My old nokia (non color screen, came with snake), my lg scoop, blackberry curve 3G, and my 3GS!
Image
No phone even comes close to that for me, could still easily use that phone now if I had it, though sadly some idiot I know lost it. Had everything I needed it to have though, 3G, great music player, great camera etc.
My Ranking
1. Apple iPhone 4
2. Nokia N82
3. Apple iPhone
4. Palm Pixi Plus
5. RIM BlackBerry Bold 9000
6. Sanyo SCP-5500
7. Nokia 3360
8. Motorola V600
9. Motorola RAZR V3
10. Sony Ericsson T616
11. Nokia 3595
12. Audiovox 91550GPX
13. Samsung A107
14. Qualcomm QCP-1960
Reception
1) Nokia
2) Motorola
3) Sanyo (thanks to CDMA)
Apps
1) Apple by far
Ecosystem
1) Apple by far
Customization
1) Any iPhone (if jailbroken)
2) N82
3) Bold 9000
Design
1) iPhone 4
2) iPhone
3) Bold 9000 (barely beating the Moto V600)
Ergonomics as a phone (comfort)
1) Pixi Plus
2) N82
3) 3360
Screen
1) iPhone 4
2) Bold 9000
3) iPhone
Camera
1) N82
2) iPhone 4
3) Pixi Plus
Video recorder
1) iPhone 4
2) N82
3) Pixi Plus
Music player
1) iPhone 4
2) Bold 9000
3) Pixi Plus
^^ No iPhone 2G because the speaker was way too soft.
Video player
1) iPhone 4
2) iPhone
3) Pixi Plus
Photo viewer
1) Any iPhone
2) Pixi Plus
3) Bold 9000
Web browsing
1) iPhone 4
2) iPhone
3) Pixi Plus
Notification system
1) Pixi Plus
2) Bold 9000
3) N82
Messaging (email or text)
1) Bold 9000
2) Pixi Plus
3) Any iPhone (never got into T9 with the Nokias)
Keyboard
1) Bold 9000
2) Pixi Plus
3) Any iPhone
Loud speaker
1) Bold 9000
2) N82
3) iPhone 4
Durability
1) Sanyo SCP-5500
2) Nokia 3360
3) iPhone (original)
Battery life
1) iPhone 4
2) Samsung A107
3. iPhone
Mobile OS
1) webOS
2) iOS
3) (Tied) Symbian or BB OS
I hope you work in the mobile phone industry. Otherwise, this is madness.
I don't know if anyone will remember them but I loved the old Motorola Startac phones. I work rough jobs and those damn things withstood a crap ton of accidents, plus they were just plain cool in my opinion. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_StarTAC
And of course my iPhone...
Even if he did, that is one impressive list. Kudos Savor.