Got my base 1.1 2 days ago.
I noticed UI lag immediately (not terrible, but enough to make you see dropped frames in animations), clean installing from internet recovery to 10.10.3 did not improve things, neither did 10.10.4 beta 3 or 4. I also setup as a new mac and did not transfer settings.
The only thing that has worked for the UI lag issue is reducing transparency.
From the numerous forums I've scanned, it appears many retina macbook owners, including 2015 pro models, suffer from the UI lag issue on Yosemite.
I do not think it is rMB hardware related, rather, an Intel and Apple driver issue.
Loving my new rMB. Best laptop I've ever used.
Let's hope Apple sort this out, as it ruins an otherwise sublime experience.
I tend to agree on all your points, based on my experience with 3 different retina MacBooks running clean installs of 10.10.3 and the various betas of 10.10.4, as well as my testing the latest MacBook Pro 13". I probably should have kept the MBP for a couple more weeks to really see how the UI lag compared to the rMB, but I got tired of testing things out.