Every forum that I've been on while a MS user, the mods did not allow ANY of the 'mild' or severe jacking of threads.
...
That said, why does the Mac Bytes section not list the pages they are linking to?!?
(I keeed, I keeed)
I agree that I pointed to a 'mild' example, that is not what is in question. The question is why is it allowed?
the moderators can't read all of the thousands of posts each day; they rely on you to call their attention to problems.
Do these other forums have 425,445 threads, 4,925,392 posts, and 164,389 registered members by any chance?
![]()
I don't think Mac/Windows culture has anything to do with it.
With thousands of posts being made a day, it's simply not possible to to regulate each and every one. So, we pick our battles. Stop spammers, stop scammers, stop major rules infractions. Thread hijacking? Who cares?
Personally, I looked at the thread when CRAZYBUBBA reported it. As far as I was concerned, it's perfectly cromulent for people to question why they should sell their HD-DVDs for $7 a pop. You'll notice that there weren't any takers for that price in that thread, ya?
Periodically when I have time, I will go through larger threads and clean them up as best I am able, but most of the time if it's not reported by members, then we don't know about it.
When posts are reported, the moderators base their actions on the forum rules and policies, which are in turn designed for the benefit of our members. The moderators do their job quite well, but it's perfectly reasonable to ask why we have the rules we do and whether they should be different.
Here's the current rule/policy:Thread hijacking is considered to be a rules violation in Marketplace threads. Off-topic posts in News threads are also routinely removed. We are less concerned in other forums, and least concerned with off-topic posts in the Community Discussion forum.and the reason:In the Marketplace, hijacking or off-topic posts can interfere with the purpose of the thread, while in the News forums they can inconvenience and annoy people reading our most important threads. On the other hand, when the topic wanders in a Community Discussion thread, the thread participants rarely mind. In between those extremes, the moderators use their best judgment case by case.Could the rule be stronger? Yes. Should it be stronger? Personally, I don't think that's necessary. But the rule is for your benefit, not ours, and comments/opinions are welcome.
When I post in the marketplace I activate instant notification and I would be frustrated evertime I got an email and it turned out to be something other than a legitimate response to my marketplace post.
Well, I should note, I removed 2 Off Topic posts in this thread earlier with no user reporting.
And I should also note that I am a new mod and not completely versed in all the rules and their application to the site, despite the whipping Q gives me.
And finally, "cromulent" is a joke word from "The Simpsons".
Let's look at this in another way, if I removed all the OT posts from the HD-DVD sales thread, that user's thread would have died a quick death in terms of visibility to the Marketplace forum. FYI, bumping is not allowed.
At least half the threads on the News section get hijacked by people who want to whine about Macbook pro updates, and half the threads in the Macbook Air forum get hijacked by people who want to whine about the Air not being exactly what they wanted it to be.
As the mods have said above Report Report Report.
In the spirit of (neigh) full disclosure, I am guilty of causing a "post drift" here or there over my time here.![]()