Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Why I switched to a BlackBerry, and I'm not coming back
- Thread starter CrzyCanuck72
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Reasons I left the blackberry for the iPhone and why I'm never going back.
1. Web browsing is awful on the Blackberry. I mean really bad.
2. Besides the almost unusable BB Storm, the screen sizes are tiny.
3. The OS is largely unchanged from the original BB OS from a decade ago.
4. Third party apps stink on the BB.
5. BB Media Player = Lame
6. No SMS threading
If all I wanted to do was email, I might consider the BB. For everything else, there is no comparison to the iPhone.
1. Web browsing is awful on the Blackberry. I mean really bad.
2. Besides the almost unusable BB Storm, the screen sizes are tiny.
3. The OS is largely unchanged from the original BB OS from a decade ago.
4. Third party apps stink on the BB.
5. BB Media Player = Lame
6. No SMS threading
If all I wanted to do was email, I might consider the BB. For everything else, there is no comparison to the iPhone.
Genuinely, I'm glad you found something that better suits your needs. The iPhone, like any other product, can't be for everyone without risking satisfying no one. Hope the BB serves you well.
i'm considering trading my 3g for a bold after using my friend's and being really impressed with it for various reasons. I realize both have its strengths and weaknesses, but for me, I think the bold was really capable for my needs.
i just feel bad doing it because I made my gf get an iphone because i did. Now it feels like I"m deserting her, unless I get her a bold too.
i just feel bad doing it because I made my gf get an iphone because i did. Now it feels like I"m deserting her, unless I get her a bold too.
I have an iphone for personal use and a curve 8320 for work. There are some nice phones out there besides the iphone (I really like the Pre and android based phones), but blackberries are not among them.
I'm not going to take the time to respond to every point the OP makes, but there are two I just can't resist.
BBM - It always kills me when people bring this up. I really can't imagine a more useless feature. I guess email, SMS, and AIM/gchat/etc. aren't enough ways to get in touch with someone. And if the fact that it's completely redundant weren't enough, it's grossly inferior to those other methods because it only works with other blackberries.
Fast OS - Ok, maybe there was a big improvement on the 8900 (as compared to the 8320), but believe me, it would have to be HUGE. The unbelievable sluggishness of my bb astounds me on a daily basis. I even frequently scroll too far because the cursor lags so far behind the ball's motion. I see the hourglass for probably 5+ seconds when I lock the phone (not that it matters, since I'm done using it, but that's just an example).
Comparing a bb to an iphone just kinda boggles my mind. My bb strikes me as a phone with a keyboard and a few apps slapped on; my iphone is a 3.5" computer.
I'm not going to take the time to respond to every point the OP makes, but there are two I just can't resist.
BBM - It always kills me when people bring this up. I really can't imagine a more useless feature. I guess email, SMS, and AIM/gchat/etc. aren't enough ways to get in touch with someone. And if the fact that it's completely redundant weren't enough, it's grossly inferior to those other methods because it only works with other blackberries.
Fast OS - Ok, maybe there was a big improvement on the 8900 (as compared to the 8320), but believe me, it would have to be HUGE. The unbelievable sluggishness of my bb astounds me on a daily basis. I even frequently scroll too far because the cursor lags so far behind the ball's motion. I see the hourglass for probably 5+ seconds when I lock the phone (not that it matters, since I'm done using it, but that's just an example).
Comparing a bb to an iphone just kinda boggles my mind. My bb strikes me as a phone with a keyboard and a few apps slapped on; my iphone is a 3.5" computer.
I used to have a Blackberry. I switched to the iPhone when it came out and loved it.
But it's not like the switch from Windows to Mac. Windows sucked, and I didn't know any better until I discovered OS X. But the Blackberry did not suck, in fact it was awesome, and better in some things than the iPhone (namely the handling of emails and SMS). But for me, the web browsing and the games
)) outweights speedy email.
But it's not like the switch from Windows to Mac. Windows sucked, and I didn't know any better until I discovered OS X. But the Blackberry did not suck, in fact it was awesome, and better in some things than the iPhone (namely the handling of emails and SMS). But for me, the web browsing and the games
)) outweights speedy email.
I used BBM everyday when the wife and I both had blackberries. I would love to see apple use iChat in this way with the iPhone. I also don't see how BBM is grossly inferior to the others messengers. For free it works and works well.
Never experienced the sluggishness or lag you did with my 8330. OS was great IMO.
Well said. I had the BB Bold when it first came out and while it's a great device, it was for the reasons listed above as to why I went back to the iPhone (from 2G to the iPhone 3G) and why I currently have an iPhone 3GS. The only thing I really miss from my BB is the LED email indicator and the instant email push. . As it stands though, the Blackberries are great communication devices whereas iPhones do everything else better IMO.
The fact that BB's still don't have threaded SMS baffles me then again so does the fact my US iPhone doesn't have MMS. Can't win em all I guess.
Even if you use BBM, what does it *add?* Couldn't you do the same thing with IM/push email/SMS? Having a 4th way of accomplishing the same thing (sending an instant communication to someone else with a smartphone) doesn't qualify as a major feature in my book. It's grossly inferior because it provides duplicate functionality but is limited to people who have blackberries.
Re: the OS, I have two complaints.
First, the sluggishness. Everyone I work with has the same issue with their bb. Maybe it's because of what the firm installs, but when we had 8700s with the same stuff they were fine.
