I got a notification for this thread because I assume I posted to it some time ago.
I probably posted about the iBook G4, which was my first Mac. At the time, owning it meant I felt like a complete usurper. There were so many people in this community and others who had been using Macs for decades. Hard core hobbyists, and some professionals.
Here's a pic that I took for the eBay listing when I sold the iBook a few years later. I wish I hadn't sold it, of course, but we don't think that way at the time. #donglelife before that was even a thing. I had a crappy external 1024x768 monitor I used with it sometimes.
And now I've been using Macs for over two decades, so am an old-timer myself.
The best Macs for me were around the OS X 10.4 era. But I realised today that these were the best computing experience
for that time. I wouldn't go back to it now because it wouldn't be right for today.
What I miss from that time was Apple putting 100% of their software attention into OS X. It was the flagship product. Each release got genuinely innovative new features, from backup that "just worked" with Time Machine, to semantic search with Spotlight. (And pretty much each release since, Apple's basically been destroying these features – Spotlight has turned into a kind of media consumption engine, with actual file search buried so deep that it's almost useless – and flaky in any event.)
The big shock for me, with that first Mac, was that everything now cost money. I'd come from Linux and Windows, where it was easy to get free apps to do useful things. But on Mac, you were VERY lucky if you could find an app that was free. Everything was $10-$20, sometimes $50-$100. Even apps that did very basic, small tasks. People even sold apps that cloned what was already built into OS X, and then charged $20 for them. CD burning was a classic example. And there weren't even any additional features! It was just the same thing, with a different user interface.
I also found the community to be a lot more highly strung. People were protectionist about knowledge and understanding, and always ready to pick a fight with anybody they felt didn't share their values. If you asked for help, you'd get a terse, quick reply at the best of times, and at the worst, the reply would be along the lines of "
Who the **** are you?"
This was
everywhere, anywhere Mac users gathered. It felt like people believed owning and using a Mac was a privilege and that everybody needed to be reminded of that over and over and over again. Coming from the world of Linux and Windows, where knowledge was freely shared, this was a real shock.
Peripherals were interesting. There were almost none built for Mac. For example, around that same time of 2005, I got an iMac... Here's a pic, with the iBook:
And I wanted to get a new keyboard because I wasn't happy with the Apple keyboard (the white one in this picture—it had weirdly sticky keys that affected typing). There were only one or two manufacturers selling external keyboards with the right Apple key layout, at least for me here in the UK. And one of those brands was extremely poor quality. All keyboards were Windows. I eventually ended-up stealing a keyboard from work that had come from an old Mac Pro G4.
Things have changed so much since those days. I do miss them, though. I miss OS X being clever and innovative, and class leading when it comes to what an OS should be. Nowadays it's just new features for the sake of new features. You could remove around 50% of the features in macOS and I wouldn't even be aware. They could remarket some of the old features like Smart Folders as if they're new, and people's mind would be blown. I just wish they'd make Spotlight usable again IMHO.
Bonus pic of the iBook, to prove in the eBay listing that it could charge (in fact, it had a new battery because Apple had been forced to do a full replacement because of faulty Sony parts). I do think this was a good design. I loved its keyboard. Hated its screen, which had an incredibly bad colour accuracy. Greens and blues were essentially in the exact same colour space as far as it was concerned.