Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Personally, I think that many of Hitchcock's movies are rather dated, or, have not aged all that well.

In terms of atmospherics, and tension, they were extraordinary; however, re character and narrative, sometimes, they left quite a lot to be desired.

Certainly I think that is true of say The Birds or Psycho. If you compare them to modern genre classics like The Silence of the Lambs there is a lot more depth in the best modern films, I think. But this is a genre I am not an expert on, I mostly avoid it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
Certainly I think that is true of say The Birds or Psycho. If you compare them to modern genre classics like The Silence of the Lambs there is a lot more depth in the best modern films, I think. But this is a genre I am not an expert on, I mostly avoid it.
Plus, writing as a woman, - especially once I reached adulthood - I find that I am uncomfortable with - and, frankly, deeply dislike - Hitchcock's portrayal of women.
 
Plus, writing as a woman, - especially once I reached adulthood - I find that I am uncomfortable with - and, frankly, deeply dislike - Hitchcock's portrayal of women.

Fair enough, I’d say. Are you encouraged by Hollywoods portrayal of women in film these days? There is a little more variety now, but if say Wonder Woman or Captain Marvel does not ring your bell then one might argue that they still haven’t figured out how to write women?
 
Of the Hitchcock movies I'm familiar with, I'd say Marnie is the worst in its treatment of women from pretty much every angle: plot, character, writing, and aesthetic.

Which brings me to a movie that over the years since its release has become unwatchable for me because of a constant stream of revelations, even up to the present, about its director: Manhattan. The plot and how every character treats the central premise as normal and unremarkable is especially heinous.

----------
@Bodhitree
I don't think mass media has changed much in how women are described, discussed, shown, and not shown. For example, it is so common for male actors to continue to get starring roles even when they're in their 80s, it is unremarkable. But how many female actors in their 50s and beyond get to carry a movie? Meryl Streep is the exception that proves the rule, I'd say.

If you're interested, here's a YouTube series about how women are portrayed in video games. It could easily be about the movies, too...especially comic book hero movies since those are so similar to video games and are targeted to the same audience.

and a somewhat glib response to your question:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
But how many female actors in their 50s and beyond get to carry a movie? Meryl Streep is the exception that proves the rule, I'd say.

I won’t argue the point, but perhaps Diane Keaton (now sadly deceased but still onscreen in Book Club 2 in 2023) and Michelle Yeoh show there is a bit of hope.
 
I won’t argue the point, but perhaps Diane Keaton (now sadly deceased but still onscreen in Book Club 2 in 2023) and Michelle Yeoh show there is a bit of hope.
How can there be a list of leading ladies over 50 and no mention of The Queen?
SvYdP_RKG6OypQ9brhwn60ABgZjS2KgQG4eSabu26gG8x3_4-mI8HGh-e1STqcbeixU

I can name a few movies in which she carried the show: Calender Girls, Woman in Gold, Eye in the Sky and The Hundred-Foot Journey.
 
Tombstone.

My wife and I were in Phoenix in 1994 and had a day to explore. The GC was too far so it was between Sedona and Tombstone. Tombstone was in the mix since the movie was fairly recent so we chose to go there.

It was fine and we enjoyed ourselves.

Fast forward to 2017 and we were in Phoenix for a wedding. We had our daughter and planned on going to the GC. On the way up, my wife asked if we could stop in Sedona for lunch since we didn't make it the last time we were in AZ.

Well, we fell in love with Sedona and on the plane ride home, pretty much decided we were going to live there. Took 5 years, but we bought a house there (technically Cottonwood, but we can see the red rocks) in 2022.

So had the movie Tombstone never been released, we may have seen Sedona back in 1994 which could have changed the trajectory of our lives.
 
An American werewolf in London, seen as an innocent kid who grew up in the countryside, scarred me for many years after. As in, bedsheets over head at night and jumpy as a chihuahua waiting for the postman.
 
Michael Cimino: "Heaven's Gate"
Sergio Leone: "Once Upon A Time In The West"

View attachment 2597314
Two excellent movies, both of which were beautifully shot and told wonderfully nuanced narratives.

Another movie that comes to mind - and one that may still have an uncomfortable resonance and relevance - is the 1981 German movie "Mephisto" (German, with sub-titles, but compelling viewing).
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.