Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I'm decidedly on the fence about upgrading. I'm a Day 1 3GS owner, and my phone is already showing signs of failure (radio won't pick up a 3G signal, I've been on EDGE for the last month). I definitely need a new phone when my contract is up in June, but...

1. I think the iPhone 4 is a rubbish design -- the "glass-sandwich" lacks the durability that I need from a phone. I'm out of the office every day, I use my phone constantly for work, and with the amount of into-pocket / out-of-pocket movement it gets, the occasional drop is almost inevitable. I need a phone that can survive a 3 foot drop without looking like it took a bullet.

If the iPhone 5 uses the same design as the 4, I'm out.

2. I'm still worried about Antennagate issues -- I'm not buying a phone that has the same known issues as the iPhone 4 with reception. Flat out. If Apple refuses to acknowledge a problem that Consumer Reports has documented, I'm going to refuse to buy their product. They should have a hardware fix for the issue (beyond "buy a case") by now.

3. I want a phone with LTE/4G -- Why would I buy a phone and lock myself into a 2 year contract for a network (3G) that is already badly outdated? The rest of the world is moving to LTE/4G right now; if you buy an iPhone 5 you fall 3 years behind the tech curve.

4. The rumored improvements just don't impress me thus far -- used the iPad 2 and the original iPad, and I don't get the hype with the A5 processor. I didn't notice a gigantic speed difference between the two. Certainly not enough to warrant being excited over it's inclusion int he iPhone 5. And, as for the camera: the only photos I take with my phone are stupid things to put on twitter or send as texts to people. I don't need great detail as I take a candid shot of something funny happening at the store.
 
I've owned my 3GS since September of '09. It's in pretty good shape thanks to its case (I use a clear plastic Contour case). I've been really happy with it, and honestly, I've had no major issues with AT&T either. The biggest reasons for upgrading that I could see would be the camera and the display. Whenever I go into the Apple store and compare the 4 to my 3GS, I really see the difference in displays when I surf to the same web page side-by-side, or view photos. The rumors are an 8 megapixel camera for the 5, but I really can't see much else happening with that display- I'd be surprised if they unveiled a "Retina 2" with the iPhone 5, or even what kind of resolution bump would be feasible at this point.

I'm torn between upgrading it (I'm eligible in May) or keeping it and getting an iPad 2 instead. As I said, The biggest improvements that I see with the iPhone 4 are the camera and the display. The iPad 2 would mean I would spend less time on my iPhone, so the display wouldn't be such an issue. The camera is the biggest selling point for me- I own a dSLR, a point-and-shoot, and my phone, and honestly, for day-to-day stuff, my iPhone IS my camera. Improved image quality is a strong selling point for me with the 4.
 
I've owned my 3GS since September of '09. It's in pretty good shape thanks to its case (I use a clear plastic Contour case). I've been really happy with it, and honestly, I've had no major issues with AT&T either. The biggest reasons for upgrading that I could see would be the camera and the display. Whenever I go into the Apple store and compare the 4 to my 3GS, I really see the difference in displays when I surf to the same web page side-by-side, or view photos. The rumors are an 8 megapixel camera for the 5, but I really can't see much else happening with that display- I'd be surprised if they unveiled a "Retina 2" with the iPhone 5, or even what kind of resolution bump would be feasible at this point.

I'm torn between upgrading it (I'm eligible in May) or keeping it and getting an iPad 2 instead. As I said, The biggest improvements that I see with the iPhone 4 are the camera and the display. The iPad 2 would mean I would spend less time on my iPhone, so the display wouldn't be such an issue. The camera is the biggest selling point for me- I own a dSLR, a point-and-shoot, and my phone, and honestly, for day-to-day stuff, my iPhone IS my camera. Improved image quality is a strong selling point for me with the 4.

tired of waiting for apple to deliver a 4" screen and a design that doesn't "look like it took a bullet" when dropped (thanks for that one, Number 41!), i went ahead and ordered a 32gig iPad 2, to do all the mulimedia things that i deem the iphone too small to do. this affords me the ability to hold onto the 3GS for as long as it lasts.
 
Yep, it's definitely more ergonomic.

By the way, I think there are a few cases for iPhone 4 that make you phone have a similar shape to the 3Gs.

The problem with that for me though is I prefer a pouch for my phone which means a naked phone when out of the pouch. I haven't come close to finding a pouch that will take a 3GS with my old Incase Slider on it.

Mike
 
Much prefer the look of the 4 over the 3gs. However, it's not a comfortable phone - not to mention slippy -to hold when it's taken out of the case and I still think that the glass sandwich design is a terrible idea.

Yeah, I too think the 4 looks GREAT, but as you do, I hate how it feels.

Mike
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.