Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
You miss the point entirely. I'm trying to tell you that you're being too serious. If us "older" people could do things over, we'd make sure we enjoyed things more, but life happens, and at the time it's hard to know or think that. I'm certainly not implying your troubles are trivial. You have a chance to maybe be with your soulmate, but you're over-thinking everything, much like an "older" person might do. Act young, be young. Ride the bike, fall off the bike. Learn from mistakes, but take chances.

You're right, I did miss the point of your post, sorry :eek:. I guess I'm just one of those people who over-analyzes things and worries, ergo... this thread.

Sorry it was lost on you. If you really feel like something is unhelpful and irrelevant, then you could save some effort by ignoring it instead of trying to start a pissing match over it. But again, I'll chalk it up to inexperience on your part; that's still okay.
Would you mind explaining it to me better then?
I think if you'd bother to listen to those who've been where you are now, you might just get the knowledge you seek. I remember being in my 20's, and I'm sure -aggie- does, too. But he can speak for himself here:

I am listening to those who have been where I am now. Two have said it led them into long term and committed relationships, a few have said they would go for it, and others have said they wouldn't. Your post was a little ambiguous....saying "the answer is so very obvious". Doesn't seem to be the case to me, given the variation in responses.
 
I came here looking for opinions, not to be patronized. Would you care to explain it to me better then?

Okay, since you asked so nicely. :)

The housing situation is temporary - you said for one year. Even if you didn't say that, my guess is you didn't plan on spending the rest of your life living with the same 7 people.

Your situation with the girl is...well, we don't know, do we?

My suggestion to you is this: don't let it find its way into the "we'll never know" category. Nothing in this world - nothing - sucks harder than regret.

Almost nobody ever says, "Man, I wish twenty years ago I had never tried to go out with what's-her-name. I mean, we went out twice and she ended up moving out six months later!" Plenty of people say, "Man, I should have asked her out - it might have been good for only a few dates, but now I'll never know."

What's the best that could happen? You could date for a few years or more, maybe even get married. Sounds great to me, too - and I'm not being facetious. The worst that could happen? She shoots you down, or you go out on one or two bad dates, live together with a modest amount of discomfort around each other (after all, there are eight of you; pretty easy for the two of you to find others to occupy yourselves with to minimize the awkwardness, if it really came to that), or one of you moves out - but no biggie there, since you're all moving out in a year anyway, right?

Nothing ventured, nothing gained. Now, I'll apologize for not going into this level of detail earlier, but when I previously intimated that the answer was obvious, this is what I was thinking. If I wrongly assumed that you and I were on the same page with this, I'll eat my crow and move on. But don't fall victim to the regret of wondering what might have been; make your move and see what happens.
 
Got it: the girl is hot and you want confirmation to do what you want to do anyway.

who cares what anyone else thinks...do what your little head tells you. :rolleyes:
 
Okay, since you asked so nicely. :)

The housing situation is temporary - you said for one year. Even if you didn't say that, my guess is you didn't plan on spending the rest of your life living with the same 7 people.

Your situation with the girl is...well, we don't know, do we?

My suggestion to you is this: don't let it find its way into the "we'll never know" category. Nothing in this world - nothing - sucks harder than regret.

Almost nobody ever says, "Man, I wish twenty years ago I had never tried to go out with what's-her-name. I mean, we went out twice and she ended up moving out six months later!" Plenty of people say, "Man, I should have asked her out - it might have been good for only a few dates, but now I'll never know."

What's the best that could happen? You could date for a few years or more, maybe even get married. Sounds great to me, too - and I'm not being facetious. The worst that could happen? She shoots you down, or you go out on one or two bad dates, live together with a modest amount of discomfort around each other (after all, there are eight of you; pretty easy for the two of you to find others to occupy yourselves with to minimize the awkwardness, if it really came to that), or one of you moves out - but no biggie there, since you're all moving out in a year anyway, right?

Nothing ventured, nothing gained. Now, I'll apologize for not going into this level of detail earlier, but when I previously intimated that the answer was obvious, this is what I was thinking. If I wrongly assumed that you and I were on the same page with this, I'll eat my crow and move on. But don't fall victim to the regret of wondering what might have been; make your move and see what happens.

That makes more sense :)

Thank you.

I'm seeing her tomorrow night... let's see what happens ;)

Got it: the girl is hot and you want confirmation to do what you want to do anyway.
who cares what anyone else thinks...do what your little head tells you. :rolleyes:

Of course I'm not going to base my actions solely on the number of votes either way...but if everybody who posted gave accounts of themselves in this position, and it ending badly/not well, then it would certainly influence my decision.... and vice versa.

You can always find another house ;).

Not easily. I'm tied into a 12 month contract with the estate agents. Would be quite a lot of hassle to get out of that...plus I'd have to find a new roommate so I don't drop my friends in it with a larger rent. Plus.... I really like all the people I'll be living with.lol.
 
Date? Hell no.
Have no strings attached sex with her? Hell ya.

Seriously though, I probably would date her. The heart wants want the heart wants.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.