Seeing as it has Been nothing but trouble for some...will you turn it off to help your battery life?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
When IOS 5.1 is released will you switch off 3G?
- Thread starter The Game 161
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
No, but I do have a few questions:
1. What trouble has 3G caused?
2. What does that trouble have to do with the release of iOS 5.1?
1. What trouble has 3G caused?
2. What does that trouble have to do with the release of iOS 5.1?
3G has to me been the issue with battery life..having 3G on all the time means it is always searching for a connection and which uses up battery. That has been clear when at work.
IOS 5.1 it has been stated you can switch 3G off where currently you cant.
----------
Because currently when not in a 3G area it uses battery by searching for a connection.
All I can say is that I keep 3G on all the time, rarely use Wi-Fi, and have no battery issues, so I will not turn off 3G.
You know I never thought about this until I see this post. I think another reason they brought back this switch is because of iPad's LTE so either 4G speeds or nothing. Also this might save battery life on it from trying to switch back and forth and looking for the strongest 3G signal when you already have a 4G signal, etc. etc.
and to answer your question yes I would disable 3G when needed.
and to answer your question yes I would disable 3G when needed.
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; CPU iPhone OS 5_0_1 like Mac OS X) AppleWebKit/534.46 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.1 Mobile/9A405 Safari/7534.48.3)
My battery "issues" come from frequent use. Nothing more.
My battery "issues" come from frequent use. Nothing more.
A switch would only be justifiable when you have 4G speeds. 4G speeds are great but they kill the phones battery. The phone (CPU) is processing so much information so quickly there is not way around the battery getting torn to shreds. In that scenario having the ability to switch to 3G is a positive.
I know first hand having had the Nexus on 4G.
I know first hand having had the Nexus on 4G.
It would never even occur to me to turn off 3G.
In have never had problems like you describe. Excellent coverage every where I go.
In have never had problems like you describe. Excellent coverage every where I go.
You can disable 3G? I've never had a need to do that, so I never even thought to find out if you could. Go figure....
3G is not the same as data
2G is not the same as "EDGE"
3G UMTS networks can provide the ability to handle calls, SMS and data.
2G GSM networks can provide the ability to handle calls, SMS and data.
Turning off 3G will not turn off data access on your phone.
If your carrier allows you to connect to a 2G GSM network that offers data services through GPRS or EDGE, then you'll still be able to connect to the internet when the "Enable 3G" switch is toggled to off
Some carriers don't support EDGE at all and most don't have EDGE coverage across their entire 2G network.
The "Enable 3G" switch is only missing on the iPhone 4S running iOS 5.0 or 5.0.1
The iPhone 4 and iPhone 3GS running iOS 5.0+ have retained the switch.
The iPhone 4 and iPhone 3GS running iOS 5.0+ have retained the switch.
Last edited by a moderator:
I know this, which is why I used the word 'effectively' in my post. My carrier (the same as yours, I believe) has such an ineffective 2G network that I may as well turn off all data. I don't think I've ever been able to access anything on Three's GPRS network.
The thing is, the phone still looks for the 3G connection for voice, regardless of whether or not you have turned data off/ Simply turning data off will not save you battery, except in the sense that mail and such will not be downloaded, thus saving the potential batter drain of sporadic data transfer. In theory, actually being able to turn 3G off in a case where there is no 3G signal but there is a 2G signal should theoretically help with battery drain issues.
FWIW, for those who are jailbroken, you can add a tweak to turn off 3G.
People don't want to just turn off cellular data. THey want to actually turn off JUST 3G. Your 4S is an accurate representation of every other 4S out there. You don;t have the option to turn off ONLY 3G.
The reason you've not been able to use Three's "GPRS Network" is that they don't have one.
They have a roaming agreement with Orange that allows Three customers to use the Orange 2G network in selected areas where there is no 3G signal.
They don't permit users to use data whilst roaming on the Orange 2G network due to the costs involved.
Given these costs, Three disables the "Enable 3G" toggle on all iPhones used on its network.
----------
It should save a LOT of battery, because the phone won't initiate and maintain a PDP connection. That in itself will save a lot of power over time vs. not turning it off.