You know, I actually thought the same thing when I tried the iMac in some Apple Stores. I remember myself at the New York Apple Store (this store is the center of the Earth to me!) and testing the iMac and the iPhone.
I also had this strange feeling about the OS and the mouse.
I went to the New York Apple Store, San Francisco Apple Store, the Apple Stores in my country. This last year, I kept thinking about my switch over Mac. I kept bashing Windows and was writing some Excel sheets in order to decide which Mac I should buy.
I travelled the US for a few months and the very first thing I did when I came back to my country was to go to an Orange Store and buy the iPhone. When I switched it on, it was perfect. I instantly loved everything of it.
Compared to the BlackBerry and all those crappy phones, it was just perfect. And it still is.
I thought that the switch to Mac OS X would be the same. I think I saw like 1,000 times the presentation video of the MacBook, with the Coldplay music. I almost know it by heart "The MacBook is our most popular Mac, but what we've... what we've done is we've decided... just to start over..."
It is one of the best product video in the all History of advertisement campaigns.
That is why it is even more sad. I didn't just thought "Hey, I don't like the mouse, I'll change it." I thought about my daily work and I rationalized things, against my envy. And my deepest envy is having an iMac and a MacBook. But this mouse drove me insane for 7 days... (let alone the very bad MightyMouse).
For those saying that I should change the preferences, I kept doing this for hours. But you can only change the speed, not the curve.
If I try to explain the feelings between the Mac OS curve and the Windows curve, it is as if the Windows way of moving the mouse was with straight lines and that the Mac OS X way was with small curves instead of lines.
I am overanalyzing this, but even after 7 days of intense tryout, even after installing MouseFix, USB Overdrive, Speed something, it was still the same thing.
This is a coincidence, but this afternoon one of my clients came to my office with his MacBook Air (he bought it because of me, the day I saw the presentation of Steve Jobs, I called this client and told him that it would be great for his work, because he was thinking of buying one of those ****** netbooks).
So, I tried the trackpad this afternoon and the way the mouse is moving is extremely precise. Moving the mouse on the Trackpad was like heaven! It really follows the finger, I had the same feeling as when I'm moving my real mouse on Windows. But as soon as you plug an external mouse (I tried a few Logitech's and a Dell mouse), the precision is lost for a strange curve way.
This is not my imagination, the precision between the Trackpad and an external mouse on Windows is about the same (even if you can see a bit of a difference, but very little). This is the real way of moving a mouse (for me at least), I find it very precise.
But I'm almost sure that if I used a Mac for 15 years and that I tried a Windows, I would think the opposite. But reality is that I used a PC for 15 years... This counts.
About the "heavy feel" (other than the mouse), I'll try to explain. A good example of it is when you are using any software on a PC and then you are using iTunes (still on a PC). You can clearly see that iTunes has this heavy and slow feeling to it. When you click on a menu (especially on the left bar), it isn't "snappy" at all.
As I am now looking at the iMac box (with the iMac in it this time), I keep thinking that I am may be doing the wrong choice. This object was just perfection in my home.
Those last few years, I've become very interested in perfection, whether it is in the IT design or the program layouts.
When Steve Jobs laughed at the phones buttons when doing the first presentation of the iPhone, and explaining that every application should be able to have its own menu, I thought about the top bar. I don't like this in Mac OS. And the Office 2008 for Mac VS the Office 2007 is a pretty good example.
Everything that was great in the PC version (according to me) cannot be done completely in the Mac version, mainly because of the top menu bar. Yes, I like the ribbon very much and the way Mac OS is created, a ribbon is against it...
Then, the way that Windows "shouldn't be opened completely" or that the applications don't close when you click on the "X" button. When I analyze things, I think that the best way of doing it is the Windows 7 way, which is kind of a best of between the Dock and the usual task bar.
Something that is alos extremely annoying is the Fn button that is on the bottom left of the keyboard. The (ugly) IBM Lenovo ThinkPad are the same and it just sucks. You use far more the Ctrl button that the Fn button. And to find it without looking at the keyboard, it is far simplier to find the button that is on the far end of the keyboard.
That is why I prefer a Dell laptop keyboard for instance, VS a Mac keyboard.
When I did some Ctrl+Tab switch, if my memory is right, all the folder windows were under one single Finder icon. In Windows, you can see all the windows while doing Ctrl+Tab.
So, those were a few things that I found really annoying (and paying 4500 bucks for a computer and having a dead pixel... the moment I saw it, I kept looking at it). On the contrary, there are things I loved with my iMac:
- The remote,
- The media center,
- Time Machine (it cannot get better than this for personal backups, the guy who had the idea should get a medal, it is perfection: beautiful design+extremely useful),
- The design (everyone looking to it was like WOW!),
- The way it looks my iPhone is an extension of it,
- The beautiful screen savers,
- The cover flow in the Finder (great idea),
- The fact that there is no ****ing messy registry like on Windows and the way you install software,
- Boot Camp (the fact that you have the choice to have Windows + Mac OS X on a Mac, but not on a PC),
- Exposé (I so miss it, the Windows+Tab aero interface looks great, but no one uses it because it takes even more time to crawl windows with it),
- The way to have multiple desktops (this is on Linux since years! how can it not be in Windows yet?).
So, you can clearly see that I am not bashing Apple, this company means more to me than any other company in the world. This company is a true inspiration to me, really.
One last thing...
I have created a new product and will need a new laptop (a small one) that I will use mainly for doing presentations at clients (on beamers). Since I don't need a fast machine at all (it's only aimed to run PowerPoint presentations and surfing the Internet), a 13'' MacBook (with the lowest hardware) could be the solution. Or a netbook if they do one this year.