Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
WOW Big Red is busting heads.
- Thread starter Apollo 13
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Fernandez21
macrumors 601
I just looked at Verizon's site and the numbers don't seem much different from AT&T. A two-person family plan is $70 for 700 minutes. Add two unlimited data plans and that's another $60, which brings you to $130. Add two unlimited texting things and that's another $40, which is $170. If you go up to the 1400 minutes and the friends and family thing, then yeah it's $190 plus taxes and crap.
If you need two phones with that many minutes, all that data and unlimited texts, WHAT DO YOU EXPECT? Either don't talk so much or do talk so much and don't send 8,000 texts per day. If you're like my mom and can get by on less than 150MB of data per month, you can do the $15 plan for that. I barely top the 200MB that AT&T gives you for $15, so I went with the $25 plan.
I'm on AT&T, have both of my parents added. My mom has an iPhone, dad has some Sony thing. We have the cheapest voice plan, I have the $25 data and $5 texts, she just has $15 data. It's all about $120-125 for THREE PEOPLE. If you're nearing $200 for two phones, you might want to re-examine your usage or realize that that's how much it costs to do what you do.
If you need two phones with that many minutes, all that data and unlimited texts, WHAT DO YOU EXPECT? Either don't talk so much or do talk so much and don't send 8,000 texts per day. If you're like my mom and can get by on less than 150MB of data per month, you can do the $15 plan for that. I barely top the 200MB that AT&T gives you for $15, so I went with the $25 plan.
I'm on AT&T, have both of my parents added. My mom has an iPhone, dad has some Sony thing. We have the cheapest voice plan, I have the $25 data and $5 texts, she just has $15 data. It's all about $120-125 for THREE PEOPLE. If you're nearing $200 for two phones, you might want to re-examine your usage or realize that that's how much it costs to do what you do.
I dont see any consideration of what "Unlimited" means on each carrier.
I believe:
ATT is not unlimited but 2gig for new accounts.
VZ is not unlimited but 5 gig for new accounts.
Additional data charges on ATT could be a cost factor.
I believe:
ATT is not unlimited but 2gig for new accounts.
VZ is not unlimited but 5 gig for new accounts.
Additional data charges on ATT could be a cost factor.
ReallyBigFeet
macrumors 68030
Apollo 13 said:
And unfortunately, you are blind. It's been proven several times in this thread that Verizon and AT&T are virtually identical on pricing for the plan you want. There's no point in comparing either company to Tmo/Sprint/US Cellular or whatever since they don't carry the iPhone (yet).
Good catch and my bad. You get 2 lines included with both the Verizon and AT&T Family plans, unlimited talk on both for $119.99. Adding a third through fifth line on Verizon costs an additional $9.99 per line. Adding a third through fifth line on AT&T costs $49.99 per line. Which given how closely the two plans otherwise mimic one another, is a bit surprising. AT&T is far more expensive for a multi-line family plan than Verizon, but then again you do get the rollover minutes on AT&T that Verizon doesn't offer.
Last edited by a moderator:
Fernandez21
macrumors 601
Um, actually .......
http://www.verizonwireless.com:80/b...ion=viewFSPlanList&catId=323&sel=fam&typeId=2
You have to select the unlimited plan to see the price change, but Verizon does charge $49 per line after the first two on the unlimited plan, just like AT&T. The prices are the same, only differences are AT&T offers unlimited text (verizon is 5000 with unlimited m2m texting) and verizon has a 5gb cap while AT&T has 2gb.
Best bet for a cheap monthly plan with iPhone is to unlock and use on t-mobile without 3G.
Wicked1
macrumors 68040
One compelling reason I went to AT&T was Rollover. I have the 1400 Family plan with 4 lines, we usually use 400 min per month so rollover 1000, and every so often I use up the extra minutes on conference calls at work, but with Verizon if you have 1400 per month and only use 400 they get to keep the rest, really unfair.
Love AT&T and we all have iPhones, and the Unlimited TXT.
1400 Min plan 80
Unlimted Data iphone 30
Unlimited txt 30
3 iphones with the 9.99 add a phone and 25.00 data so add $105 plus the original 140 is 245 plus taxes minus discounts I pay 105 per month. my company pays the rest.
Which is exactly what I've been doing for the past year or so and can't complain. 🙂
$79.99 unlimited everything and no contract. And honestly, haven't had a dropped call with the same iPhone 4 I was using on AT&T and had literally 50+ dropped calls in the 1.5 months I was with them. Yeah, my data speeds are slightly slower and if I'm traveling I don't get data all the time, but with AT&T I was having a LOT more issues.
Sprint has been my favorite carrier to the present time, I had them for 5 years and had zero dropped calls, even on campouts in the mountains.
I'm hoping the Verizon iPhone can be 'unlocked' to work on Sprint, but I'm not holding my breath since CDMA technology can be a bit trickier than GSM when it comes to unlocking.
I'm still waiting to see if the Verizon plans change any for the iPhone but as they stand it isn't enough to sway me. It'd cost roughly $60/mo more for slightly better data and reception.
Geckotek
macrumors G3
I guess if I had a family plan w/ multiple users rollover minutes would be valuable.
For me, they are a waste. I'd gladly trade them for 3G service when I travel to visit family.
Counting your mom and dads income as your own doesn't count, LOL!
As numerous others have already pointed out, you just don't know what you're doing with the plans. I, like many others have come up with different prices (often equivalent) to AT&T.