I'm a bit clumsy, but I have managed to go over two years without breaking my 3gs. That's due in part to having a good case on it. I sure would like to go case-less... and I wouldn't have to spend 40 bucks on a case, so there's that. I hadn't planned on buying it, but I also didn't know that they offer accidental damage coverage. I think I've about changed my mind. It sure would be nice to be less worried about breaking the darn thing.