Just following up here. I just spoke to Apple and they said that the express replacement is only valid if you go the repair process and Apple determines that there is defect or an issue. Thus this won't work since I'm sure my screen is within the spectrum of "acceptable." I thought it was a no questions asked policy but it's not.try express replacement through AppleCare. They will put a 1000$ hold on your CC and overnight you a new 12 pro.