Second, everything takes far more steps than it should. The whole expanding menu thing is a mess.
hey now, there's no need to bash on the uselessness of BBM just because you have barely any need for it, i know if I had a bold, BBM would be one of my most used apps since most of my close friends have bb's.
I am confused over BBM
I have read numerous threads on here stating that people would love to have this ability on the iPhone.
Now its suddenly hated.
I have read numerous threads on here stating that people would love to have this ability on the iPhone.
Now its suddenly hated.
It all depends on your needs.
If you just want/need a phone with email capabilities (no doubt...they are good) , just grab a BB. I guess, you are doing fine.
If you really like something like a swiss pocketknife, a device which is far more than the sum of the single parts it is made of, take the iPhone with it's pros and cons. I am sure it's the best allraounder available on this planet so far.
Cheers
If you just want/need a phone with email capabilities (no doubt...they are good) , just grab a BB. I guess, you are doing fine.
If you really like something like a swiss pocketknife, a device which is far more than the sum of the single parts it is made of, take the iPhone with it's pros and cons. I am sure it's the best allraounder available on this planet so far.
Cheers
I am really happy for you OP. Finding something I really like or I like the best is a great thing indeed.
I don't understand all these people trying to prove you wrong. I have to wonder if they are the same ones who used to say "Who's forcing you to buy iPhone?" "If you don't like iPhone, don't buy one.".
Anyway, it is refreshing to hear that an iPhone user can find an alternative more useful than iPhone. I hope more and more iPhone users cross over to BB or Pre or Android or anything else, because that will only make Apple listen more what the users want.
I don't understand all these people trying to prove you wrong. I have to wonder if they are the same ones who used to say "Who's forcing you to buy iPhone?" "If you don't like iPhone, don't buy one.".
Anyway, it is refreshing to hear that an iPhone user can find an alternative more useful than iPhone. I hope more and more iPhone users cross over to BB or Pre or Android or anything else, because that will only make Apple listen more what the users want.
What does IM have over email for sending quick messages? What does email have over SMS for sending quick messages? etc etc... Why not just say all forms of text messaging are useless as you have a phone if you need to communicate with someone.
It is just another way to communicate. As it was free and the wife and I liked to use it over the other messengers. It was also always on. I didn't have to load a messenger or 3rd party program. Was just far from useless and would love if the iPhone had something similar.
What I'm asking, and it's a serious question, is how does *anyone* have any need for it? It's one way of doing what any smartphone can already do in at least 3 other ways, except it's limited to blackberries.
If you happen to like its layout or whatever better than an IM program or email then fine, enjoy it. But the OP touted BBM as some major advantage of bb, and I'm still waiting to hear an explanation for that.
I realize you posted before my last post, but I'll say the same thing to you I said to daonesteven: how exactly is it some big advantage?
But to answer your question:
- IM has the advantage (over email) of being faster if it's a prolonged back and forth. No hitting "send," no auto spell check, no waiting for the SMTP server.
- email has the advantage that not everyone is on IM all the time or even has an IM account. also better for longer messages as you can take the time to proofread without someone waiting for a response.
- SMS has the advantage that it can reach any person with a phone, smart or not. It has the disadvantage of costing money.
Each of the other three adds something the other two alone don't cover. I don't see a single thing that BBM adds that the other three, collectively, lack.
I'm not trying to prove him wrong - this is a thread about the relative merits of bb and iphone. I would have thought the point of a message board was to have discussions about the topics raised in the threads.
Who said it was a big advantage? It is the same as saying Yahoo messenger is better than AIM or any other messenger. It is free and works well.
BBM adds that it is free and something all Blackberry phones have. Just an easy solution.
Must have missed the big advantage point but what he said I agree with.
"There really is no match for BBM... every BB user has it, it's always on, there's no service to sign in to... really a genius move by RIM"
Still think Apple should have done this with iChat on the iPhone.
i think that the bb is much more stable than the iphone, in terms of customization. my sister has one, and she never has a single problem with it.
...but the iphone is just too damn fun.
...but the iphone is just too damn fun.
He listed 6 things he liked about bb over iphone and BBM made the list. he also said it had "no match" and was a "genius move." If you want to quibble about my paraphrasing that as "big advantage" go right ahead - I don't think I'm exactly making things up out of whole cloth here.
But fine, I'll play your game. How is it either unmatched or a genius move? It's a duplicative service that only works with a very limited universe of other users. I guess that's kinda unmatched in terms of restrictiveness...
Wait......what? Not trying to "quibble" at all
What game am I playing
Again:every BB user has it, it's always on, there's no service to sign in to
Just a really nice service IMO. Really wish Apple would have also adopted this with iChat as they did with the computers.
I was this way. I had an iPhone 2G, got sick of it and went to a MotoQ (not a BB, I know), and guess what, I'm back. I was happy being away from it for a while, but after a few months I desperately wanted my iPhone back.
For me, the change was what I wanted more than anything. After the 'new toy' excitement went away, I realized what I now had wasn't anything like the iPhone is. But thats just me.
For me, the change was what I wanted more than anything. After the 'new toy' excitement went away, I realized what I now had wasn't anything like the iPhone is. But thats just me.
Why i hated my work Blackberry. I am so glad I don't have one anymore for work. Now i just need my company to go with the iPhone haa haa