I am getting my daughter an ipad for Christmas. She will be almost 10. I have decided on a 32, but cant decide if I want to get her the newest model, or go with a cheaper, older one. She is not a big reader, although I wish she were. She likes to take pictures, play games and watch videos and although she listens to music a lot, she doesnt put more than 15-20 songs on her ipod at a time. She likes to listen to the same ones over and over and over! I dont want to get her something that is obsolete in a year or two but am trying not to spend a ton of money because I want to upgrade her ipod 4 to a 5 for her birthday 2 months after Christmas. Any suggestions? If I get her an older model, will it still be functional with newer apps? Thanks in advance for any help.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Resolved Which Ipad for a 10-year-old?
- Thread starter trish1964
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I would wait for an iPad Mini ( a new generation which isn't released yet )
and get the 16GB Wifi model with a decent case and screen protector.
and get the 16GB Wifi model with a decent case and screen protector.
I considered a mini but decided against it. She already said that she would like a full-sized ipad since she already has an ipod. My biggest concern is that if I get her an older one, will it be compatible with new apps?
Plus I think ipad minis are too expensive for what they are. My reasoning is that if I am already spending $300 I might as well spend a little more for the bigger one. It will last her longer.
Plus I think ipad minis are too expensive for what they are. My reasoning is that if I am already spending $300 I might as well spend a little more for the bigger one. It will last her longer.
If that reasoning was sufficient to spend $170 more, wouldn't it suffice for the much smaller differential between the two full size iPads? (Just substitute "newer one" for "bigger one" above.)
Perfect now just wait for the new iPad 5 to come out in 2 weeks and you can get the iPad 4 for $100 Less
----------
A little extreme don't you think?
I agree,
Or instead, get her a Mac. Let her learn how to use a REAL computer rather than a crippled one.
I'm worried we're going to end up with a generation of kids growing up on tablets who don't know how to use real computers. Tablets are toys.
Osofast, that is what I was just thinking actually. I think I will do that and see how much lower the price goes. Also, does anyone know if newer apps are compatible with older ipads?
And as for the bike, zorinlynx, she has one and rides a lot in her spare time. She is an outside girl, outside with the neighbor kids most of her free time which isnt a lot because she plays on a travel club soccer team that practices twice a week spring, summer and fall, with weekly games spring and fall. They also do many tournaments year-round and play indoor in the off season all winter with weekly games, which is why I have no problem getting her an ipad since she wants one so badly. She is about as far from a couch potato as you can get. Her ipod gets used mostly in the car on the way to practices, games and tournaments (which is A LOT, much to the dismay of my gas card!). I am new here and I mean no disrespect, but comments like that arent productive since you dont know anything about my daughter.
And I have a macbook that she is quite proficient in using and uses it for homework. I just dont like her on it a lot otherwise because she keeps downloading things on it. Drives me crazy! Ipad will hopefully keep her off my macbook
And as for the bike, zorinlynx, she has one and rides a lot in her spare time. She is an outside girl, outside with the neighbor kids most of her free time which isnt a lot because she plays on a travel club soccer team that practices twice a week spring, summer and fall, with weekly games spring and fall. They also do many tournaments year-round and play indoor in the off season all winter with weekly games, which is why I have no problem getting her an ipad since she wants one so badly. She is about as far from a couch potato as you can get. Her ipod gets used mostly in the car on the way to practices, games and tournaments (which is A LOT, much to the dismay of my gas card!). I am new here and I mean no disrespect, but comments like that arent productive since you dont know anything about my daughter.
And I have a macbook that she is quite proficient in using and uses it for homework. I just dont like her on it a lot otherwise because she keeps downloading things on it. Drives me crazy! Ipad will hopefully keep her off my macbook
Unless she's unusual for her age, she'll likely drop, lose, smash, etc. her iPad before it becomes obsolete.
So I'd go for a refurb iPad 4 or even find an iPad 3 on sale... but you know her best. If she has a knack for taking care of things and won't be taking it out of the house (much?), then maybe consider waiting for the iPad 5... It will last longer and I'd guess the size and weight will probably suit a girl that age better.
edit: oh, BTW, you don't have to bother addressing the free parenting advice people offer here. It's the weirdest thing, but some people feel free to offer all kinds of it while implying that you're a bad parent, seemingly with no awareness that they know absolutely nothing about your situation and have no context to base this "advice" on. But most of us understand people come to Apple forums for advice on Apple products and trust that if you're looking for parenting advice you'll ask for it.
So I'd go for a refurb iPad 4 or even find an iPad 3 on sale... but you know her best. If she has a knack for taking care of things and won't be taking it out of the house (much?), then maybe consider waiting for the iPad 5... It will last longer and I'd guess the size and weight will probably suit a girl that age better.
edit: oh, BTW, you don't have to bother addressing the free parenting advice people offer here. It's the weirdest thing, but some people feel free to offer all kinds of it while implying that you're a bad parent, seemingly with no awareness that they know absolutely nothing about your situation and have no context to base this "advice" on. But most of us understand people come to Apple forums for advice on Apple products and trust that if you're looking for parenting advice you'll ask for it.
Last edited:
Thanks everyone for the replies. I think I will wait for the new version to come out and see how much the current one drops. I am a swagbucks, mypoints and harris poll user and already have almost $100 worth of Amazon gift cards to put towards it if I decide to get it through Amazon. I hope to add to that by Christmas so that will help a lot with the cost. And I am not that bothered by the bike comment. I am just one of those people who cant keep their mouth shut so I felt compelled to reply to it.
There might be a generation that doesn't know what a non-touchscreen computer is. That's the sad thing. I'm only 15 and I don't see any appeal in the touchscreen laptop trends, or the iPad. I like the smaller tablets, though.
A discounted (firesaled) iPad Mini sounds perfect for a 10-year old. This may happen in the next few weeks.
EDIT: whoops just noticed OP's response. OK then a discounted iPad 4 will be fine, once the iPad 5 comes out.
That comment is very speculative. You answer has nothing to do with her question. You know nothing about her or her daughter. Either answer the question or move on.
Like what other helpful members have said, wait a couple more weeks and see what the new models bring. I have a 6 years old that enjoys a few apps and likes watching Netflix on. I will give him my iPad 4 and I'll be picking up the 5 when it comes out.
My 7yo and 11yo have been using ipad1 since launch, and have yet failed to smash, lose, etc. Kid's aren't as careless as you might think.
I, on the other hand, managed to break my ipad3 screen.
Back OT, get a new one, 32GB. 16GB fills up too fast. An iPad5 will have a life of at least 3 years, based on past experience. Buying an iPad4 would be false economy, IMHO, as you would be paying a lot of money for something that will slow to a crawl within 2 years as iOS updates to match new hardware.
+++1. It is hilarious the unsolicited parenting advice one gets from complete strangers. Often, I suspect such advice comes from those with no kids, or whose kids grew up in a completely different generation and whose advice is now suspect.