Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Stick with the i7, the i9 is not a big improvement, and the chassis can't handle the thermals anyway so it throttles under max load, which would be the main point of having it. Also don't mix the RAM, it slows it down. Buy 64 and put that in, take out the original 8 that it came with. Also: 64 runs faster with 4x16 than 2x32, so if you don't think you'll want to upgrade to 128, then go with 4x16.

GAS? Never heard of it o_O But yeah, I've been going back and forth on whether to spend the additional $360 to make the jump from 8 core i7 to the 10 core i9 (I get the military discount). As much fun as it would be to have the i9, I will probably end up with the i7 but will go all the way on the graphics card. I think I would more likely buy the nano-texture screen for $400 since I'm a semi-serious amature photographer and want to get more into video too.



As long as the memory is user upgradable there is no way I would buy more than the minimum 8GB from Apple. My plan is to add two more 32GB sticks (OWC) for a total of 72 which will likely be as much as I'll ever need (well, never say never).
 
Stick with the i7, the i9 is not a big improvement, and the chassis can't handle the thermals anyway so it throttles under max load, which would be the main point of having it. Also don't mix the RAM, it slows it down. Buy 64 and put that in, take out the original 8 that it came with. Also: 64 runs faster with 4x16 than 2x32, so if you don't think you'll want to upgrade to 128, then go with 4x16.
Agreed. The i7 is much better. I have the i7 and it’s fantastic. Don’t waste your $400 on the i9.
 
It's not much better, just not much worse in most circumstances and marginally better in a few specific cases.
I meant much better for the price like as a decision for your purchase. Yes as far as performance I agree with you it’s not much of a difference at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jobinhosyntax
Yeah, I haven't experienced that previously either. When turning it on the fan spins up a tiny bit like I would expect it to do normally, but the screen remains completely black. And after roughly 30 seconds it shuts down.
I've tried every single thing known to man and talked to an Apple technician as well, but nothing worked. So called them up and asked them to ship a new unit, which they immediately agreed to. I should receive a new one within 1-2 weeks.

Just an odd coincidence ... when I received my new 2020 i7 5700XT last Monday, I immediately removed the 8GB Apple Ram and installed 64GB Crucial from my 2019 iMac, then plugged it in and powered it up. NOTHING ... no noise, no video ... DOA! I rechecked the power cable connections and memory seating and tried again ... and again ... still nothing. I was explaining to my wife my DOA situation and what I had done so far ... a fairly long discussion! Then, suddenly without me touching the computer during all of this ... the Apple logo appeared on the screen and it proceeded to boot up normally. It has been working great ever since ... I don't know what happened???

I did have one other issue discussed in another thread of the boot bar freezing after I migrated my old setup from a backup. That was fixed by a simple OS reinstall over the loaded system ... and as I said, it has been working great ever since, including a BootCamp Windows 10 installation with VMware Fusion on the same BootCamp installation.
 
The iMac does an extended power on self test (POST) when it detects the amount of RAM in the system has changed. This will only happen the first boot after changing RAM. This is why it took a long time to display the Apple logo after you changed the RAM and powered back on.
 
Just an odd coincidence ... when I received my new 2020 i7 5700XT last Monday, I immediately removed the 8GB Apple Ram and installed 64GB Crucial from my 2019 iMac, then plugged it in and powered it up. NOTHING ... no noise, no video ... DOA! I rechecked the power cable connections and memory seating and tried again ... and again ... still nothing. I was explaining to my wife my DOA situation and what I had done so far ... a fairly long discussion! Then, suddenly without me touching the computer during all of this ... the Apple logo appeared on the screen and it proceeded to boot up normally. It has been working great ever since ... I don't know what happened???

I did have one other issue discussed in another thread of the boot bar freezing after I migrated my old setup from a backup. That was fixed by a simple OS reinstall over the loaded system ... and as I said, it has been working great ever since, including a BootCamp Windows 10 installation with VMware Fusion on the same BootCamp installation.
When installing new ram the machine has to initialize the ram which takes a few minutes to do. That’s why you experienced the delay.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hfg
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.