shared minutes- $100
2nd line- $9.99
Two iPhone 3G data plans- $60

Total = $169.99

Get it?

If you want to get an iPhone 3G and a normal phone on a two line Family Plan, all you have to do is add $30 to the cost.

What he ^ said.
 
WOW!!! Is this what it takes to make you feel superior? I guess my PhD from Columbia hasn't blessed me with enough common sense to immediately INFER something not explicitly documented on a site meant to allow me to EASILY "pre-plan" my cost of ownership.

I do stand humbly corrected on one point, however, - I said conceited and I obviously meant jackass...

Wow... Well then... I guess Columbia needs to tighten up on its entrance requirements.

Here is the link to the page

At&t iPhone plan information

Look at your address bar... See that? That's right, it says "/cell-phone-service/specials/iphone-info.jsp" right after the address...

Say it with me now... iphone-info.

Now, look at the rest of the page. Do you see any other mention of At&t devices that aren't the iPhone? Do you see anything that talks about non-iPhone related information?

No.

Finally. If you look at the plan information, in nice blue text it says, and I quote, "What types of plans are available for the iPhone 3G?" Hmm... I wonder what this page is referring to?

Case in point. The page is dedicated to the iPhone, and it should be all around common sense that the Family Plans depicted represent having 2 lines and each with an iPhone 3G.

You started getting all pissy with people for being "rude" to you when it was your simple lack of common sense in reading that led to your confusion. You had no grounds to call anyone rude simply because YOU can't get it. If calling it as I see it makes me a jackass, I happily accept the title.
 
Wow... Well then... I guess Columbia needs to tighten up on its entrance requirements.

Here is the link to the page

At&t iPhone plan information

Look at your address bar... See that? That's right, it says "/cell-phone-service/specials/iphone-info.jsp" right after the address...

Say it with me now... iphone-info.

Now, look at the rest of the page. Do you see any other mention of At&t devices that aren't the iPhone? Do you see anything that talks about non-iPhone related information?

No.

Finally. If you look at the plan information, in nice blue text it says, and I quote, "What types of plans are available for the iPhone 3G?" Hmm... I wonder what this page is referring to?

Case in point. The page is dedicated to the iPhone, and it should be all around common sense that the Family Plans depicted represent having 2 lines and each with an iPhone 3G.

You started getting all pissy with people for being "rude" to you when it was your simple lack of common sense in reading that led to your confusion. You had no grounds to call anyone rude simply because YOU can't get it. If calling it as I see it makes me a jackass, I happily accept the title.

I guess I just don't understand why you feel the need take such a smug condescending attitude and tone when all I did was ask for some clarification.

Whatever it is that makes you feel the need to overcompensate to this degree in order to make yourself feel superior, I hope you find some comfort one day...
 
What AT&T should do is just say pick a plan, any plan, and add $30 for each iPhone data plan you want to add. Period.

I agree. That is what they did the first time around and it made plenty of sense. Kind of surprising with the new tack--the prices are eyepopping to anyone, even if you are getting a lot.
 
I agree. That is what they did the first time around and it made plenty of sense. Kind of surprising with the new tack--the prices are eyepopping to anyone, even if you are getting a lot.

I thoroughly agree with this point. No matter how much common sense anyone has, the marketing literature from today's release is ridiculously vague with the family plan - rooted in the fact that AT&T made the improper assumption that everyone in a family plan would get an iPhone.

The true way to address this would have been to give the normal family plan rates with a strong emphasis (something like $30 extra for each iPhone line) on the modification to the traditional plan. But then, I'm sure that the average family with 5 lines can easily throw down $1k on everyone's phones each year and an extra $150 per month on data.

An additional piece of those charts would have been great as well (Current Customers: Add an iPhone to your current plan for $30).

Their pre-marketing "rumors" were vastly superior marketing than anything they have come out with now. Just like the stupid "iReady" marketing slogan - whom do they hire? I'm a software engineer, and I have better marketing skills.
 
I thoroughly agree with this point. No matter how much common sense anyone has, the marketing literature from today's release is ridiculously vague with the family plan - rooted in the fact that AT&T made the improper assumption that everyone in a family plan would get an iPhone.

The true way to address this would have been to give the normal family plan rates with a strong emphasis (something like $30 extra for each iPhone line) on the modification to the traditional plan. But then, I'm sure that the average family with 5 lines can easily throw down $1k on everyone's phones each year and an extra $150 per month on data.

An additional piece of those charts would have been great as well (Current Customers: Add an iPhone to your current plan for $30).

Their pre-marketing "rumors" were vastly superior marketing than anything they have come out with now. Just like the stupid "iReady" marketing slogan - whom do they hire? I'm a software engineer, and I have better marketing skills.
I know that the current family plan pricing is vague, but the part that confuses me is how it was the same for the 1G iPhone and not nearly as many people complained last year. What changed?
 
But what about the exchange support? We don't have to pay any extra for that? I don't really understand what this enterprise data plan is all about.

Exchange support is offered to businesses. A tax ID number is required. Once an Exchange server is accessed, the monthly price increases by $15 per phone.
 
I am on the family plan that was originally mentioned in here with the 1400 minute family plan ( My mom's phone being a regular line and my iPhone) It comes out to 119.99 plus the $20 for unlimited text on my line. I called AT&T and she said the only thing that would change to my plan would be the $10 increase in the data plan, which is provided above in my post. The page, which a few people have cleared up, with all the iPhone plans and family plans is for iPhone lines, thus being the reason why it is more expensive.
 
Gosh there was a lot of uncalled for statements made in this thread. Mean and hateful :mad:
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.