iPhone 3G Geekbench Score: 135
iPhone 3GS Geekbench Score: 150
iPhone 5 Geekbench Score: 1296
iPhone 5S Geekbench Score: 2557
The 5->5S is MUCH more substantial than the 3->3GS upgrade in terms of what you get in forms of an update.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
What was the weakest update to iPhones
- Thread starter MrXiro
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
iPhone 3G Geekbench Score: 135
iPhone 3GS Geekbench Score: 150
iPhone 5 Geekbench Score: 1296
iPhone 5S Geekbench Score: 2557
The 5->5S is MUCH more substantial than the 3->3GS upgrade in terms of what you get in forms of an update.
Having personally stood in line in June 2007 for the original, and owning each iteration since the current jump from the 5 to the 5s is the least impressive based on my own use and needs. Thus the latest received my vote. Each iteration was an improvement in its time. The addition of 3G radio to get off the edge network was a lot more significant to the user than this thread seems to give credit.
3G. Too slow out of the gate. Much slower yet after OS updates.
The 3Gs was actually one of the better updates. It turned an unusable phone into a nice experience.
The 3Gs was actually one of the better updates. It turned an unusable phone into a nice experience.
It's all relative. We all know measuring mobile world performance is subjective to various different test.
Based on 2009 test results with 2009 testing methods they determined iPhone 3GS to be 128% faster than iPhone 3G. A significant performance boost that's comparable to similar tests run on 2013 testing methods for iPhone 5 to iPhone 5s.
http://www.anandtech.com/show/2790
No, maybe the raw numbers are higher but in real world performance the 3G was laggy compared to the 3GS. My 5S performs almost identically to my 5 - in daily usage. I'd say this upgrade was def the weakest.
On paper, yes, but in terms of real world usage the 3GS felt significantly faster. Anybody who has actually gone from original iPhone or 3G to 3GS and from 5 to 5s would agree.
3G tech was out, and already being adopted by many companies at the point in 2007 when the iPhone came to market. There was quite a bit of debate on here (MacRumors) at the time, regarding why it was excluded.
Anand posted a great article, and if I recall, they believed the reasons Apple chose to hold off was more due to the size of 3G chips at the time, as well as reduced battery life.
I agree that the speed increases offered by 3G were definitely significant, however I still feel the overall upgrade was one of the most minor in the iPhone's history. That said, As someone pointed out earlier, they really didn't have any competition at the time (2008), so there really wasn't much need to take chances.
Maybe the phone was minor but because of the subsidized pricing it was a huge update.
iPhone 2G to 3G was the worst update.
However getting 3G was a big deal.
iPhone 5 to 5s has probably been the biggest update to me.
The camera tech, the speed, the power, better battery and Touch ID will be a real game changer.
However getting 3G was a big deal.
iPhone 5 to 5s has probably been the biggest update to me.
The camera tech, the speed, the power, better battery and Touch ID will be a real game changer.
Last edited:
The iPhone 3G in 2008. Same internals, added 3G radio only. It couldn't even support iOS 4 which was released just 2 years later. Compare it with the 3GS which supported up to iOS 6 - it ran the newest iOS until this September - more than 4 years after its release in June 2009.
3G to 3GS was the weakest.
Going from EDGE to 3G made the jump from iPhone to iPhone 3G more significant.
Going from EDGE to 3G made the jump from iPhone to iPhone 3G more significant.
The 3GS is really getting a bum rap here; in many ways it was the first feature complete iPhone in hardware terms, particularly with the camera - I mean we're not just talking an extra megapixel here, this was the first iPhone with autofocus! The first with video! Basically the first iPhone with a camera worth using at all. Considering the iPhone is now famously the most used camera in the world, that makes the 3GS a pretty significant milestone along the way.
The "spec bump" was a big one at the time and enabled lots of other things iPhone users take for granted now. The 3G may have taken the iPhone off Edge, but it was the 3GS that actually first achieved the same kind of data speeds that other phones had for years. That processor wasn't just clocked higher, it had GPU support for a new breed of games, hardware support for on-device encryption, there's a reason they carried on selling it three years and supported it through three major IOS revisions, while the 3G before it basically failed to survive two.
Don't get me wrong, the 3G was my first iPhone and I loved it, but it had little over the original and the 3GS was the phone it really should have been.
The "spec bump" was a big one at the time and enabled lots of other things iPhone users take for granted now. The 3G may have taken the iPhone off Edge, but it was the 3GS that actually first achieved the same kind of data speeds that other phones had for years. That processor wasn't just clocked higher, it had GPU support for a new breed of games, hardware support for on-device encryption, there's a reason they carried on selling it three years and supported it through three major IOS revisions, while the 3G before it basically failed to survive two.
Don't get me wrong, the 3G was my first iPhone and I loved it, but it had little over the original and the 3GS was the phone it really should have been.
3G to 3GS
for me the biggest upgrade was 4 to 4S only because this is when the Iphone came available to Sprint
for me the biggest upgrade was 4 to 4S only because this is when the Iphone came available to Sprint
Are you guys actually using the 5s?
I seriously can't tell 1 bit of difference between it and my old 5 besides the 50% that TouchID works.
Not really quite sure why people even voted for iPhone 3GS to iPhone 4 or iPhone 4S to iPhone 5 lol.
----------
I went from an iPhone 5 to an iPhone 5S. Here's what I can honestly tell.
I "upgraded" because I had an upgrade when I got my iPhone 4S. I bought my iPhone 5 outright last year so it was available for upgrade. I flipped my iPhone 5 for almost $400 so "upgrading" to an iPhone 5S was a no-brainer. Better device, made $100 ($99 for AC+).
----------
I went from an iPhone 5 to an iPhone 5S. Here's what I can honestly tell.
- The camera is awesome and seems much better than my iPhone 5
- The Slo-Mo Camera is awesome
- I changed from Black to Silver, so I got a free paint job
- The device, especially Safari, seems quicker, however slightly
- Touch ID works aboiut 90% of the time. Only when my fingers are wet/dirty does it occasionally struggle.
- 64-bit architecture is something that is futureproof but only has an advantage if you are a developer or if you are someone who wants your e-p***s to enlarge when you talk specs.
I "upgraded" because I had an upgrade when I got my iPhone 4S. I bought my iPhone 5 outright last year so it was available for upgrade. I flipped my iPhone 5 for almost $400 so "upgrading" to an iPhone 5S was a no-brainer. Better device, made $100 ($99 for AC+).
Last edited:
Also the battery capacity was about 60% the capacity of the original iPhone.
----------
3G didn't receive a spec bump. CPU and RAM are identical to the iPhone 2G.
The A7 is twice as fast as the already-super fast A6. The fact it's 64bit didn't factor into my decision to upgrade. The speed difference is very noticeable.
Battery life is vastly improved as well.
----
As for the OP, original iPhone to 3G was the weakest.
----------
Battery life is vastly improved for me. And I love touchid, which works almost every time.