I hate to revive this thread, but I'm frustrated lol
So I have two hard drives in my macbook pro. An SSD running El Cap that I use as my main drive, and the original Toshiba HDD (in the optibay) which runs OS X Mavericks (as a "failsafe") and also acts as a scratch disk... all of this I say in my signature.
Both have active recovery partitions. I couldn't access recovery from my SSD at first because I have FileVault enabled, but after disabling it I was able to access it.
First issue:
Restarts and shutdowns don't "work" for whatever reason though. The screen will go black, and the mouse cursor will be there and it'll just hang forever until I force a shutdown. In Recovery OS, clicking "Restart" or "Shut Down" is futile too, as nothing happens and whatever window (Terminal, Recovery options list) stays. Every time getting out of Recovery, I had to force a shutdown by holding the power button, AND reset the PRAM because nothing would show up after turning the machine on. I need to go and zap the SMC too because the fan is running at max speed for no reason and all I have open right now is this tab in Safari and forums.macrumors.com in another.
Second issue:
Xtrafinder was issued an update to support El Cap on November 16th, and I found this out a couple of days ago (v0.25.7). I had to disable SIP – obviously – and did this with no problem... however, since nothing happened when I clicked on "Restart" in Recovery OS and ultimately had to force a shutdown and reset the PRAM, I reckon by doing that, I tripped up the change and it reverted back to being enabled... this is evident once I logged in, this lovely window showed up every time (see attached). The status also shows as "enabled" in Terminal when I check. There doesn't seem to be any way for me to enable it since the machine won't properly perform a restart/reboot when I tell it to. Something wrong with the logic board you think? It's definitely time for a new machine, I plan on buying myself a new rMBP for my birthday next year... custom configuration too haha. It'd be great if I can figure this mess out though.