How do you think its gonna get slimmer?,take alook at the ports,the only thing
that could possibly get slimmer is the screen and across a 17" screen that
would probably be ni impossible due to warping
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Why I think everyone may be crying out for a MBP re-design
- Thread starter ibizarocks
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
How do you think its gonna get slimmer?,take alook at the ports,the only thing
that could possibly get slimmer is the screen and across a 17" screen that
would probably be ni impossible due to warping
I think people are wishing for a redesign because like they've been using their powerbooks for a long old time now and don't look forward to the prospect of using a computer for the next 'long old time' that looks exactly the same.
Variety is the spice of life and all that...
The lack of redesign is making me think twice about the purchase. And no, my computer isn't there as a fashion accessory... blah blah blah co*k size comparison yadda yadda.
Anyway the point is that, as nice as this computer is there is a lot that can and needs to be improved.
1. Magnetic latch - this button thing is an absolute farce.
2. Plastic trim falls off - redesign it with smooth edges and no trim.
3. Keyboard - personal pref, let's get some continuity in the Apple line up. Sitting on the fence is crap.
See, the majority aren't even asking for some space-age LED masque that looks like the computer has been covered in glue and had a load of rubbish thrown at it.
They're merely refinements of the design that are needed.
OVERDUE!
Variety is the spice of life and all that...
The lack of redesign is making me think twice about the purchase. And no, my computer isn't there as a fashion accessory... blah blah blah co*k size comparison yadda yadda.
Anyway the point is that, as nice as this computer is there is a lot that can and needs to be improved.
1. Magnetic latch - this button thing is an absolute farce.
2. Plastic trim falls off - redesign it with smooth edges and no trim.
3. Keyboard - personal pref, let's get some continuity in the Apple line up. Sitting on the fence is crap.
See, the majority aren't even asking for some space-age LED masque that looks like the computer has been covered in glue and had a load of rubbish thrown at it.
They're merely refinements of the design that are needed.
OVERDUE!
id like to see the same size casing, but the bottom/underside of the MBP should be like the macpro side case that can latch off to easily replace battery,HDD,memory.
perhaps a dedicate GPU component that can be upgraded (but thats stretching it a bit)
but id like a secure undercase that doesnt bend so easily and a sturdier display casing because mine seems to have a slight bend on either side
other than that i really like the casing of the MBP, i wouldnt be suprised if they updated the display case similar to the Alum. iMacs with a black border, well for the glossy screens atleast.
maybe a different shade, perhaps a gun metal black or a glossy kind of casing.
perhaps a dedicate GPU component that can be upgraded (but thats stretching it a bit)
but id like a secure undercase that doesnt bend so easily and a sturdier display casing because mine seems to have a slight bend on either side
other than that i really like the casing of the MBP, i wouldnt be suprised if they updated the display case similar to the Alum. iMacs with a black border, well for the glossy screens atleast.
maybe a different shade, perhaps a gun metal black or a glossy kind of casing.
A lot of things mentioned in this thread are going in the wrong direction.
Nixing the IR sensor? I use that every single day.
A card reader? A fingerprint reader? While card readers are useful, I can live with the little USB dongle I have, since most people use keychain USB drives for small data transfer these days. Fingerprint readers are neat and shiny, but pretty useless if you ask me. They're less secure than a robust password and not specifically useful for anything really.
I wouldn't mind seeing a high-resolution 15in. option and a casing with a magnetic latch, but honestly the current screen and the current latch aren't really bad, or anything. I don't know why people complain about the latch all the time. I mean, it's feels a little fragile, but then again I've never had a problem with it, which is a lot more than I can say about a lot of other products I like and use everyday.
SSD is an eventuality and doesn't require a new case design. On the same note, the high-res screen doesn't either.
Nixing the IR sensor? I use that every single day.
A card reader? A fingerprint reader? While card readers are useful, I can live with the little USB dongle I have, since most people use keychain USB drives for small data transfer these days. Fingerprint readers are neat and shiny, but pretty useless if you ask me. They're less secure than a robust password and not specifically useful for anything really.
I wouldn't mind seeing a high-resolution 15in. option and a casing with a magnetic latch, but honestly the current screen and the current latch aren't really bad, or anything. I don't know why people complain about the latch all the time. I mean, it's feels a little fragile, but then again I've never had a problem with it, which is a lot more than I can say about a lot of other products I like and use everyday.
SSD is an eventuality and doesn't require a new case design. On the same note, the high-res screen doesn't either.
The MBP is plenty thin enough. Maybe they could shave off an extra .1" but really, it's thin enough.
But as for everyone who says that it's not a professional machine and not fashion statement? What's wrong with wanting to look good? Really? Besides, most of us hoping for a redesign don't even want some kind of major overhaul or something uber-flashy, but are looking for features that are practical too.
Trackpad:
The current MBP is in bad need of a bigger trackpad to go with the multi-touch. After looking at the MBA, it really reveals the wasted space around the MBP's smaller trackpad. It needs a bigger trackpad for the multi-touch technology to really be practical and useful, and to eliminate that wasted space around it.
Keyboard:
I'm in the camp that fines the MB/MBA keyboards easier to use. I think they feel better. I'm hoping the MBP gets a new keyboard in the redesign. I don't really care what color. And if it's black like the MBA, who says that black looks any less professional? If one's primary concern is a professional machine that does the job, why would you even care what color the keyboard is, or care about other such changes? A keyboard isn't a fashion statement--it's a tool and some of us want (what we think is) a better one.
Size:
I know there are a lot of people that want a 12" MBP, but that's too small for me. I'd like a 13-4" or so for the extra portability
Again, not a fashion statement, just a practical desire.
