Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
You did very well and it was close. You also made it to the end. I'm now waiting for all the comments "I knew it was Pluto".

This was a very strange game (based on QoS post)
Turn 1: DP protected himself. WW tried to eat DP. QoS tried to scan DP. WW meal and scan failed.
Turn 2: DP protected Pluto. WW tried to eat DP. QoS tried to scan Pluto. DP is eaten and the scan fails.

We had to eat Moyank right after she taunted me :D.

raven and pluto are WW
qos was seer
moyank was hunter
 
  • Like
Reactions: Meister
Pluto's vote for me wasn't random.
It was a clumsy attempt to distract from ravii.

I explained all this on day 4:

Sorry, but I have to lol at this.
And somebody who actually starts posting the forth day shouldn't pad himself on the back too hard I might add as that was what made his "distraction" possible to begin with - but you might know better.

Sorry comeagain, but I still stand by my choice. Can't go with my gut in such a situation and unfortunately you triggered some red flags too much for me.

Anyway, congrats to the bad guys. And sorry for losing it for the village. :(
 
Sorry comeagain, but I still stand by my choice. Can't go with my gut in such a situation and unfortunately you triggered some red flags too much for me.
Eh, I get it. By the time we could've done something it was already too late.

I like my first vote choice though. Was even tempted to continue that trend.
 
raven and pluto are WW
qos was seer
moyank was hunter

wow, and I thought it was DP

Pluto's vote for me wasn't random.
It was a clumsy attempt to distract from ravii.

I explained all this on day 4:

And as I explained on day 5: There was no reason to vote for comeagain.

As I posted, the vote was not a random vote but was a placeholder to get you to start posting :). If you played other games with Ravenvii, he always plays like that and most of the time he isn't a WW.

Comeagain? was a much more probable vote then Plutonius due to him missing a vote and then saving Ravenvii. That's a bigger reason to vote for someone rather than because someone voted for you :D. You did sniff me out though so good job in the game.
 
Eh, I get it. By the time we could've done something it was already too late.

I like my first vote choice though. Was even tempted to continue that trend.

Let's blame it on QoS. One day ago I was all over those two suckers! :D

And about your vote choice, I was like: Ok, now he talks like Pluto is worth saving but voted him asap Day 1. - Yep, figures " :D (albeit not that serious)
 
Is there anyone lined up to host the next one? I actually enjoy GGing much more than playing, and I'd like to do another more complicated one if there's enough people.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Meister
wow, and I thought it was DP



As I posted, the vote was not a random vote but was a placeholder to get you to start posting :). If you played other games with Ravenvii, he always plays like that and most of the time he isn't a WW.

Comeagain? was a much more probable vote then Plutonius due to him missing a vote and then saving Ravenvii. That's a bigger reason to vote for someone rather than because someone voted for you :D. You did sniff me out though so good job in the game.
I didn't vote for you as a retaliation vote, I merely interpreted the voting record.

My record was squeeky clean.
Ravii was the obvious choice.
Your vote for me was a obvious distraction.
The other villagers fell for it.

Well done! ;)
 
Let's blame it on QoS. One day ago I was all over those two suckers! :D

And about your vote choice, I was like: Ok, now he talks like Pluto is worth saving but voted him asap Day 1. - Yep, figures " :D (albeit not that serious)

By the time I thought about switching to Pluto it wouldn't have mattered. I got to two first and wouldn't have been able to convince you to switch off me.
 
By the time I thought about switching to Pluto it wouldn't have mattered. I got to two first and wouldn't have been able to convince you to switch off me.

I guess so. It was strange to see you voting for me though. I was quite sure you'd go after Pluto .
 
I guess so. It was strange to see you voting for me though. I was quite sure you'd go after Pluto .

I originally didn't know what to think, since none of us were cleared really. I only didn't immediately go for Pluto because of the assumption that DP was the hunter, and he'd trusted Pluto enough to protect him.
 
Apparently it says that in the rules on the first page, but I didn't do a very good job of protecting!

Sorry QOS!

Crikey. Mea culpa.

A quick read of the rules on page one has revealed that this is indeed how it was interpreted this game. Has that been the way it was played since forever?

Anyway, I followed this one - somewhat distantly - from the sidelines. Congrats WWs, commiserations villagers.
 
Last edited:
Crikey. Mea culpa.

A quick read of the rules on page one has revealed that this is indeed his it was interpreted this game. Has that been the way it was played since forever?

Anyway, I followed this one - somewhat distantly - from the sidelines. Congrats WWs, commiserations villagers.

no, it is not the usual way, although it might not be the first time it is done that way.
an interesting twist, which we payed dearly for :)
 
Re Night 2, I am curious as to how the scan (by QoS) on Plutonius was deemed to have failed, even though DP - the Hunter - - who protected Plutonius - was successfully attacked.

If DP was attacked, should the protection have remained in effect?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.