Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
However, there are a few movies that I thought powerful, thought-provoking, and exceptionally well made.

One test is whether I would willingly watch a movie a second time, a test that - to my mind - these movies meet.

In no particular order, herewith some of the movies that have impressed me, along with my (naturally, subjective) thoughts on what made them special, or singling out as worth viewing.

@arkitect (and others) will note the paucity of US movies on my (initial and any subsequent) list, or lists, and my preference for British and European movies.

The Third Man:

A superb British movie with terrific cinematography, a gripping narrative - written by Graham Greene - a superb cast, script, haunting soundtrack, and a stunning setting - postwar Vienna, where the movie was actually shot on location; a movie that understands nuance, and acknowledges a world of grubby and sordid choices and exchanges, made by morally compromised people who struggle with simply surviving while keeping body and soul intact.

Above all, I love the courage of the downbeat ending, an example of the triumph of the bitter sweet integrity of art, a movie where Harry died, and Holly Didn't Get The Girl.

Jesus of Montreal:

An exceptionally intelligent, gripping, and thought-provoking telling of the Passion; this is an outstanding Canadian movie, (it is in French, with sub-titles), with a terrific cast, setting, script, story, and soundtrack, which manages the "Hamlet" trick (no mean feat) of telling a further play, or story, within the main narrative, in itself a spell-binding and compelling take on the Passion. I loved it.

Au Revoir, Les Enfants:

A movie that stunned me when I first saw it. Again, a superb - and haunting - tale (based on a true story) set in a French boarding school (it is in French, with sub-titles) during the German Occupation of France during the second world war. Terrific cast, story, script, setting, a powerful and compelling and unforgettable story.

The Life of Brian:

Monty Python's masterpiece; hilarious, brilliant, original, inventive, and extraordinarily intelligent movie. George Harrison (who financed it) appears fleetingly, and the fact that the movie was shot on location in north Africa meant that the lighting was authentically searing; elements of the humour was so accurately and sharply observed that some of the expressions have passed into everyday speech ("what did the Romans ever do for us?")

Lone Star:

An exceedingly rare (to my mind, at least) example of an American movie that I regard as nuanced, intelligent, interesting, thought-provoking, subtle, with a wonderfully complex story that spans around half a century, a story that features at least four different interracial couples, (and the interracial couples differ from one another, appearing naturally in the story as it unfolds, including two different Caucasian/Latino couples, an African American/Indian couple, Caucasian/African American couple, etc, as well as Latino couples, African American couples etc), an excellent cast, a terrific soundtrack (which I ordered as a CD from the sort of wonderful small, independent bricks'n'mortar music store that specialised in rare and unusual music that easily existed in our worlds around a quarter of a century ago), a story that addresses narrative, memory, and differing and contested histories.

Indochine:

A stunning French movie (yes, it is in French and can be watched with sub-titles), another story that spans more than half a century, set (mostly) in French Indochina (modern Vietnam); a superb cast, complex and interesting and intelligent story, brilliant cinematography.


The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp:

An original, intelligent, generous, subtle, thought-provoking (and moving, in part) British movie dating from the second world war. Terrific story, cast, script, and cinematography (in difficult circumstances).


Kind Hearts and Coronets:

The best, darkest, driest and most witty of the classic Ealing comedies. Outstanding (and - to my mind, - hilarious) story, incredible script, superb cast, and wonderful cinematography. Probably best known nowadays for the many roles played (superbly) by Sir Alec Guinness, but, to my mind, without the exquisite Dennis Price, and the excellence of both Valerie Hobson, and Joan Greenwood, the movie wouldn't have been anywhere near the classic it is.

I daresay that more movies may occur to me, but, for now, I will content myself with posting this (initial) list of some of my favourite movies.
 
Last edited:
Schindler's List plus many others. Schindler's List is the only movie I have ever seen in a theater where the entire audience was completely silent and remained seated till the end of the credits, stunning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn and Bodhitree
I forgot one.
I saw it 4 decades ago, in a planetarium in Winnipeg, CA, with my folks. I learned from my boss, about 15 years ago, that it originally was a novel. It floored me.
It was a science fiction story, about human society advancing thru the years, and cataloging all their information into a supercomputer in the ether (this was 3.5 decades before AI, which is why I'd love to see it again). The major issue that humanity had, by then, was that the entire universe was running out of energy, and the final scene was One Last Star, fading into a darker and darker red, and then finally, it went out (impactful, in a planetarium). A single voice asked the supercomputer, "What happens now?"
The entire theater was dark, and there was no answer for a long time. Then, finally, a separate voice said something like, "the supercomputer searched for an answer, but it needed more data. But there WAS no more data. And it thought, and it thought..."
And then it said, "Let There Be Light!!!"