Blu-ray:
In all honesty, not that important to me, but again something that would probably require a change in design due to the internals that would add some functionality that's important for many people.
Magnetic Latch:
Not cosmetic. Just more practical. (What really amuses me is the people who think this is a problem with a metal laptop. It's ALUMINUM! Not magnetic. And it already has Magsafe. Come on.)
If I got those redesigns I'd be very happy. None of those are fashion statements.
That said, I'd really like to see the MBP get the MBA's tapered edges, so it will "feel" thinner to me. Some of us just want machines WE enjoy looking at, and frankly some of us are bored.
But as for everyone who says that it's not a professional machine and not fashion statement? What's wrong with wanting to look good? Really? Besides, most of us hoping for a redesign don't even want some kind of major overhaul or something uber-flashy, but are looking for features that are practical too.
Trackpad:
The current MBP is in bad need of a bigger trackpad to go with the multi-touch. After looking at the MBA, it really reveals the wasted space around the MBP's smaller trackpad. It needs a bigger trackpad for the multi-touch technology to really be practical and useful, and to eliminate that wasted space around it.
Keyboard:
I'm in the camp that fines the MB/MBA keyboards easier to use. I think they feel better. I'm hoping the MBP gets a new keyboard in the redesign. I don't really care what color. And if it's black like the MBA, who says that black looks any less professional? If one's primary concern is a professional machine that does the job, why would you even care what color the keyboard is, or care about other such changes? A keyboard isn't a fashion statement--it's a tool and some of us want (what we think is) a better one.
Size:
I know there are a lot of people that want a 12" MBP, but that's too small for me. I'd like a 13-4" or so for the extra portability
Again, not a fashion statement, just a practical desire.Blu-ray:
In all honesty, not that important to me, but again something that would probably require a change in design due to the internals that would add some functionality that's important for many people.
Magnetic Latch:
Not cosmetic. Just more practical. (What really amuses me is the people who think this is a problem with a metal laptop. It's ALUMINUM! Not magnetic. And it already has Magsafe. Come on.)
If I got those redesigns I'd be very happy. None of those are fashion statements.
That said, I'd really like to see the MBP get the MBA's tapered edges, so it will "feel" thinner to me. Some of us just want machines WE enjoy looking at, and frankly some of us are bored.
the difference is b\c some people's whining is for legitimate concerns and others is b\c they want a different color or something completely cosmetic and worthless.
Another reason for a redesign ... you'll be the envy of numerous Mac owners when people see that you have the "newest" MBP.
Right now, there's really no way to determine when a person bought their MBP. Imagine all the attention one would get if/when Apple releases a redesign.
Right now, there's really no way to determine when a person bought their MBP. Imagine all the attention one would get if/when Apple releases a redesign.
contrary to what we think.. 2/3 of the people doesn't really care... esp if they're happy with windows.
before i got addicted/hooked to this forum... i really never CARED.
I am probably buy the new MBP's even though I can wait for Montevina. I like the current keyboard better then the MB's style. I can't type on that keyboard no matter how long I use a MB for at the store. Unless someone can absolutely guarantee me that the MBP won't see a redesign or at least the MBA like keyboard come June( I am feeling a redesign too, WWDC is a Pro event and would be the perfect time to announce it) I will be buying the just updated 17" MBP. I am also in the camp though it is overdue for a redesign. It is getting stale.
YES I also agree strongly with this!!!!!!! There are a hell a of a lot of posers out there whether they admit to it or not. I for one think the same as this!!! It's like when (again) people buy a new car with an 07 plate when literally a new car design comes out with the 57 plate. Both cars were purchased in the same year but my god, you'd be fu**ing pissed off if you had got the 07 version!!!
i think apple should sell MB MBP and MBA cases.. that's right! just the cases.
so we can carry it around the mall or in the office..playing PRETEND!
that's a lot of fun.. and it will be lite as a feather
Mon: carry the MBA
Tues" the MBP
Wed. carry the MB white
Thurs: carry the MB black
FRiday: hmm haven't decided yet
"IM SO HOT" ( with a PAris Hilton voice)
so we can carry it around the mall or in the office..playing PRETEND!
that's a lot of fun.. and it will be lite as a feather
Mon: carry the MBA
Tues" the MBP
Wed. carry the MB white
Thurs: carry the MB black
FRiday: hmm haven't decided yet
"IM SO HOT" ( with a PAris Hilton voice)
Anyone who buys it for or is desperate to be seen with a (new) Mac is just that: desperate. Of course we love Macs or we wouldn't be here, but being a smug git is not something that you should aspire to. "Look at me" crap is just that: crap. Grow up.
Having said that, I do think the MBPs need a redesign. I had a 15 inch 2.33 for 6 months last year and the first thing I noticed was how old fashioned it looked. I changed it for the new iMac + bought an old 12 inch G4 Powerbook and don't regret it for a second.
I don't think they should get thinner for practical reasons but a 12 or 13 inch version is essential simply because there is a large market for it. Also the magnetic latch, also improvements to its wifi range, also the heat issue, also a keyboard in line with other Macs would be better IMHO. So, to the OP, I agree - (subtle) improvements can be made.
Having said that, I do think the MBPs need a redesign. I had a 15 inch 2.33 for 6 months last year and the first thing I noticed was how old fashioned it looked. I changed it for the new iMac + bought an old 12 inch G4 Powerbook and don't regret it for a second.
I don't think they should get thinner for practical reasons but a 12 or 13 inch version is essential simply because there is a large market for it. Also the magnetic latch, also improvements to its wifi range, also the heat issue, also a keyboard in line with other Macs would be better IMHO. So, to the OP, I agree - (subtle) improvements can be made.