MOTU here. DP 4.6 and an 828 mkII plus a rack full of synths and whatnot.
I think if I ever upgrade my hardware I'll go Apogee, just for the sake of quality.
I still don't understand everyone's fixation with PT. I understand that back in the day computers didn't have the power to do what they can now, and the DSP cards PT offered were a godsend, but I see no reason to buy a PT rig anymore. You can get comparable quality converters from Apogee and others, you can get *better* software from MOTU or Apple, and buying two (or 3) G5s is still less than 50% of the cost of an HD core.
+1 yes that was in 2006. how about now? 2009. Most commercial studios seems to be using protools especially colleges, universities, but there is growing number of Logic Studio 9 users too. It's hard to see the industry changing from a proven DAW that delivers 24/7. The recent plague of bugs in Logic 9 and Logic 8 haven't been resolved yet and it such a shame, cos many people including me would love to see a real decent alternative to Pro tools HD systems. One that can do everything, composing mixing producing etc. with Serious Raw Processing Power.
I predict that protools will be 50- 60% cheaper in the next few years, in order to stay competitive with the growing CPU speeds and other DAW's having fairly similar features and quality.
Apple Mac Pro's now cos around 3.3k USD for an 8 core nehalem 2.26 ghz. It's speed in my estimation would be close to a HD3 system and definately more than a HD2 system.
Many studios with Protools HD systems are switching to PC to host HD cos Mac Pro's are quite expensive atm. So for logic users, it's a real hurdle to interface with commercial studios that use PC's and Protools HD.
I predict a real significant shake up in the industry in 3-5 years from now when studios will be considering mandatory upgrades for Pro tools HD. You can't be the market leader selling the same old technology that's over 5 years old. imo, Mac Pro's with DP, Logic, Cubase or Nuendo will be a serious contenders by 2011.
The best DAW to stay current and get working with Top Industry Professionals in commerical recording studios is still Pro Tools 8. However, its expensive to purchase Pro Tools HD's, And the cheaper entry level LE systems are deliberately limited with no Plugin Delay Compensation.
Josef Horhay
Mixing Engineer
http://www.acoosticzoo.com
acoostic zoo
recording studio