The planetarium exploded with visuals (in those days a planetarium projector looked like a fat Q-tip, mounted on spindly legs) and it was spinning around on at least two axes and going crazy:


...the screen image was just mesmerizing.

On the drive back to the hotel, I asked my folks, "So, is God just a supercomputer from a prior civilization?" I was immediately hushed; and they never spoke of it again.

If anyone here knows the name of this novel, or movie, I would love to know what it is, to see/read it again. TIA.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Arran and Huntn
I forgot one.
I saw it 4 decades ago, in a planetarium in Winnipeg, CA, with my folks. I learned from my boss, about 15 years ago, that it originally was a novel. It floored me.
It was a science fiction story, about human society advancing thru the years, and cataloging all their information into a supercomputer in the ether (this was 3.5 decades before AI, which is why I'd love to see it again). The major issue that humanity had, by then, was that the entire universe was running out of energy, and the final scene was One Last Star, fading into a darker and darker red, and then finally, it went out (impactful, in a planetarium). A single voice asked the supercomputer, "What happens now?"
The entire theater was dark, and there was no answer for a long time. Then, finally, a separate voice said something like, "the supercomputer searched for an answer, but it needed more data. But there WAS no more data. And it thought, and it thought..."
And then it said, "Let There Be Light!!!"

The planetarium exploded with visuals (in those days a planetarium projector looked like a fat Q-tip, mounted on spindly legs) and it was spinning around on at least two axes and going crazy:


...the screen image was just mesmerizing.

On the drive back to the hotel, I asked my folks, "So, is God just a supercomputer from a prior civilization?" I was immediately hushed; and they never spoke of it again.

If anyone here knows the name of this novel, or movie, I would love to know what it is, to see/read it again. TIA.

I've been trying out a generative-AI search engine, Perplexity.ai, as a substitute for Google, Bing, and the like for awhile. See what you think of Perplexity's response to an excerpt of your post:

—————
ETA: it’s funny that a way to find an answer to this question was predicted by the story, no?
 
Last edited:
the English Patient, 1996

\great book, excellent acting, better cinematography, deep plot, every scene counted, music alluring
won an Oscar or nine,
but all that sand made my golf game better as I avoid the traps after the desert storm scene.
so that changed my life!

the Herodotus references were true to the book in sequence of the movie I recently found out.
 
I've been trying out a generative-AI search engine, Perplexity.ai, as a substitute for Google, Bing, and the like for awhile. See what you think of Perplexity's response to an excerpt of your post:

—————
ETA: it’s funny that a way to find an answer to this question was predicted by the story, no?
WOW. Thank you so much for that, wanted to give you a Thumb's-up and a Heart emoji too; gotta look that up now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KaliYoni
ETA: it’s funny that a way to find an answer to this question was predicted by the story, no?
I think it's also interesting to see sci-fi predictions that fail.

I recall one in which a handheld recording mechanism used a very fine wire that ran between miniature spools. This was probably very futuristic (but still recognizable) for people who only knew about wire recorders. I don't recall the author or story, but it may have been in the Triplanetary / Lensman series.

I mostly remember that I got bored with that series and stopped reading it. I was an avid reader of Asimov, though, for the robots and his other stories. I was quite amused when US Robotics appeared as a modem vendor in ye olden tymes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KaliYoni
Yes indeed, some good films mentioned by all, I thought the case of Saving Private Ryan to be particularly interesting. The films quoted by Tom in the ‘War and Evil’ section of his list were largely anti-war films, which I think SPR also is. For me the beach assault section of the D-day landings is still one of the great depictions of war on film.

I also think an honourable mention has to go to 1917 for it’s outstanding cinematography and managing to shoot an entire film in very long over-the-shoulder takes to really place you in the First World War. It made a deep impression on me, the whole story.
 
If you're looking for a movie to change your life you're on a fools quest indeed. A few are good, most are terrible, a waste of your time money and effort. Most people have forgotten the movie by the time they get home and can only describe it as great, awesome or amazing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
The Neverending Story. The death of Artax destroyed my childhood.

Artax.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
While I'm usually not terribly interested in listicles or influencers, I think the YouTube list has a major flaw: barely any mentions of documentaries. Of all the movie genres, I regard documentaries as the most likely to "change lives" or to change one's outlook on a topic.

Here are a few releases by documentary directors who have repeatedly moved me, in no particular order:




 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
While I'm usually not terribly interested in listicles or influencers, I think the YouTube list has a major flaw: barely any mentions of documentaries. Of all the movie genres, I regard documentaries as the most likely to "change lives" or to change one's outlook on a topic.

Here are a few releases by documentary directors who have repeatedly moved me, in no particular order:




Excellent post and you make a very salient point, one with which I completely agree.

To your list I would add two superlative documentaries, both of which had a powerful impact on me.

Shoah,

and,

The Act of Killing
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn and KaliYoni
Two parts of Shoah that deeply affected me are the interviews with the railway worker and the family who took over a house.
The railway worker who casually and cheerfully - with an almost blithe indifference - recounted how he had booked mass excursions at tourist rates to peculiar destinations in central and eastern Europe not previously considered, or deemed to be - still less known as - popular tourist spots?

Horrifying, haunting, yet both compelling, and utterly grotesque.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
If you're looking for a movie to change your life you're on a fools quest indeed. A few are good, most are terrible, a waste of your time money and effort. Most people have forgotten the movie by the time they get home and can only describe it as great, awesome or amazing.
I agree, a huge preponderance of awful.
 
The railway worker who casually and cheerfully - with an almost blithe indifference - recounted how he had booked mass excursions at tourist rates to peculiar destinations in central and eastern Europe not previously considered, or deemed to be - still less known as - popular tourist spots?

Yes, if he was the same person who talked about making a throat slitting gesture whenever he saw a Deutsche Reichsbahn cattle car pass by (it's been a few years since I last saw the film).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
Great resource, so many films I missed, need to catch up.

Yes, that’s the reason why I engaged with Tom’s list in the first place, to see what great films I had missed over the years.

But I can sympathise with Nada Ting’s point of view. I think which films affect you personally on a deep level is very individual, and if you make the effort to dig through your memory and see which they are you are likely to come up with a more or less unique list of your own.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scepticalscribe
One thing I’d add to the list is…

Nature documentaries narrated by David Attenborough. Although I can’t mention any single one (maybe Blue Planet), these have had such a lasting impact on my life that I can’t leave them out.
 
One thing I’d add to the list is…

Nature documentaries narrated by David Attenborough. Although I can’t mention any single one (maybe Blue Planet), these have had such a lasting impact on my life that I can’t leave them out.
I'd also add to that the excellent - if, perhaps, a little dated - several series that the BBC (principally BBC2, under the stewardship of the selfsame David Attenborough, when he was Controller of Programmes for BBC2) commissioned, produced and broadcast: Jacob Bronowski's wonderful "The Ascent of Man", Kenneth Clark's "Civilisation", are but two of them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Arran
Reflecting a little on Toms list and my own, there are still a lot of movies that feature violence and lives in peril, guns, sword fights, kungfu… it strikes me that even in lists of life changing films, death and murder are not far away. The modern movie going public seem to like this.

It wasn’t always like this. In the 1930’s movies and entertainment were quite different. But I think it’s interesting that Hitchcock doesn’t make Toms list or mine, although he undoubtedly had a great cultural impact.
 
Reflecting a little on Toms list and my own, there are still a lot of movies that feature violence and lives in peril, guns, sword fights, kungfu… it strikes me that even in lists of life changing films, death and murder are not far away. The modern movie going public seem to like this.

It wasn’t always like this. In the 1930’s movies and entertainment were quite different. But I think it’s interesting that Hitchcock doesn’t make Toms list or mine, although he undoubtedly had a great cultural impact.
Personally, I think that many of Hitchcock's movies are rather dated, or, have not aged all that well.

In terms of atmospherics, and tension, they were extraordinary; however, re character and narrative, sometimes, they left quite a lot to be desired.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.